KARL JASPERS FORUM
AN ELECTRONIC JOURNAL FOR TARGET ARTICLES
FOR AUTHORS WHO WISH TO DISCUSS THEIR WORK AFTER POSTING
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Herbert Muller, the editor of the Karl Jaspers Forum, has passed away at the age of 85, after a brief illness.
His family thanks all the paricipants in the Karl Jaspers Forum.
Your discussions stimulated his thinking on the brain/mind question, which gave him a great deal of pleasure over the past 12 years.
As some of you may be aware, only a few days before he passed away, Herbert completed the final revisions of his book
BRAIN IN MIND - ONTOLOGY BECOMES PRAGMATIC DESIGN IN THE UNSTRUCTURED.
The book will soon be published and distributed through Barnes & Noble.
The www.kjf.ca site will continue to be accessible in the near future, however we will not be updating any of the articles.
Muller Family
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
STATEMENT
OF PURPOSE
Editorial Policy
LINKS to other Web
Sites Of Interest
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
TABLE
OF CONTENTS
(most recent update
2 January 2010)
To read the texts, click on their titles. -
All texts remain open for commentary.
Conventions and abbreviations: TA Target Article; C Commentary; R Response or
additional note to the TA;
N Short Note; numbers in brackets refer to paragraphs :
square brackets [1] in articles
and responses, pointed brackets <1> in commentaries and notes.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
INDEX FOR TARGET ARTICLES 1 TO 29 AND THEIR DISCUSSION
ARTICLES 30 TO 59 INCLUDING SYMPOSIUM SEPTEMBER 2001
ARTICLES
60 TO 99
SHORT NOTES
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
TARGET
ARTICLE 100 :
TA 100 by Roulette William Smith : A TRANSPERSONAL APPROACH TO HELPING
UNKNOWINGLY NEEDY AND WORRIED WELL PERSONS :
AN EXAMPLE OF IN SITU DIAGNOSES AND FOLLOW-UP OF COMMON SENSE AND
ABERRANT COMMON SENSE IN POST-WORLD WAR II IN GERMANY (Sept / 15 December 2007) Biographical
note
COMMENTARIES
on TA 100 :
TA100 C1 by Liu Zhida : THE EXPLANATION
OF THE PICTURES PRESENTING THE CONFLICT CAUSED BY CROSSING A BRIDGE (12 / 22
Dec 2007) Chinese original
TA100 C2 by Stanley Krippner
: ( COMMON SENSE ) (3 / 22 Dec 2007)
TA100 C3 by Fred Abraham to Krippner,
C2 : ( COMMON SENSE ) (20 / 29 December 2007)
TA100 C4 by Herbert FJ Muller : THE DIAGNOSIS OF LACK
OF COMMON SENSE (29 Dec 2007 / 5 Jan 2008)
TA100 C5 by Frederick David Abraham : OPERATIONAL
DEFINITIONS : TRIAGE AND SOCIAL
SIGNIFICANCE (30 Dec 2007 / 5 Jan 2008)
TA100 C6 by Fred Abraham : ( COMMON SENSE ) (3 / 12 January 2008)
TA100 C7 by Herbert FJ Muller : POSTMODERNISM,
RELATIVISM, AND COMMON SENSE (RAYMOND BOUDON ON COMMON SENSE) (14 / 19 January
2008)
TA100 C8 by Herbert FJ Muller : COMMON SENSE AND
METAPHYSICS (JOHN R SEARLE AND HIS
COMMON SENSE) (29 Jan / 9 Febr 2008)
TA100 C9 by Serge Patlavskiy
: CAN COMMON SENSE BE AN OBJECT OF STUDY ? (8 / 16 Febr
2008)
TA100 C10 by Elizabeth Johnson-Kallos :
DEFINITION OF COMMON SENSE (15 / 23 February 2008)
TA100 C11 by John R Searle : JUST COMMON SENSE (1 / 23
February 2008)
TA100 C12 by David Papineau
(to C11, Searle) : ( COMMON
SENSE ) (21 Febr / 1 March 2008)
TA100 C13 by Bill Adams (to C11, Searle) : ( BRAIN
AND MIND ) (27 Febr / 1 March 2008)
TA100 C14 by Slavoj Hontela (to C11, Searle) : ( JOHN SEARLE AND THE SNEAKY
OCTOPUS ) (2 / 15 March 2008)
TA100 C15 by Serge Patlavskiy
(to C14, Hontela) : TYPES OR MECHANISMS ? (15 / 22 March 2008)
TA100 C16 by Maurioce McCarthy :
DEFINING COMMON SENSE
(17 / 22 March 2008)
TA100 C17 by Slavoj Hontela : (
QUESTIONS FOR PHYSISICSTS ) (27 March / 5 April 2008)
RESPONSES by
Roulette William Smith :
TA100 R1 to Krippner and Abraham
: ON FUNCTIONAL AND OPERATIONAL DEFINITIONS FOR ‘COMMON SENSE’ (28 Dec 2007 / 5
Jan 2008)
TA100 R2 to C4, Muller : ( THE DIAGNOSIS OF LACK OF
COMMON SENSE ) (14 / 19 January 2008)
TA100 R3 to several comments : ( COMMON
SENSE ) (21 / 29 March 2008)
*******************************************************************************************
TARGET
ARTICLE 101 :
TA101 by Ulrich Mohrhoff : THE TRANSPARENT BRAIN (18 / 29 December 2007)
COMMENTARIES
on TA 101 :
TA101 C1 by Herbert FJ Muller :
EXPERIENCE ENCOMPASSES MATTER (20 Dec 2007 / 5 Jan 2008)
TA101 C2 by Serge Patlavskiy
: WHICH REALITY WE PERCEIVE ? (29 Dec
2007 / 5 Jan 2008)
TA101 C3 by Herbert FJ Muller : QUESTIONS
OF TERMINOLOGY (14 / 22 March 2008)
TA101 C4 (to R2) by Herbert FJ Muller : STRUCTURING, FINDING, AND CONCEPTS’ TRICKS
(31 March / 5 April 2008)
TA101 C5 (to R3) by Herbert FJ Muller : STRUCTURING (23 / 31 May 2008)
RESPONSES by
Ulrich Mohrhoff :
TA101 R1 to C1 . Muller : ( THE TRANSPARENT BRAIN ) (9 / 15 March 2008)
TA101 R2 to C3, Muller : ( TERMINOLOGY ) (23 / 29 March 2008)
TA101 R3 to C4, Muller : ( STRUCTURING ) (17 / 24 May 2008)
TA101 R4 to C5, Muller : ( INEFFABLE
FULLNESS ) (30 June / 5 July 2008)
*******************************************************************************************
TARGET
ARTICLES 102, 103, and 104 :
TA104 by Ram Lakhan Pandey Vimal : PROTO-EXPERIENCES
AND SUBJECTIVE EXPERIENCES : INTEGRATION
OF CLASSICAL, QUANTUM, AND SUBQUANTUM EFFECTS (19 / 26 January 2008) .pdf
version .pdf version updated
26 Jan 2008 .pdf version updated 3
Febr 2008
COMMENTARIES
on TAs 103 and 103 :
TA 102-103 C1 by Philip Benjamin : CHAMPENROVF
THE CHIMP CHAMP (11 / 19 January
2008)
TA 102-103 C2 by Herbert FJ Muller : AN INITIAL
QUERY (15 / 19 January 2008)
TA 102-103-C3 by Herbert FJ Muller : CO-EVOLUTION ? (18 / 26 January 2008)
TA 102-104-C4 by Herbert FJ Muller : SUBJECTS AND BRAINS (27 Jan / 2 Feb 2008)
TA 102-104 C5 by Herbert FJ Muller : THE
BRAIN IN 0-D
EPISTEMOLOGY (4 / 9 Febr 2008)
TA 102-104 C6 by Herbert FJ Muller : THE BRAIN IN 0-D EPISTEMOLOGY (8 / 16 Febr 2008)
TA 102-104 C7 by Herbert FJ Muller : MIR VERSUS
WORKING-MIR (29 Febr / 8 March 2008)
TA 102-104 C8 by Herbert FJ Muller : PROBLEMS OF DUALISM (9 / 15 March 2008)
TA 102 C9 by Adhanom Andemicael : THE
NATURE OF TIME (9 / 12 December 2009)
RESPONSES by
Ram Lakhan Pandey Vimal :
TA 102-103-R1 to Benjamin : ( THANKS ) (11 / 19 January 2008)
TA 102-103 R2 to Wood : ( JASPERS REFERENCES ) (12
/ 19 January 2008)
TA 102-103 R3 to Muller (C2) : ( ON THE DE & PAL PROPOSAL ) (17 / 26
January 2008)
TA 102-104 R4 to C3, Muller : ( ON ENCOMPASSINGH
EXPERIENCE ) (26 Jan / 2 Feb 2008)
TA 102-104 R5 to C4, Muller : ( SUBJECTS AND
BRAINS ) (3 / 9 Febr 2008)
TA 102-104 R6 to C5, Muller : ( THE BRAIN IN 0-D
EPISTEMOLOGY )
TA 102-104 R7 to C7, Muller : ( THE BRAIN IN 0-D
EPISTEMOLOGY ) (28 Febr / 8 March 2008)
TA 102-104 R8 to C8, Muller : ( MIR VERSUS
WORKING-MIR ) (5 / 15 March 2008)
TA 102-104 R9 to C8, Muller : ( NIRVANA ) (12 / 22
March 2008)
TA 102-104 R10 (addition) : DEFINITION
OF CONSCIOUSNESS (3 / 9 August
2008)
*******************************************************************************************
TARGET
ARTICLE 105 :
COMMENTARIES
on TA 105 :
TA 105 C1 by Cr Alan Oliver : (
NEURAL NETWORKS AND BUDDHISM ) (2 / 9 Febr 2008)
TA 105 C2 by Peter Beamish : MIND DEFINITION (7 / 16 Febr 2008)
TA 105 C3 by Peter Beamish : IN DEFENCE OF A NEW “MIND
DEFINITION” USING REVERSE ‘CONCENTIONAL TIME’ (10 / 16 Febr
2008)
RESPONSES by
Ram Lakhan Pandey Vimal :
TA 105 R1 to Oliver, C1 : (
NEURAL NETWORKS AND BUDDHISM ) (7 / 16 Febr 2008 )
*******************************************************************************************
TARGET
ARTICLE 106 :
COMMENTARIES
on TA 106 :
TA 106 C1 by Serge Patlavskiy : IS IT NATURAL TO BE A NON-BELIEVER ? (29 Febr / 8 March
2008)
TA 106 C2 by Peter Schuster :
( DOES GOD EXIST ? ) (11 / 15 March 2008)
TA 106 C3 by Varadaraja V
Raman (to Schuster, C2) : ( DOES GOD EXIST ? ) (12 /
22 March 2008)
TA 106 C4 by Peter Beamish : RELATIVITY AND “OBJECTIVE
REALITY” (2c : TWICE THE SPEED OF LIGHT) (13 / 22 March 2008)
TA 106 C5 by Alain Chouinard
: SPEED
OF LIGHT (13 / 22 March 2008)
TA 106 C6 by Varadaraja V
Raman : ON DAWKINS (19 / 29 March 2008)
TA 106 C7 by Paul Roberts : ( ON DAWKINS ) (24 / 29 March 2008)
TA 106 C8 by Joseph S Johnson : IN
SEARCH OF MEANING (25 / 29 March 2008)
TA 106 C9 by Maurice McCarthy : THE GOD HYPOTHESIS NEEDS RECONCEIVING (24 /
29 March 2008)
TA 106 C10 by Joan Koss-Chioino,
Zvi Lothane, John Mikes,
Peter Schuster (to L Sundararajan) : ON GOD
(25 / 29 March 2008)
TA 106 C11 by
Varadaraja V Raman (to L Sundararajan)
: TOWARDS A DESCRIPTIVE DEFINITION OF
RELIGION (26 / 29 March 2008)
TA 106 C12 by Peter Beamish : ( QUESTIONS FOR PHYSICISTS
) [Relativity] (27 March / 5 April 2008)
TA 106 C13 by Pete Schuster, Santiago Cardoso, Elli Winer (to L Sundararajan)
(RELIGION AND DAWKINS) (1 / 5 April 2008)
TA 106 C14 by Louise Sundararajan
: ( WORK
AND RELIGION ) (7 / 12 April
2008)
TA 106 C15 by Varadaraja V
Raman : ULTIMATE ENTITIES (21 March / 12 April 2008)
TA 106 C16 by Robert A Segal : THE STRIVING IS ALL, on David K Kim : MELANCHOLIC FREEDOM (28 March / 19 April
2008)
TA 106 C17 by Varadaraja V
Raman ( ON SPEED OF LIGHT ) (9 / 19
April 2008)
TA 106 C18 by Peter Beamish : SPEED OF LIGHT (AND PEOPLE ) (9 / 19 April
2008)
TA 106 C19 by Robert Neil Boyd : EXCEEDING
THE SPEED OF LIGHT
(11 / 19 April 2008)
TA 106 C20 by Philip Benjamin : NEW AGE OR NEW
PHYSICALITY ? RIGHT OR AUTHORITY ?
DEFINITION OR DEDUCTION ? (17 / 26 April 2008)
TA 106 C21 by Peter Beamish (to Boyd) : THE VELOCITY (NOT “SPEED”) OF LIGHT (21 / 26
April 2008)
TA 106 C22 by Robert Neil Boyd (to Beamish) : (
SPEED OF
LIGHT ) (21 / 26 April 2008)
TA 106 C23 by Varadaraja V
Raman (to Benjamin, C20) : CRITERION OF
RELIGIOSITY (22 April / 3 May 2008)
TA 106 C24 by Zvi Lothane : (SPEED OF
LIGHT SOUR GRAPES) (22 April / 3 May 2008)
TA 106 C25 by Peter Beamish (to Boyd, C22) : THE VELOCITY OF LIGHT (22 April / 3 May 2008)
TA 106 C26 by Peter Beamish (to R9) : LIGHT VELOCITY “AND PEOPLE” (22 April / 3 May
2008)
TA 106 C27 by Maurice McCarthy : EVOLUTION AT PLAY (27 April / 3 May 2008)
TA 106 C28 by Peter Beamish (to R10) :
SUBJECT-INCLUSIVE RELARTIVITY (1 / 10 May 2008)
TA 106 C29 by Varadaraja V
Raman : THOUGHTS ON YOGA (3 / 10 May
2008)
TA 106 C30 by Philip Benjamin : ( EVOLUTION AND RELIGION ) (8 / 17 May 2008)
TA 106 C31 by Peter Beamish : ( SUBJECT-INCLUSIVE RELATIVITY WITHIN
EXPERIENCE ) (9 / 17 May 2008)
TA 106 C32 by Maurice McCarthy : EVOLUTION AND RELIGION (12 / 17 May 2008)
TA 106 C33 by Serge Patlavskiy
: DO WE REALLY NEED TO REINVENT THE IDEA
OF GOD ? (17 / 24 May 2008)
TA 106 C34 by Varadaraja V Raman
: ATTITUDES TO OTHER RELIGIONS : A
PERSONAL APPROACH (24 May/ 14 June 2008)
TA 106 C35 by Slavoj Hontela : ( GOD AND
CONSCIOUSNESS ) (8 / 16 August 2008)
TA 106 C36 by Serge Patlavskiy
to S Hontela and J Johnson : GODS AND CONSERVATION OF CONSCIOUSNESS (29
Aug / 6 Sept 2008)
TA 106 C37 by Michael Chumakin
: LOOKING FOR COMMON
GROUND (9 / 16 May 2009)
TA 106 C38 by Maurice McCarthy to M Chumakin (C37) :
FURTHERING COMMON GROUND (18 / 23 May 2009)
TA 106 C39 by Steven M Rosen to C37, Chumakin : (
MATERIALISM AND SCIENCE ) (13 / 22 August 2009)
TA 106 C40 by William A Adams, to R15, on Dawkins and
Collins : CRITICAL THINKING VS SCIENTISM
AND DOGMA (16 / 22 August 2009)
TA 106 C41 by Serge Patlavskiy
to C37, Chumakin, and R14 to Chumakin
: META-THEORY VS ONTOLOGY AND
METAPHYSICS (16 / 22 August 2009)
TA 106 C42 by Serge Patlavskiy
to Adams (C40 ) : IN WHICH SCIENCE
FIFFERS FROM RE;IGION ? (19 / 29 August 2009)
TA 106 C43 by WA Adams to S Patlavskiy
C42 : SCIENCE
DOES DIFFER FROM RELIGION (27 August / 5 Sept 2009)
TA 106 C44 by WA Adams to H Muller (R17) : NONDUAL KNOWING (4 / 12 Sept 2009)
TA 106 C45 by S Patlavskiy
to WA Adams, C43 : SCIENCE AND RELIGION
ARE “GENETICALLY” COMPATIBLE (6 /12 September 2009)
TA 106 C46 by WA Adams to SPatlavskiy
(C45) : ARE ALL EXPLANATIONS EQUIVALENT
? (10 / 19 Sept 2009)
TA 106 C47 by HZ Lothane to Patlavskiy : RELIGION AND SCIENCE (12 / 19 Sept 2009)
TA 106 C48 by S Patlavskiy
to H Muller : CAN NOUMENAL REALITY BE
THOUGHT ABOUT ? (13 / 19 Sept 2009)
TA 106 C49 by P Benjamin to Lothane,
C47 : RELIGION
AND SCIENCE (15 / 26 Sept 2009)
TA 106 C50 by WA Adams to R19 by Muller : TWO KINDS OF
DUALISM (16 / 26 Sept 2009)
TA 106 C51 by S Patlavskiy
to Adams, C46 : WHAT IS
CONSESNSUS-GENERATING DE FACTO ? (17 / 26 Sept 2009)
TA 106 C52 by Ken Bausch : RELIGION AS ATTRACTOR, PROCESS, AND BIOLOGY
(20 / 29 Sept 2009)
TA 106 C53 by F Abraham : CRITICAL PHILOSOPHY (23 Sep / 3 Oct 2009)
TA 106 C54 by HZ Lothane (to
Benjamin) : RELIGION (23 Sep / 3 Oct
2009)
TA 106 C55 by WA Adans to Patlavskiy (C51) :
SCIENTIST DISCOVERED TO HAVE NO BODY (24 Sep / 3 Oct 2009)
TA 106 C56 by Phil Benjamion
to HZ Lothane C47 :
SPIRITUALITY AND PSYCHOLOGY (25 Sep / 3 Oct 2009)
TA 106 C57 by WA Adams to HF Muller R21 : ARE WE NOT DEMI-URGES ? (27 sep / 3 Oct 2009)
TA 106 C58 by S Barnett to Adams C50 : SUBJECTIVE EXPERIENCES WITHOUT SUBJECTS; OBSERVATIONS WITHOUT OBSERVERS (28 Sep / 3
Oct 2009)
TA 106 C59 by WA Adams to Muller, R22 : END OF THE ROAD (30 Sept / 3 Oct 2009)
TA 106 C60 by P Roberts to Muller et al : (MIND-INDEPENDENT REALITY) (30 Sept / 3 Oct
2009)
TA 106 C61 by S Patlavskiy
to R20, Muller : THE OBVIOUS CONFLICT OF
INTERESTS (1 / 3 October 2009)
TA 106 C62 by S Patlavskiy
to C55, Adams : FINAL CONSIDERATIONS (1
/ 3 Oct 2009)
TA 106 C63 by WA Adams to Barnett, C58 : CURSE OF THE ZOMBIE OBSERVER (2 / 17 October
2009)
TA 106 C64 Adams to Muller, R23 : MOONBEAMS R US (3 / 17 October 2009)
TA 106 C65 Adams to Patlavskiy
: WHAT ARE THE FACTS ? (4 / 17 October 2009)
TA 106 C66 Baranett to Adams
C63 : ZOMBIES’ BOOGALOO
(7 / 17 October 2009)
TA 106 C67 Patlavskiy to
Adams C65 : A POSSIBLE COMPROMISE (14 /
24 October 2009)
TA 106 C68 CM Taylor and J Habermas
: RELIGIOUS AND SECULAR ETHICS
TA 106 C69 Harwood Fisher : PRE-STRUCTURED VERSUS RE-CONFIGURABLE
OBJECTS, AND THEIR RELATION TO THE TERMS OFETHICAL THEORIES (11/19 Dec 2009)
TA 106 C70 Henry (Zvi) Lothane : ( DEUS
SIVE NATURA ) (12/19 Dec 2009)
RESPONSES by Herbert FJ Muller :
TA 106 R1 (addition to TA106) :
UNDERSTANDING NATURE [Peter Dear] (11 / 15 March 2008)
TA 106 R2 to Patlavskiy (C1)
: ABSOLUTE AND WORKING BELIEFS (6 / 15
March 2008)
TA 106 R3 to Beamish& Chouinard
: SOME
QUESTIONS FOR PHYSICISTS [Relativity] (16 / 29 March 2008)
TA 106 R4 to Schuster and Raman : COMMENTS
ON DAWKINS’ BOOK (17 / 22 March 2008)
TA 106 R5 to Cardoso (C13) : WORK
AND RELIGION (1 / 5 April 2008)
TA 106 R6 to Peter Beamish (C12) : SPEED
OF LIGHT AND
PEOPLE (2 / 12 April 2008)
TA 106 R7 to Joseph S Johnson : THE METAPHYSICS BOOMERANG : CONVERSION INTO A MORE USEFUL TOOL (5 / 19
April 2008)
TA 106 R8 to Maurice McCarthy : INDIVIDUALS
AND GUIDELINES (7 / 19 April 2008)
TA 106 R9 to Raman, Beamish, Boyd : THE SPEED OF LIGHT AND PEOPLE : FINDING VERSUS STANDARD (16 / 26 April 2008)
TA 106 R10 to Beamish, C26 : SUBJECT-INCLUSIVE RELATIVITY : STRUCTURES IN MIND, NOT MIND IN STRUCTURES
(27 April / 3 May 2008)
TA 106 R11 to McCarthy, C27 : EVOLUTION AND RELIGION (1 / 10 May 2008)
TA 106 R12 to Beamish (C28) : SUBJECT-INCLUSIVE RELATIVITY WITHIN
EXPERIENCE (4 / 10 May 2008)
TA 106 R13 :
CHRISTIANITY AND EVOLUTION
(18 / 24 May 2008)
TA 106 R14 to Chumakin
: MATERIALISM AND SCIENCE (12 May / 15
August 2009)
TA 106 R15 (Addition) : GOD
VS SCIENCE (Dawkins, Collins, Whittenberger) (5
Nov 2006 / 15 Aug 2006)
TA 106 R16 to Rosen (C39) : STRUCTURING IN THE UNSTRUCTURED (15 / 29
August 2009)
TA 106 R17 to WA Adams, C40 : THE UNSTRUCTURED ORIGIN (17 Aug / 5 Sept
2009)
TA 106 R18 to S Patlavskiy,
C41 : ON MATERIALISM (21 Aug / 12 Sept 2009)
TA 106 R19 to Adams (C44) : UNDERSTANDING, FAMILIARITY, AND EVIDENCE (5 /
19 Sept 2009)
TA 106 R20 to Patlavskiy C48
: REQUEST FOR CLARIFICATION (15 /26 Sept
2009)
TA 106 R21 to Adams (C50) : PRAGMATIC DISTANCING (18 / 26 Sept 2009)
TA 106 R22 to Adams C57 : WE ARE REALITY-DESIGNERS (27 Sept / 3 Oct
2009)
TA 106 R23 to Adams C59 and Roberts C60 : QUERIES FROM LEFT AND RIGHT (1 / 3 October
2009)
TA 106 R24 to Patlavskiy
(C61) and Adams (C64) : ON BLACK CATS
AND MOON-BEAMS (15 / 24 October 2009)
TA 106 R25 to Taylor and Habermas
(C68) : MORALS AND THE UNSTRUCTURED
MATRIX (3 / 12 December 2009)
TA 106 R26 to Fisher (C68) : THE
WAY FROM HERE (28 Dec 2009 / 2 Jan 2010)
*******************************************************************************************
TARGET
ARTICLE 107 :
COMMENTARIES
on TA 107 :
TA 107 C1 by Joseph McCard : (
CEZANNE’S SPACE ) (23 / 31 May 2008)
TA 107 C2 by Donald Mender : ( BRIDGING THE ‘TWO
CULTURES’ : MERLEAU-PONTY AND THE CRISIS
IN MODERN PHYSICS ) (27 / 31 May 2008)
TA 107 C3 by Donald Mender (to R2) : ( SUBJECT AND
OBJECT ) (31 May/7June 2008)
TA 107 C4 by Herbert FJ Muller : THE 0-D ONTOLOGY
INSTRUMENT (1 / 7 June 2008)
TA 107 C5 by Herbert FJ Muller (to R4):
SUBJECT-INCLUSIVE EPISTEMOLOGY AND META-PHENOMENAL DESIGN (10 / 14 June 2008)
TA 107 C6 by Steve Bindeman :
( MERLEAU-PONTY AND THE CRISIS
IN MODERN SCIENCE ) (16 / 21 June 2008)
TA 107 C7 by Zvi Lothane : (
MATERIALISM AND MINDFULNESS ) (17 / 21 June 2008)
TA 107 C8 by Louise Sundararajan
: BRIDGING THE “TWO CULTURES” : MERLEAU-PONTY AND THE CRISIS IN MODERN
PHYSICS (8 / 16 August 2008)
TA 107 C9 by Lloyd Gilden
: ON Steven M Rosen : BRIDGING THE “TWO CULTURES” : MERLEAU-PONTY AND THE CRISIS IN MODERN
PHYSICS (13 / 16 August 2008)
RESPONSES by
Steven M Rosen :
TA 107 R1 to Joseph McCard : (
PHYSICS AND ACTION ) (30 May / 7 June 2008)
TA 107 R2 to Donald Mender (C2) : ( MERLEAU-PONTY AND
PHYSICS ) (30 May / 7 June 2008)
TA 107 R3 to Donald Mender (C3) : ( TOPOLOGY ) (31 May
/ 7 June 2008)
TA 107 R4 to Herbert FJ Muller (C4) : (
SUBJECT-INCLUSIVE EPISTEMOLOGY ) (8 / 14
June 2008)
TA 107 R5 to Steven Bindeman
(C6) : ( KLEIN BOTTLE )
(19 / 29 June 2008)
TA 107 R6 to Louise Sundararajan
(C8) : ( EMOTION AND KLEIN BOTTLING
) (12 / 16 August 2008)
*******************************************************************************************
TARGET
ARTICLE 108 :
COMMENTARIES
on TA 108 :
TA 108 C1 by Herbert FJ Muller : FROM
EXCLUSION TO INCLUSION OF
SUBJECTS ; REVOLUTION BY
INSTALMENTS (4 / 14 June 2008)
TA 108 C2 by Gregory Nixon : ( DIVINE RECIPE ) (4 / 14 June 2008)
TA 108 C3 by Serge Patlavskiy
: THE LAWS OF
CONSCIOUSNESS COMPARED (6 / 14
June 2008)
TA 108 C4 by Joseph S Johnson : THE
MEANING OF REVOLUTION
(14 / 21 June 2008)
TA 108 C5 by Joseph McCard
: THE
GOSPEL ACCORDING TO
JANE ROBERTS (16 / 21 June 2008)
TA 108 C6 Joseph S Johnson to Joseph McCard :
REVOLUTION FOR SURVIVAL (21
/ 28 June 2008)
TA 108 C7 Serge Patlavskiy to
Joseph Johnson : REJECTING EPIPHENOMENA
(28 June / 5 July 2008)
TA 108 C8 Joseph S Johnson to Serge Patlavskiy
: NATURAL ORDER, NATURAL LAW (15 July /
16 August 2008)
TA 108 C9 Serge Patlavskiy to Joseph Johnson : ON
MATERIALISM, TRIALISM, AND
NATURAL LAW (14 / 23 August 2008)
TA 108 C10 Joseph S Johnson to Serge Patlavskiy :
EXEMPLARS OF CONSCIOUSNESS (25 / 30 August 2008)
*******************************************************************************************
TARGET
ARTICLE 109 :
COMMENTARIES
on TA 109 :
TA 109 C1 by Felix Holmgren : ( BUDDHIST
EPISTEMOLOGY ) (3 July / 2 August
2008)
TA 109 C2 Muller to Bhatt and Holmgren : THE MIND-BRAIN PUZZLE AND BUDDHIST AND
WESTERN EPISTEMOLOGIES (26 July / 9 August 2008)
TA 109 C3 by A Priya : QUESTIONS
ABOUT NAGARJUNA (31 July / 9 August 2008)
TA 109 C4 Muller to Priya
: ON NAGARJUNA’S EPISTEMOLOGY (5 / 16
August 2008)
TA 109 C5 Muller :
NIRVANA VERSUS METAPHYSICS
(25 / 30 August 2008)
TA 109 C6 Rob Weedon : COMMENTING ON BUDDHISM (5 / 15 November 2008)
TA 109 C7 William A Adams : ABIDHAMMIC
PERCEPTION (16 / 22 November 2008)
TA 109 C8 Felix Holmgren, review of Mark Siderits : BUDDHISM
AS PHILOSOPHY (13 June 2008, posted 28
February 2009)
TA 109 C9 Varadaraja V Raman
: CULTURE AND SCIENCE : IN THE INDIAN CONTEXT (4 April / 30 May 2009)
*******************************************************************************************
TARGET
ARTICLE 110 :
[ MIND AND
METAPHYSICS ]
COMMENTARIES
on TA 110 :
TA 110 C1 by Herbert FJ Muller : A
WAY OUT OF
PLATO’S CAVE (6 / 13 September 2008)
TA 110 C2 by Simon Blackburn : FROZEN IN TIME (on The Mind
In Nature by C B Martin) (12 Sept / 4 October 2008)
TA 110 C3 by Herbert FJ Muller (to C2, Blackburn)
: THINGS
WITHOUT ONTOLOGY (28 Sept / 4 October 2008)
TA 110 C4 by Herbert FJ Muller (to C2, Blackburn and C.B.Martin) :
REALITY-DESIGN VERSUS CONTEMPORARY
- AND TEMPORARY
- METAPHYSICS-ONTOLOGY. SOME
QUESTIONS RAISED BY READING C.B. MARTIN’S ‘MIND
IN NATURE’ (20 / 25 October 2008)
TA 110 C5 by Herbert FJ Muller : DENIAL
OF SUBJECTIVITY VIA
MATERIALISM (DENNETT) (10 / 15
November 2008)
TA 110 C6 by Herbert FJ Muller : NATURAL
METAPHYSICS, REALITY WITHOUT
PEOPLE - Alexander Bird, reviewed by Helen Beebee (24 / 29
November 2008)
TA 110 C7 by Herbert FJ Muller : ON EMBODIMENT
(NATURAL STRUCTURE, LAKOFF AND
JOHNSON) (29 Nov / 6 Dec 2008)
TA 110 C8 by Herbert FJ Muller : THE
LAW OF RELAPSE
INTO MIR-BELIEF (2 / 6 Dec 2008)
TA 110 C9 by Harwood Fisher : EMBODIMENT AND CAUSAL PATTERNS (3 / 13 December 2008)
TA 110 C10 by Herbert FJ Muller : ON
EMBODIMENT (as discussed in Mark Johnson’s ‘Meaning the Body’) (12 / 20 December 2008)
TA 110 C11 by William A Adams (to C10): PURPOSE OF THE BODY (18 / 27 December 2008)
TA 110 C12 by Slavoj Hontela to HF Muller :
ON EMBODIMENT AND NATURAL STRUCTUREE (12 Nov 2008 / 3 Jan 2009)
TA 110 C13 by Herbert FJ Muller to S Hontela, C12 : ON
MIND AND
METAPHYSICS (28 Dec 2008 / 3 Jan 2009)
TA 110 C14 by Richard Moodey
: ON EMBODIMENT (2 / 7 Febr 2009)
TA 110 C15 by William A Adams (to Moodey,
C14) : THE BODY AS MENTAL CONSTRUCT (5
/ 14 February 2009)
TA 110 C16 by Herbert FJ Muller (to Moodey, C14, and Freeman, C17) : ON EMBODIMENT (6 / 14 Febr 2009)
TA 110 C17 by Margaret Freeman (to Muller, C10) : ( ON EMBODIMENT ) (9 / 14 Febr.
2009)
TA 110 C18 by Harwood Fisher (to Moodey
and others) : ON EMBODIMENT (11 / 21 Febr 2009)
TA 110 C19 by Richard Moodey
(to Freeman) : (ON EMBODIMENT) (13 / 21 Febr 2009)
TA 110 C20 by Richard Moodey
(to Adams) : THE BODY AS MENTAL
CONSTRUCT (13 / 21 Febr 2009)
TA 110 C21 by Richard Moodey
(to Fisher) : ON EMBODIMENT (18 / 28 Febr 2009)
TA 110 C22 by William A Adams (to Moodey,
C20) THE BODY AS MENTAL CONSTRUCT (20 /
28 Febr 2009)
TA 110 C23 by Paul Roberts to Adams and Moodey : (
EVOLUTION AND PROPAGATION )
(23 / 28 Febr 2009)
TA 110 C24 by Harwood Fisher (to Moodey,
C21) : ( ON EMBODIMENT ) (23 / 28 Febr 2009)
TA 110 C25 by Richard Moodey
(to Adams, C22) : THE BODY AS
MENTAL CONSTRUCT (25 / 28 Febr 2009)
TA 110 C26 by Richard Moodey
(to Roberts, C23) : ( EVOLUYION AND
PROPAGATION ) (25 Febr / 7 Mar 2009)
TA 110 C27 by Richard Moodey (to
Fisher, C24) : ( ON EMBODIMENT ) (25 Febr / 7 Mar 2009)
TA 110 C28 by Harwood Fisher (to Moodey,
C27) : ( AGENCY ) (2 / 7 March 2009)
TA 110 C29 by Richard Moodey
(to Fisher, C28) : ( AGENCY ) ( 8 / 14 March 2009 )
*******************************************************************************************
TARGET
ARTICLE 111 :
COMMENTARIES
on TA 111 :
TA 111 C1 by Herbert FJ Muller : GROUND
RULES FOR ACCESS TO
CONSCIOUSNESS (1 / 8 November 2008)
TA 111 C2 by Rob Weedon
: THE
GUV’NOR (5 / 15 November 2008)
TA 111 C3 by Herbert FJ Muller to Beamish and Patlavskiy : ACCESS
TO CONSCIOUSNESS (10 / 22 November 2008)
TA 111 C4 by Serge Patlavskiy
: NOTHING CAN “BE SEEN” AS
MIND-INDEPENDENT (9 / 15 November 2008)
TA 111 C5 by Serge Patlavskiy
: CONSERVATION OF “SOMTHINGNESS” AND
“NOTHINGNESS” (23 / 29 November 2008)
TA 111 C6 by Adrian Klein and R N Boyd : REALITY IS NEITHER ABSURD NOR PARADOXICAL (3
/ 13 December 2008)
TA 111 C7 by Herbert FJ Muller : SPACE-TIME :
ANAXIMANDER, HERAKLEITOS, MINKOWSKI
- BUT WHO COUNTS
? (30 Nov / 13 Dec 2008)
TA 111 C8 by Herbert FJ Muller : CONCERNING TIME AND REALITY (11 / 20 December
2008)
TA 111 C9 by Robert N Boyd : ( REALITY IS NEITHER ABSURD NOR PARADOXICAL )
(17 / 27 December 2008)
TA 111 C10 by Herbert FJ Muller : CONCERNING TIME AND REALITY (19 / 27 December
2008)
TA 111 C11 by Herbert FJ Muller : CONCERNING TIME AND REALITY (23 Dec 2008 / 3
Jan 2009)
TA 111 C12 by Herbert FJ Muller : CONCERNING TIME AND REALITY (31 Dec 2008 / 10
Jan 2009)
RESPONSES by
Peter Beamish :
TA 111 R1 to Muller : Re GROUND RULES FOR ACCESS TO CONSCIOUSNESS
(6 / 15 November 2008)
TA 111 R2 to Pande : QM
TIME (9 / 15 November 2008)
TA 111 R3 to Weedon : Re. The GUV’NOR (12 / 22 November 2008)
TA 111 R4 to Kanda :
FASTER THAN THE
SPEED OF LIGHT (19 / 22 November 2008)
TA 111 R5 to Muller : ACCESS TO CONSCIOUSNESS (20 ? 29
November 2008)
TA 111 R6 to Patlavskiy
: CONSERVATION (27 Nov / 6 Dec 2008)
TA 111 R7 to Klein, Boyd, Muller : ( REALITY IS NEITHER ABSURD NOR PARADOXICAL )
(4 / 20 Dec 2008)
TA 111 R8 to Boyd :
UNIFICATION OF TIME WITH GRAVITATION AND ELECTROMAGNETISM (15 / 20
December 2008)
TA 111 R9 to Kanda :
SCALARS (16 / 20 Dec 2008)
TA 111 R10 to Muller (C8) : CONCERNING TIME AND REALITY (18 / 27 December
2008)
TA 111 R11 to Muller (C10) : CONCERNING TIME AND REALITY (23 Dec 2008 / 3
Jan 2009)
TA 111 R12 to Muller (C11) : CONCERNING TIME AND REALITY (31 Dec 2008 / 10
Jan 2009)
TA 111 R13 (addition) : CONCERNING TIME AND REALITY (31 Dec 2008 / 10
Jan 2009)
TA 111 R14 to Muller C12 : ( MIND )
8 / 17 January 2009
*******************************************************************************************
TARGET
ARTICLE 112 :
COMMENTARIES
on TA 112 :
TA 112 C1 by William Byers : ( MATHEMATICAL THINKING ) (6 / 14 Febr 2009)
TA 112 C2 by Harwood Fisher : ( EMBODIMENT
AND REIFICATION ) (23 / 28 Febr 2009)
TA 112 C3 by Michael Schwartz to R2 : I AND
EXISTENCE (25 / 28 Febr 2009)
TA 112 C4 by Richard Moodey
to R2 : ( THEISM AND CONSTRUCTION ) (25
/ 28 Febr 2009)
TA 112 C5 by Harwood Fisher to R3 : ( EMBODIMENT AND REIFICATION ) (2 Febr / 7 Mar 2009)
TA 112 C6 by Harwood Fisher to R4 : ( STRUCTURE OR PERISH ) (3 /
7 March 2009)
TA 112 C7 by Richard Moodey
to R5 : ( THEISM AND CONSTRUCTION ) (10
/ 14 March 2009)
TA 112 C8 by Richard Moodey
to R7 : ( THEISM AND CONSTRUCTION ) (17
/ 28 March 2009)
TA 112 C9 by Richard Moodey
to R8 : ( EVOLUTION, OBJECTIVITY,
AND REALITY-DESIGN ) (25 March /
4 April 2009)
TA 112 C10 by Richard Moodey
to R7[6] : ( CRITICAL
REA;LISM AND RELIGION ) (26 March / 4 April 2009)
TA 112 C11 by Richard Moodey
further to C9 : (EVOLUTION, OBJECTIVITY,
AND REALITY-DESIGN) (2 / 11 April 2009)
TA 112 C12 by Richard W Moodey
(to R10) : ON ALVA NOE (11 / 18 April 2009)
TA 112 C13 by William A Adams (to Moodey,
C12) NOË, GIBSON AND REPRESENTATIONALISM (17 / 25 April 2009)
TA 112 C14 by Shakti Sharma : ( SELF-STRUCTURING, SOUL, AND DEATH ) (28
April / 9 May 2009)
TA 112 C15 by Fred Abraham : ( PARMENIDES
AND GORGIAS ) (4 / 14 November 2009)
RESPONSES by
Herbert FJ Muller :
TA 112 R1 (to C1, Byers) :
DREAM OF REASON (9 / 20 Febr 2009)
TA 112 R2 (to Fisher and Moodey,
discussion of TA110) : EMBODIMENT AND REIFICATION (AND PF STRAWSON’S NEO-METAPHYSICS) (21 / 28 Febr.
2009)
TA 112 R3 (to Fisher, C2) : EMBODIMENT
AND REIFICATION (25 / 28 Febr 2009)
TA 112 R4 (to Fisher, C5 and Schwartz, C3) : STRUCTURE OR PERISH (3 / 7 March 2009)
TA 112 R5 (to Moodey, C4)
: THEISM AND CONSTRUCTION
(8 /14 March 2009)
TA 112 R6 (to Fisher, C6) : STRUCTURE
OR PERISH (8 / 14 March 2009)
TA 112 R7 (to Moodey, C7)
: THEISM
AND THE UNSTRUCTURED
- WHOSE PURPOSE
AND CONCERN ? (14 / 21 March 2009)
TA 112 R8 (to Moodey, C7)
: THEISM
AND CONSTRUCTION (17 / 28 March
2009)
TA 112 R9 (addition) :
0-D AND HEIDEGGER’S METAPHYSICS
(24 / 28 March 2009)
TA 112 R10 (to Moodey, C11)
: EVOLUTION, OBJECTIVITY, AND
REALITY-DESIGN (7 / 11 April 2009)
TA 112 R11 (to Adams, C13) : SELF-STRUCTURING : ON ALVA NOË’S ENACTIVISM
(28 Apr / 2 May 2009)
TA 112 R12 (to Sharma, C14) : MIND AND SOUL
(1 / 9 May 2009)
TA 112 R13 (Addition by Evan Thompson) :
SENSORIMOTORISTS (Review of books by Andy Clark and Alva Noe)
(26 June / 8 August 2009)
TA 112 R14 (Addition to R9) : THE GODDESS OF PARMENIDES AND THE BEING OF
HEIDEGGER (3 / 7 Nov 2009)
*******************************************************************************************
TARGET
ARTICLE 113 :
COMMENTARIES
on TA 113 :
TA 113 C1 by Fritz G. Wallner : CULTURE
AND SCIENCE. THE METHODOLOGICAL APPROACH (2004 / 14 March 2009)
TA 113 C2 by Zvi Lothane : ( C’EST LA
METHODE ) (10 / 14 March 2009)
TA 113 C3 by Herbert FJ Muller : WALLNER’S CONSTRUCTIVE
REALISM AND ZERO-DERIVATION (0-D) STRUCTURING (6 / 11 April 2009)
TA 113 C4 by Herbert FJ Muller : TAO
AND THE UNSTRUCTURED (25 April / May 2009)
TA 113 C5 by Herbert FJ Muller : THE UNSTRUCTURED IN EASTERN EPISTEMOLOGY (12
/ 16 May 2009)
*******************************************************************************************
TARGET
ARTICLE 114 :
COMMENTARIES
on TA 114 :
*******************************************************************************************
TARGET
ARTICLE 115 :
COMMENTARIES
on TA 115 :
TA 115 C1 by Gary Schuborg
: ( BELIEF, FAITH, RELIGION ) (28 May /
13 June 2009)
TA 115 C2 by Maurice
McCarthy : PSYCHE AND
PNEUMA ( 13 / 20 June 2009)
TA 115 C3 by Maurice McCarthy : APOLOGY
(27 June / 4 July 2009)
RESPONSES by
Zvi Lothane :
TA 115 R1 to McCarthy (C2) : ( DISCUSSION ) (18 / 27 June 2009)
TA 115 R2 to McCarthy (C3) : (THANKS)
(2 July / 8 August 2009)
*******************************************************************************************