KARL JASPERS FORUM
AN ELECTRONIC JOURNAL FOR TARGET ARTICLES
FOR AUTHORS WHO WISH TO DISCUSS THEIR WORK AFTER POSTING
All original www.kjf.ca content is available below the following notice. Please scroll down to see journal articles.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
January 2010
Herbert Muller, the editor of the Karl Jaspers Forum, has passed away at the age of 85, after a brief illness.
His family thanks all the participants in the Karl Jaspers Forum.
Your discussions stimulated his thinking on the brain/mind question, which gave him a great deal of pleasure over the past 12 years.
The www.kjf.ca site will continue to be accessible in the foreseeable future for your reference, however we will not be updating articles any further.
Only a few days before he passed away, Herbert completed the final draft of his book:
BRAIN IN MIND
ONTOLOGY BECOMES PRAGMATIC DESIGN IN THE UNSTRUCTURED
The book has been published and is distributed through Barnes & Noble's iUniverse.
You can order it online here
A book review has been published Feb 10, 2011
The Muller Family
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
STATEMENT
OF PURPOSE
Editorial Policy
LINKS to other Web
Sites Of Interest
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
TABLE
OF CONTENTS
(most recent update
2 January 2010)
To read the texts, click on their titles. -
All texts remain open for commentary.
Conventions and abbreviations: TA Target Article; C Commentary; R Response or
additional note to the TA;
N Short Note; numbers in brackets refer to paragraphs :
square brackets [1] in articles
and responses, pointed brackets <1> in commentaries and notes.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
INDEX FOR TARGET ARTICLES 1 TO 29 AND THEIR DISCUSSION
ARTICLES 30 TO 59 INCLUDING SYMPOSIUM SEPTEMBER 2001
ARTICLES
60 TO 99
SHORT NOTES
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
TARGET
ARTICLE 100 :
TA 100 by Roulette William Smith : A TRANSPERSONAL APPROACH TO HELPING
UNKNOWINGLY NEEDY AND WORRIED WELL PERSONS :
AN EXAMPLE OF IN SITU DIAGNOSES AND FOLLOW-UP OF COMMON SENSE AND
ABERRANT COMMON SENSE IN POST-WORLD WAR II IN GERMANY (Sept / 15 December 2007) Biographical
note
COMMENTARIES
on TA 100 :
TA100 C1 by Liu Zhida : THE EXPLANATION
OF THE PICTURES PRESENTING THE CONFLICT CAUSED BY CROSSING A BRIDGE (12 / 22
Dec 2007) Chinese original
TA100 C2 by Stanley Krippner
: ( COMMON SENSE ) (3 / 22 Dec 2007)
TA100 C3 by Fred Abraham to Krippner,
C2 : ( COMMON SENSE ) (20 / 29 December 2007)
TA100 C4 by Herbert FJ Muller : THE DIAGNOSIS OF LACK
OF COMMON SENSE (29 Dec 2007 / 5 Jan 2008)
TA100 C5 by Frederick David Abraham : OPERATIONAL
DEFINITIONS : TRIAGE AND SOCIAL
SIGNIFICANCE (30 Dec 2007 / 5 Jan 2008)
TA100 C6 by Fred Abraham : ( COMMON SENSE ) (3 / 12 January 2008)
TA100 C7 by Herbert FJ Muller : POSTMODERNISM,
RELATIVISM, AND COMMON SENSE (RAYMOND BOUDON ON COMMON SENSE) (14 / 19 January
2008)
TA100 C8 by Herbert FJ Muller : COMMON SENSE AND
METAPHYSICS (JOHN R SEARLE AND HIS
COMMON SENSE) (29 Jan / 9 Febr 2008)
TA100 C9 by Serge Patlavskiy
: CAN COMMON SENSE BE AN OBJECT OF STUDY ? (8 / 16 Febr
2008)
TA100 C10 by Elizabeth Johnson-Kallos :
DEFINITION OF COMMON SENSE (15 / 23 February 2008)
TA100 C11 by John R Searle : JUST COMMON SENSE (1 / 23
February 2008)
TA100 C12 by David Papineau
(to C11, Searle) : ( COMMON
SENSE ) (21 Febr / 1 March 2008)
TA100 C13 by Bill Adams (to C11, Searle) : ( BRAIN
AND MIND ) (27 Febr / 1 March 2008)
TA100 C14 by Slavoj Hontela (to C11, Searle) : ( JOHN SEARLE AND THE SNEAKY
OCTOPUS ) (2 / 15 March 2008)
TA100 C15 by Serge Patlavskiy
(to C14, Hontela) : TYPES OR MECHANISMS ? (15 / 22 March 2008)
TA100 C16 by Maurioce McCarthy :
DEFINING COMMON SENSE
(17 / 22 March 2008)
TA100 C17 by Slavoj Hontela : (
QUESTIONS FOR PHYSISICSTS ) (27 March / 5 April 2008)
RESPONSES by
Roulette William Smith :
TA100 R1 to Krippner and Abraham
: ON FUNCTIONAL AND OPERATIONAL DEFINITIONS FOR ‘COMMON SENSE’ (28 Dec 2007 / 5
Jan 2008)
TA100 R2 to C4, Muller : ( THE DIAGNOSIS OF LACK OF
COMMON SENSE ) (14 / 19 January 2008)
TA100 R3 to several comments : ( COMMON
SENSE ) (21 / 29 March 2008)
*******************************************************************************************
TARGET
ARTICLE 101 :
TA101 by Ulrich Mohrhoff : THE TRANSPARENT BRAIN (18 / 29 December 2007)
COMMENTARIES
on TA 101 :
TA101 C1 by Herbert FJ Muller :
EXPERIENCE ENCOMPASSES MATTER (20 Dec 2007 / 5 Jan 2008)
TA101 C2 by Serge Patlavskiy
: WHICH REALITY WE PERCEIVE ? (29 Dec
2007 / 5 Jan 2008)
TA101 C3 by Herbert FJ Muller : QUESTIONS
OF TERMINOLOGY (14 / 22 March 2008)
TA101 C4 (to R2) by Herbert FJ Muller : STRUCTURING, FINDING, AND CONCEPTS’ TRICKS
(31 March / 5 April 2008)
TA101 C5 (to R3) by Herbert FJ Muller : STRUCTURING (23 / 31 May 2008)
RESPONSES by
Ulrich Mohrhoff :
TA101 R1 to C1 . Muller : ( THE TRANSPARENT BRAIN ) (9 / 15 March 2008)
TA101 R2 to C3, Muller : ( TERMINOLOGY ) (23 / 29 March 2008)
TA101 R3 to C4, Muller : ( STRUCTURING ) (17 / 24 May 2008)
TA101 R4 to C5, Muller : ( INEFFABLE
FULLNESS ) (30 June / 5 July 2008)
*******************************************************************************************
TARGET
ARTICLES 102, 103, and 104 :
TA104 by Ram Lakhan Pandey Vimal : PROTO-EXPERIENCES
AND SUBJECTIVE EXPERIENCES : INTEGRATION
OF CLASSICAL, QUANTUM, AND SUBQUANTUM EFFECTS (19 / 26 January 2008) .pdf
version .pdf version updated
26 Jan 2008 .pdf version updated 3
Febr 2008
COMMENTARIES
on TAs 103 and 103 :
TA 102-103 C1 by Philip Benjamin : CHAMPENROVF
THE CHIMP CHAMP (11 / 19 January
2008)
TA 102-103 C2 by Herbert FJ Muller : AN INITIAL
QUERY (15 / 19 January 2008)
TA 102-103-C3 by Herbert FJ Muller : CO-EVOLUTION ? (18 / 26 January 2008)
TA 102-104-C4 by Herbert FJ Muller : SUBJECTS AND BRAINS (27 Jan / 2 Feb 2008)
TA 102-104 C5 by Herbert FJ Muller : THE
BRAIN IN 0-D
EPISTEMOLOGY (4 / 9 Febr 2008)
TA 102-104 C6 by Herbert FJ Muller : THE BRAIN IN 0-D EPISTEMOLOGY (8 / 16 Febr 2008)
TA 102-104 C7 by Herbert FJ Muller : MIR VERSUS
WORKING-MIR (29 Febr / 8 March 2008)
TA 102-104 C8 by Herbert FJ Muller : PROBLEMS OF DUALISM (9 / 15 March 2008)
TA 102 C9 by Adhanom Andemicael : THE
NATURE OF TIME (9 / 12 December 2009)
RESPONSES by
Ram Lakhan Pandey Vimal :
TA 102-103-R1 to Benjamin : ( THANKS ) (11 / 19 January 2008)
TA 102-103 R2 to Wood : ( JASPERS REFERENCES ) (12
/ 19 January 2008)
TA 102-103 R3 to Muller (C2) : ( ON THE DE & PAL PROPOSAL ) (17 / 26
January 2008)
TA 102-104 R4 to C3, Muller : ( ON ENCOMPASSINGH
EXPERIENCE ) (26 Jan / 2 Feb 2008)
TA 102-104 R5 to C4, Muller : ( SUBJECTS AND
BRAINS ) (3 / 9 Febr 2008)
TA 102-104 R6 to C5, Muller : ( THE BRAIN IN 0-D
EPISTEMOLOGY )
TA 102-104 R7 to C7, Muller : ( THE BRAIN IN 0-D
EPISTEMOLOGY ) (28 Febr / 8 March 2008)
TA 102-104 R8 to C8, Muller : ( MIR VERSUS
WORKING-MIR ) (5 / 15 March 2008)
TA 102-104 R9 to C8, Muller : ( NIRVANA ) (12 / 22
March 2008)
TA 102-104 R10 (addition) : DEFINITION
OF CONSCIOUSNESS (3 / 9 August
2008)
*******************************************************************************************
TARGET
ARTICLE 105 :
COMMENTARIES
on TA 105 :
TA 105 C1 by Cr Alan Oliver : (
NEURAL NETWORKS AND BUDDHISM ) (2 / 9 Febr 2008)
TA 105 C2 by Peter Beamish : MIND DEFINITION (7 / 16 Febr 2008)
TA 105 C3 by Peter Beamish : IN DEFENCE OF A NEW “MIND
DEFINITION” USING REVERSE ‘CONCENTIONAL TIME’ (10 / 16 Febr
2008)
RESPONSES by
Ram Lakhan Pandey Vimal :
TA 105 R1 to Oliver, C1 : (
NEURAL NETWORKS AND BUDDHISM ) (7 / 16 Febr 2008 )
*******************************************************************************************
TARGET
ARTICLE 106 :
COMMENTARIES
on TA 106 :
TA 106 C1 by Serge Patlavskiy : IS IT NATURAL TO BE A NON-BELIEVER ? (29 Febr / 8 March
2008)
TA 106 C2 by Peter Schuster :
( DOES GOD EXIST ? ) (11 / 15 March 2008)
TA 106 C3 by Varadaraja V
Raman (to Schuster, C2) : ( DOES GOD EXIST ? ) (12 /
22 March 2008)
TA 106 C4 by Peter Beamish : RELATIVITY AND “OBJECTIVE
REALITY” (2c : TWICE THE SPEED OF LIGHT) (13 / 22 March 2008)
TA 106 C5 by Alain Chouinard
: SPEED
OF LIGHT (13 / 22 March 2008)
TA 106 C6 by Varadaraja V
Raman : ON DAWKINS (19 / 29 March 2008)
TA 106 C7 by Paul Roberts : ( ON DAWKINS ) (24 / 29 March 2008)
TA 106 C8 by Joseph S Johnson : IN
SEARCH OF MEANING (25 / 29 March 2008)
TA 106 C9 by Maurice McCarthy : THE GOD HYPOTHESIS NEEDS RECONCEIVING (24 /
29 March 2008)
TA 106 C10 by Joan Koss-Chioino,
Zvi Lothane, John Mikes,
Peter Schuster (to L Sundararajan) : ON GOD
(25 / 29 March 2008)
TA 106 C11 by
Varadaraja V Raman (to L Sundararajan)
: TOWARDS A DESCRIPTIVE DEFINITION OF
RELIGION (26 / 29 March 2008)
TA 106 C12 by Peter Beamish : ( QUESTIONS FOR PHYSICISTS
) [Relativity] (27 March / 5 April 2008)
TA 106 C13 by Pete Schuster, Santiago Cardoso, Elli Winer (to L Sundararajan)
(RELIGION AND DAWKINS) (1 / 5 April 2008)
TA 106 C14 by Louise Sundararajan
: ( WORK
AND RELIGION ) (7 / 12 April
2008)
TA 106 C15 by Varadaraja V
Raman : ULTIMATE ENTITIES (21 March / 12 April 2008)
TA 106 C16 by Robert A Segal : THE STRIVING IS ALL, on David K Kim : MELANCHOLIC FREEDOM (28 March / 19 April
2008)
TA 106 C17 by Varadaraja V
Raman ( ON SPEED OF LIGHT ) (9 / 19
April 2008)
TA 106 C18 by Peter Beamish : SPEED OF LIGHT (AND PEOPLE ) (9 / 19 April
2008)
TA 106 C19 by Robert Neil Boyd : EXCEEDING
THE SPEED OF LIGHT
(11 / 19 April 2008)
TA 106 C20 by Philip Benjamin : NEW AGE OR NEW
PHYSICALITY ? RIGHT OR AUTHORITY ?
DEFINITION OR DEDUCTION ? (17 / 26 April 2008)
TA 106 C21 by Peter Beamish (to Boyd) : THE VELOCITY (NOT “SPEED”) OF LIGHT (21 / 26
April 2008)
TA 106 C22 by Robert Neil Boyd (to Beamish) : (
SPEED OF
LIGHT ) (21 / 26 April 2008)
TA 106 C23 by Varadaraja V
Raman (to Benjamin, C20) : CRITERION OF
RELIGIOSITY (22 April / 3 May 2008)
TA 106 C24 by Zvi Lothane : (SPEED OF
LIGHT SOUR GRAPES) (22 April / 3 May 2008)
TA 106 C25 by Peter Beamish (to Boyd, C22) : THE VELOCITY OF LIGHT (22 April / 3 May 2008)
TA 106 C26 by Peter Beamish (to R9) : LIGHT VELOCITY “AND PEOPLE” (22 April / 3 May
2008)
TA 106 C27 by Maurice McCarthy : EVOLUTION AT PLAY (27 April / 3 May 2008)
TA 106 C28 by Peter Beamish (to R10) :
SUBJECT-INCLUSIVE RELARTIVITY (1 / 10 May 2008)
TA 106 C29 by Varadaraja V
Raman : THOUGHTS ON YOGA (3 / 10 May
2008)
TA 106 C30 by Philip Benjamin : ( EVOLUTION AND RELIGION ) (8 / 17 May 2008)
TA 106 C31 by Peter Beamish : ( SUBJECT-INCLUSIVE RELATIVITY WITHIN
EXPERIENCE ) (9 / 17 May 2008)
TA 106 C32 by Maurice McCarthy : EVOLUTION AND RELIGION (12 / 17 May 2008)
TA 106 C33 by Serge Patlavskiy
: DO WE REALLY NEED TO REINVENT THE IDEA
OF GOD ? (17 / 24 May 2008)
TA 106 C34 by Varadaraja V Raman
: ATTITUDES TO OTHER RELIGIONS : A
PERSONAL APPROACH (24 May/ 14 June 2008)
TA 106 C35 by Slavoj Hontela : ( GOD AND
CONSCIOUSNESS ) (8 / 16 August 2008)
TA 106 C36 by Serge Patlavskiy
to S Hontela and J Johnson : GODS AND CONSERVATION OF CONSCIOUSNESS (29
Aug / 6 Sept 2008)
TA 106 C37 by Michael Chumakin
: LOOKING FOR COMMON
GROUND (9 / 16 May 2009)
TA 106 C38 by Maurice McCarthy to M Chumakin (C37) :
FURTHERING COMMON GROUND (18 / 23 May 2009)
TA 106 C39 by Steven M Rosen to C37, Chumakin : (
MATERIALISM AND SCIENCE ) (13 / 22 August 2009)
TA 106 C40 by William A Adams, to R15, on Dawkins and
Collins : CRITICAL THINKING VS SCIENTISM
AND DOGMA (16 / 22 August 2009)
TA 106 C41 by Serge Patlavskiy
to C37, Chumakin, and R14 to Chumakin
: META-THEORY VS ONTOLOGY AND
METAPHYSICS (16 / 22 August 2009)
TA 106 C42 by Serge Patlavskiy
to Adams (C40 ) : IN WHICH SCIENCE
FIFFERS FROM RE;IGION ? (19 / 29 August 2009)
TA 106 C43 by WA Adams to S Patlavskiy
C42 : SCIENCE
DOES DIFFER FROM RELIGION (27 August / 5 Sept 2009)
TA 106 C44 by WA Adams to H Muller (R17) : NONDUAL KNOWING (4 / 12 Sept 2009)
TA 106 C45 by S Patlavskiy
to WA Adams, C43 : SCIENCE AND RELIGION
ARE “GENETICALLY” COMPATIBLE (6 /12 September 2009)
TA 106 C46 by WA Adams to SPatlavskiy
(C45) : ARE ALL EXPLANATIONS EQUIVALENT
? (10 / 19 Sept 2009)
TA 106 C47 by HZ Lothane to Patlavskiy : RELIGION AND SCIENCE (12 / 19 Sept 2009)
TA 106 C48 by S Patlavskiy
to H Muller : CAN NOUMENAL REALITY BE
THOUGHT ABOUT ? (13 / 19 Sept 2009)
TA 106 C49 by P Benjamin to Lothane,
C47 : RELIGION
AND SCIENCE (15 / 26 Sept 2009)
TA 106 C50 by WA Adams to R19 by Muller : TWO KINDS OF
DUALISM (16 / 26 Sept 2009)
TA 106 C51 by S Patlavskiy
to Adams, C46 : WHAT IS
CONSESNSUS-GENERATING DE FACTO ? (17 / 26 Sept 2009)
TA 106 C52 by Ken Bausch : RELIGION AS ATTRACTOR, PROCESS, AND BIOLOGY
(20 / 29 Sept 2009)
TA 106 C53 by F Abraham : CRITICAL PHILOSOPHY (23 Sep / 3 Oct 2009)
TA 106 C54 by HZ Lothane (to
Benjamin) : RELIGION (23 Sep / 3 Oct
2009)
TA 106 C55 by WA Adans to Patlavskiy (C51) :
SCIENTIST DISCOVERED TO HAVE NO BODY (24 Sep / 3 Oct 2009)
TA 106 C56 by Phil Benjamion
to HZ Lothane C47 :
SPIRITUALITY AND PSYCHOLOGY (25 Sep / 3 Oct 2009)
TA 106 C57 by WA Adams to HF Muller R21 : ARE WE NOT DEMI-URGES ? (27 sep / 3 Oct 2009)
TA 106 C58 by S Barnett to Adams C50 : SUBJECTIVE EXPERIENCES WITHOUT SUBJECTS; OBSERVATIONS WITHOUT OBSERVERS (28 Sep / 3
Oct 2009)
TA 106 C59 by WA Adams to Muller, R22 : END OF THE ROAD (30 Sept / 3 Oct 2009)
TA 106 C60 by P Roberts to Muller et al : (MIND-INDEPENDENT REALITY) (30 Sept / 3 Oct
2009)
TA 106 C61 by S Patlavskiy
to R20, Muller : THE OBVIOUS CONFLICT OF
INTERESTS (1 / 3 October 2009)
TA 106 C62 by S Patlavskiy
to C55, Adams : FINAL CONSIDERATIONS (1
/ 3 Oct 2009)
TA 106 C63 by WA Adams to Barnett, C58 : CURSE OF THE ZOMBIE OBSERVER (2 / 17 October
2009)
TA 106 C64 Adams to Muller, R23 : MOONBEAMS R US (3 / 17 October 2009)
TA 106 C65 Adams to Patlavskiy
: WHAT ARE THE FACTS ? (4 / 17 October 2009)
TA 106 C66 Baranett to Adams
C63 : ZOMBIES’ BOOGALOO
(7 / 17 October 2009)
TA 106 C67 Patlavskiy to
Adams C65 : A POSSIBLE COMPROMISE (14 /
24 October 2009)
TA 106 C68 CM Taylor and J Habermas
: RELIGIOUS AND SECULAR ETHICS
TA 106 C69 Harwood Fisher : PRE-STRUCTURED VERSUS RE-CONFIGURABLE
OBJECTS, AND THEIR RELATION TO THE TERMS OFETHICAL THEORIES (11/19 Dec 2009)
TA 106 C70 Henry (Zvi) Lothane : ( DEUS
SIVE NATURA ) (12/19 Dec 2009)
RESPONSES by Herbert FJ Muller :
TA 106 R1 (addition to TA106) :
UNDERSTANDING NATURE [Peter Dear] (11 / 15 March 2008)
TA 106 R2 to Patlavskiy (C1)
: ABSOLUTE AND WORKING BELIEFS (6 / 15
March 2008)
TA 106 R3 to Beamish& Chouinard
: SOME
QUESTIONS FOR PHYSICISTS [Relativity] (16 / 29 March 2008)
TA 106 R4 to Schuster and Raman : COMMENTS
ON DAWKINS’ BOOK (17 / 22 March 2008)
TA 106 R5 to Cardoso (C13) : WORK
AND RELIGION (1 / 5 April 2008)
TA 106 R6 to Peter Beamish (C12) : SPEED
OF LIGHT AND
PEOPLE (2 / 12 April 2008)
TA 106 R7 to Joseph S Johnson : THE METAPHYSICS BOOMERANG : CONVERSION INTO A MORE USEFUL TOOL (5 / 19
April 2008)
TA 106 R8 to Maurice McCarthy : INDIVIDUALS
AND GUIDELINES (7 / 19 April 2008)
TA 106 R9 to Raman, Beamish, Boyd : THE SPEED OF LIGHT AND PEOPLE : FINDING VERSUS STANDARD (16 / 26 April 2008)
TA 106 R10 to Beamish, C26 : SUBJECT-INCLUSIVE RELATIVITY : STRUCTURES IN MIND, NOT MIND IN STRUCTURES
(27 April / 3 May 2008)
TA 106 R11 to McCarthy, C27 : EVOLUTION AND RELIGION (1 / 10 May 2008)
TA 106 R12 to Beamish (C28) : SUBJECT-INCLUSIVE RELATIVITY WITHIN
EXPERIENCE (4 / 10 May 2008)
TA 106 R13 :
CHRISTIANITY AND EVOLUTION
(18 / 24 May 2008)
TA 106 R14 to Chumakin
: MATERIALISM AND SCIENCE (12 May / 15
August 2009)
TA 106 R15 (Addition) : GOD
VS SCIENCE (Dawkins, Collins, Whittenberger) (5
Nov 2006 / 15 Aug 2006)
TA 106 R16 to Rosen (C39) : STRUCTURING IN THE UNSTRUCTURED (15 / 29
August 2009)
TA 106 R17 to WA Adams, C40 : THE UNSTRUCTURED ORIGIN (17 Aug / 5 Sept
2009)
TA 106 R18 to S Patlavskiy,
C41 : ON MATERIALISM (21 Aug / 12 Sept 2009)
TA 106 R19 to Adams (C44) : UNDERSTANDING, FAMILIARITY, AND EVIDENCE (5 /
19 Sept 2009)
TA 106 R20 to Patlavskiy C48
: REQUEST FOR CLARIFICATION (15 /26 Sept
2009)
TA 106 R21 to Adams (C50) : PRAGMATIC DISTANCING (18 / 26 Sept 2009)
TA 106 R22 to Adams C57 : WE ARE REALITY-DESIGNERS (27 Sept / 3 Oct
2009)
TA 106 R23 to Adams C59 and Roberts C60 : QUERIES FROM LEFT AND RIGHT (1 / 3 October
2009)
TA 106 R24 to Patlavskiy
(C61) and Adams (C64) : ON BLACK CATS
AND MOON-BEAMS (15 / 24 October 2009)
TA 106 R25 to Taylor and Habermas
(C68) : MORALS AND THE UNSTRUCTURED
MATRIX (3 / 12 December 2009)
TA 106 R26 to Fisher (C68) : THE
WAY FROM HERE (28 Dec 2009 / 2 Jan 2010)
*******************************************************************************************
TARGET
ARTICLE 107 :
COMMENTARIES
on TA 107 :
TA 107 C1 by Joseph McCard : (
CEZANNE’S SPACE ) (23 / 31 May 2008)
TA 107 C2 by Donald Mender : ( BRIDGING THE ‘TWO
CULTURES’ : MERLEAU-PONTY AND THE CRISIS
IN MODERN PHYSICS ) (27 / 31 May 2008)
TA 107 C3 by Donald Mender (to R2) : ( SUBJECT AND
OBJECT ) (31 May/7June 2008)
TA 107 C4 by Herbert FJ Muller : THE 0-D ONTOLOGY
INSTRUMENT (1 / 7 June 2008)
TA 107 C5 by Herbert FJ Muller (to R4):
SUBJECT-INCLUSIVE EPISTEMOLOGY AND META-PHENOMENAL DESIGN (10 / 14 June 2008)
TA 107 C6 by Steve Bindeman :
( MERLEAU-PONTY AND THE CRISIS
IN MODERN SCIENCE ) (16 / 21 June 2008)
TA 107 C7 by Zvi Lothane : (
MATERIALISM AND MINDFULNESS ) (17 / 21 June 2008)
TA 107 C8 by Louise Sundararajan
: BRIDGING THE “TWO CULTURES” : MERLEAU-PONTY AND THE CRISIS IN MODERN
PHYSICS (8 / 16 August 2008)
TA 107 C9 by Lloyd Gilden
: ON Steven M Rosen : BRIDGING THE “TWO CULTURES” : MERLEAU-PONTY AND THE CRISIS IN MODERN
PHYSICS (13 / 16 August 2008)
RESPONSES by
Steven M Rosen :
TA 107 R1 to Joseph McCard : (
PHYSICS AND ACTION ) (30 May / 7 June 2008)
TA 107 R2 to Donald Mender (C2) : ( MERLEAU-PONTY AND
PHYSICS ) (30 May / 7 June 2008)
TA 107 R3 to Donald Mender (C3) : ( TOPOLOGY ) (31 May
/ 7 June 2008)
TA 107 R4 to Herbert FJ Muller (C4) : (
SUBJECT-INCLUSIVE EPISTEMOLOGY ) (8 / 14
June 2008)
TA 107 R5 to Steven Bindeman
(C6) : ( KLEIN BOTTLE )
(19 / 29 June 2008)
TA 107 R6 to Louise Sundararajan
(C8) : ( EMOTION AND KLEIN BOTTLING
) (12 / 16 August 2008)
*******************************************************************************************
TARGET
ARTICLE 108 :
COMMENTARIES
on TA 108 :
TA 108 C1 by Herbert FJ Muller : FROM
EXCLUSION TO INCLUSION OF
SUBJECTS ; REVOLUTION BY
INSTALMENTS (4 / 14 June 2008)
TA 108 C2 by Gregory Nixon : ( DIVINE RECIPE ) (4 / 14 June 2008)
TA 108 C3 by Serge Patlavskiy
: THE LAWS OF
CONSCIOUSNESS COMPARED (6 / 14
June 2008)
TA 108 C4 by Joseph S Johnson : THE
MEANING OF REVOLUTION
(14 / 21 June 2008)
TA 108 C5 by Joseph McCard
: THE
GOSPEL ACCORDING TO
JANE ROBERTS (16 / 21 June 2008)
TA 108 C6 Joseph S Johnson to Joseph McCard :
REVOLUTION FOR SURVIVAL (21
/ 28 June 2008)
TA 108 C7 Serge Patlavskiy to
Joseph Johnson : REJECTING EPIPHENOMENA
(28 June / 5 July 2008)
TA 108 C8 Joseph S Johnson to Serge Patlavskiy
: NATURAL ORDER, NATURAL LAW (15 July /
16 August 2008)
TA 108 C9 Serge Patlavskiy to Joseph Johnson : ON
MATERIALISM, TRIALISM, AND
NATURAL LAW (14 / 23 August 2008)
TA 108 C10 Joseph S Johnson to Serge Patlavskiy :
EXEMPLARS OF CONSCIOUSNESS (25 / 30 August 2008)
*******************************************************************************************
TARGET
ARTICLE 109 :
COMMENTARIES
on TA 109 :
TA 109 C1 by Felix Holmgren : ( BUDDHIST
EPISTEMOLOGY ) (3 July / 2 August
2008)
TA 109 C2 Muller to Bhatt and Holmgren : THE MIND-BRAIN PUZZLE AND BUDDHIST AND
WESTERN EPISTEMOLOGIES (26 July / 9 August 2008)
TA 109 C3 by A Priya : QUESTIONS
ABOUT NAGARJUNA (31 July / 9 August 2008)
TA 109 C4 Muller to Priya
: ON NAGARJUNA’S EPISTEMOLOGY (5 / 16
August 2008)
TA 109 C5 Muller :
NIRVANA VERSUS METAPHYSICS
(25 / 30 August 2008)
TA 109 C6 Rob Weedon : COMMENTING ON BUDDHISM (5 / 15 November 2008)
TA 109 C7 William A Adams : ABIDHAMMIC
PERCEPTION (16 / 22 November 2008)
TA 109 C8 Felix Holmgren, review of Mark Siderits : BUDDHISM
AS PHILOSOPHY (13 June 2008, posted 28
February 2009)
TA 109 C9 Varadaraja V Raman
: CULTURE AND SCIENCE : IN THE INDIAN CONTEXT (4 April / 30 May 2009)
*******************************************************************************************
TARGET
ARTICLE 110 :
[ MIND AND
METAPHYSICS ]
COMMENTARIES
on TA 110 :
TA 110 C1 by Herbert FJ Muller : A
WAY OUT OF
PLATO’S CAVE (6 / 13 September 2008)
TA 110 C2 by Simon Blackburn : FROZEN IN TIME (on The Mind
In Nature by C B Martin) (12 Sept / 4 October 2008)
TA 110 C3 by Herbert FJ Muller (to C2, Blackburn)
: THINGS
WITHOUT ONTOLOGY (28 Sept / 4 October 2008)
TA 110 C4 by Herbert FJ Muller (to C2, Blackburn and C.B.Martin) :
REALITY-DESIGN VERSUS CONTEMPORARY
- AND TEMPORARY
- METAPHYSICS-ONTOLOGY. SOME
QUESTIONS RAISED BY READING C.B. MARTIN’S ‘MIND
IN NATURE’ (20 / 25 October 2008)
TA 110 C5 by Herbert FJ Muller : DENIAL
OF SUBJECTIVITY VIA
MATERIALISM (DENNETT) (10 / 15
November 2008)
TA 110 C6 by Herbert FJ Muller : NATURAL
METAPHYSICS, REALITY WITHOUT
PEOPLE - Alexander Bird, reviewed by Helen Beebee (24 / 29
November 2008)
TA 110 C7 by Herbert FJ Muller : ON EMBODIMENT
(NATURAL STRUCTURE, LAKOFF AND
JOHNSON) (29 Nov / 6 Dec 2008)
TA 110 C8 by Herbert FJ Muller : THE
LAW OF RELAPSE
INTO MIR-BELIEF (2 / 6 Dec 2008)
TA 110 C9 by Harwood Fisher : EMBODIMENT AND CAUSAL PATTERNS (3 / 13 December 2008)
TA 110 C10 by Herbert FJ Muller : ON
EMBODIMENT (as discussed in Mark Johnson’s ‘Meaning the Body’) (12 / 20 December 2008)
TA 110 C11 by William A Adams (to C10): PURPOSE OF THE BODY (18 / 27 December 2008)
TA 110 C12 by Slavoj Hontela to HF Muller :
ON EMBODIMENT AND NATURAL STRUCTUREE (12 Nov 2008 / 3 Jan 2009)
TA 110 C13 by Herbert FJ Muller to S Hontela, C12 : ON
MIND AND
METAPHYSICS (28 Dec 2008 / 3 Jan 2009)
TA 110 C14 by Richard Moodey
: ON EMBODIMENT (2 / 7 Febr 2009)
TA 110 C15 by William A Adams (to Moodey,
C14) : THE BODY AS MENTAL CONSTRUCT (5
/ 14 February 2009)
TA 110 C16 by Herbert FJ Muller (to Moodey, C14, and Freeman, C17) : ON EMBODIMENT (6 / 14 Febr 2009)
TA 110 C17 by Margaret Freeman (to Muller, C10) : ( ON EMBODIMENT ) (9 / 14 Febr.
2009)
TA 110 C18 by Harwood Fisher (to Moodey
and others) : ON EMBODIMENT (11 / 21 Febr 2009)
TA 110 C19 by Richard Moodey
(to Freeman) : (ON EMBODIMENT) (13 / 21 Febr 2009)
TA 110 C20 by Richard Moodey
(to Adams) : THE BODY AS MENTAL
CONSTRUCT (13 / 21 Febr 2009)
TA 110 C21 by Richard Moodey
(to Fisher) : ON EMBODIMENT (18 / 28 Febr 2009)
TA 110 C22 by William A Adams (to Moodey,
C20) THE BODY AS MENTAL CONSTRUCT (20 /
28 Febr 2009)
TA 110 C23 by Paul Roberts to Adams and Moodey : (
EVOLUTION AND PROPAGATION )
(23 / 28 Febr 2009)
TA 110 C24 by Harwood Fisher (to Moodey,
C21) : ( ON EMBODIMENT ) (23 / 28 Febr 2009)
TA 110 C25 by Richard Moodey
(to Adams, C22) : THE BODY AS
MENTAL CONSTRUCT (25 / 28 Febr 2009)
TA 110 C26 by Richard Moodey
(to Roberts, C23) : ( EVOLUYION AND
PROPAGATION ) (25 Febr / 7 Mar 2009)
TA 110 C27 by Richard Moodey (to
Fisher, C24) : ( ON EMBODIMENT ) (25 Febr / 7 Mar 2009)
TA 110 C28 by Harwood Fisher (to Moodey,
C27) : ( AGENCY ) (2 / 7 March 2009)
TA 110 C29 by Richard Moodey
(to Fisher, C28) : ( AGENCY ) ( 8 / 14 March 2009 )
*******************************************************************************************
TARGET
ARTICLE 111 :
COMMENTARIES
on TA 111 :
TA 111 C1 by Herbert FJ Muller : GROUND
RULES FOR ACCESS TO
CONSCIOUSNESS (1 / 8 November 2008)
TA 111 C2 by Rob Weedon
: THE
GUV’NOR (5 / 15 November 2008)
TA 111 C3 by Herbert FJ Muller to Beamish and Patlavskiy : ACCESS
TO CONSCIOUSNESS (10 / 22 November 2008)
TA 111 C4 by Serge Patlavskiy
: NOTHING CAN “BE SEEN” AS
MIND-INDEPENDENT (9 / 15 November 2008)
TA 111 C5 by Serge Patlavskiy
: CONSERVATION OF “SOMTHINGNESS” AND
“NOTHINGNESS” (23 / 29 November 2008)
TA 111 C6 by Adrian Klein and R N Boyd : REALITY IS NEITHER ABSURD NOR PARADOXICAL (3
/ 13 December 2008)
TA 111 C7 by Herbert FJ Muller : SPACE-TIME :
ANAXIMANDER, HERAKLEITOS, MINKOWSKI
- BUT WHO COUNTS
? (30 Nov / 13 Dec 2008)
TA 111 C8 by Herbert FJ Muller : CONCERNING TIME AND REALITY (11 / 20 December
2008)
TA 111 C9 by Robert N Boyd : ( REALITY IS NEITHER ABSURD NOR PARADOXICAL )
(17 / 27 December 2008)
TA 111 C10 by Herbert FJ Muller : CONCERNING TIME AND REALITY (19 / 27 December
2008)
TA 111 C11 by Herbert FJ Muller : CONCERNING TIME AND REALITY (23 Dec 2008 / 3
Jan 2009)
TA 111 C12 by Herbert FJ Muller : CONCERNING TIME AND REALITY (31 Dec 2008 / 10
Jan 2009)
RESPONSES by
Peter Beamish :
TA 111 R1 to Muller : Re GROUND RULES FOR ACCESS TO CONSCIOUSNESS
(6 / 15 November 2008)
TA 111 R2 to Pande : QM
TIME (9 / 15 November 2008)
TA 111 R3 to Weedon : Re. The GUV’NOR (12 / 22 November 2008)
TA 111 R4 to Kanda :
FASTER THAN THE
SPEED OF LIGHT (19 / 22 November 2008)
TA 111 R5 to Muller : ACCESS TO CONSCIOUSNESS (20 ? 29
November 2008)
TA 111 R6 to Patlavskiy
: CONSERVATION (27 Nov / 6 Dec 2008)
TA 111 R7 to Klein, Boyd, Muller : ( REALITY IS NEITHER ABSURD NOR PARADOXICAL )
(4 / 20 Dec 2008)
TA 111 R8 to Boyd :
UNIFICATION OF TIME WITH GRAVITATION AND ELECTROMAGNETISM (15 / 20
December 2008)
TA 111 R9 to Kanda :
SCALARS (16 / 20 Dec 2008)
TA 111 R10 to Muller (C8) : CONCERNING TIME AND REALITY (18 / 27 December
2008)
TA 111 R11 to Muller (C10) : CONCERNING TIME AND REALITY (23 Dec 2008 / 3
Jan 2009)
TA 111 R12 to Muller (C11) : CONCERNING TIME AND REALITY (31 Dec 2008 / 10
Jan 2009)
TA 111 R13 (addition) : CONCERNING TIME AND REALITY (31 Dec 2008 / 10
Jan 2009)
TA 111 R14 to Muller C12 : ( MIND )
8 / 17 January 2009
*******************************************************************************************
TARGET
ARTICLE 112 :
COMMENTARIES
on TA 112 :
TA 112 C1 by William Byers : ( MATHEMATICAL THINKING ) (6 / 14 Febr 2009)
TA 112 C2 by Harwood Fisher : ( EMBODIMENT
AND REIFICATION ) (23 / 28 Febr 2009)
TA 112 C3 by Michael Schwartz to R2 : I AND
EXISTENCE (25 / 28 Febr 2009)
TA 112 C4 by Richard Moodey
to R2 : ( THEISM AND CONSTRUCTION ) (25
/ 28 Febr 2009)
TA 112 C5 by Harwood Fisher to R3 : ( EMBODIMENT AND REIFICATION ) (2 Febr / 7 Mar 2009)
TA 112 C6 by Harwood Fisher to R4 : ( STRUCTURE OR PERISH ) (3 /
7 March 2009)
TA 112 C7 by Richard Moodey
to R5 : ( THEISM AND CONSTRUCTION ) (10
/ 14 March 2009)
TA 112 C8 by Richard Moodey
to R7 : ( THEISM AND CONSTRUCTION ) (17
/ 28 March 2009)
TA 112 C9 by Richard Moodey
to R8 : ( EVOLUTION, OBJECTIVITY,
AND REALITY-DESIGN ) (25 March /
4 April 2009)
TA 112 C10 by Richard Moodey
to R7[6] : ( CRITICAL
REA;LISM AND RELIGION ) (26 March / 4 April 2009)
TA 112 C11 by Richard Moodey
further to C9 : (EVOLUTION, OBJECTIVITY,
AND REALITY-DESIGN) (2 / 11 April 2009)
TA 112 C12 by Richard W Moodey
(to R10) : ON ALVA NOE (11 / 18 April 2009)
TA 112 C13 by William A Adams (to Moodey,
C12) NOË, GIBSON AND REPRESENTATIONALISM (17 / 25 April 2009)
TA 112 C14 by Shakti Sharma : ( SELF-STRUCTURING, SOUL, AND DEATH ) (28
April / 9 May 2009)
TA 112 C15 by Fred Abraham : ( PARMENIDES
AND GORGIAS ) (4 / 14 November 2009)
RESPONSES by
Herbert FJ Muller :
TA 112 R1 (to C1, Byers) :
DREAM OF REASON (9 / 20 Febr 2009)
TA 112 R2 (to Fisher and Moodey,
discussion of TA110) : EMBODIMENT AND REIFICATION (AND PF STRAWSON’S NEO-METAPHYSICS) (21 / 28 Febr.
2009)
TA 112 R3 (to Fisher, C2) : EMBODIMENT
AND REIFICATION (25 / 28 Febr 2009)
TA 112 R4 (to Fisher, C5 and Schwartz, C3) : STRUCTURE OR PERISH (3 / 7 March 2009)
TA 112 R5 (to Moodey, C4)
: THEISM AND CONSTRUCTION
(8 /14 March 2009)
TA 112 R6 (to Fisher, C6) : STRUCTURE
OR PERISH (8 / 14 March 2009)
TA 112 R7 (to Moodey, C7)
: THEISM
AND THE UNSTRUCTURED
- WHOSE PURPOSE
AND CONCERN ? (14 / 21 March 2009)
TA 112 R8 (to Moodey, C7)
: THEISM
AND CONSTRUCTION (17 / 28 March
2009)
TA 112 R9 (addition) :
0-D AND HEIDEGGER’S METAPHYSICS
(24 / 28 March 2009)
TA 112 R10 (to Moodey, C11)
: EVOLUTION, OBJECTIVITY, AND
REALITY-DESIGN (7 / 11 April 2009)
TA 112 R11 (to Adams, C13) : SELF-STRUCTURING : ON ALVA NOË’S ENACTIVISM
(28 Apr / 2 May 2009)
TA 112 R12 (to Sharma, C14) : MIND AND SOUL
(1 / 9 May 2009)
TA 112 R13 (Addition by Evan Thompson) :
SENSORIMOTORISTS (Review of books by Andy Clark and Alva Noe)
(26 June / 8 August 2009)
TA 112 R14 (Addition to R9) : THE GODDESS OF PARMENIDES AND THE BEING OF
HEIDEGGER (3 / 7 Nov 2009)
*******************************************************************************************
TARGET
ARTICLE 113 :
COMMENTARIES
on TA 113 :
TA 113 C1 by Fritz G. Wallner : CULTURE
AND SCIENCE. THE METHODOLOGICAL APPROACH (2004 / 14 March 2009)
TA 113 C2 by Zvi Lothane : ( C’EST LA
METHODE ) (10 / 14 March 2009)
TA 113 C3 by Herbert FJ Muller : WALLNER’S CONSTRUCTIVE
REALISM AND ZERO-DERIVATION (0-D) STRUCTURING (6 / 11 April 2009)
TA 113 C4 by Herbert FJ Muller : TAO
AND THE UNSTRUCTURED (25 April / May 2009)
TA 113 C5 by Herbert FJ Muller : THE UNSTRUCTURED IN EASTERN EPISTEMOLOGY (12
/ 16 May 2009)
*******************************************************************************************
TARGET
ARTICLE 114 :
COMMENTARIES
on TA 114 :
*******************************************************************************************
TARGET
ARTICLE 115 :
COMMENTARIES
on TA 115 :
TA 115 C1 by Gary Schuborg
: ( BELIEF, FAITH, RELIGION ) (28 May /
13 June 2009)
TA 115 C2 by Maurice
McCarthy : PSYCHE AND
PNEUMA ( 13 / 20 June 2009)
TA 115 C3 by Maurice McCarthy : APOLOGY
(27 June / 4 July 2009)
RESPONSES by
Zvi Lothane :
TA 115 R1 to McCarthy (C2) : ( DISCUSSION ) (18 / 27 June 2009)
TA 115 R2 to McCarthy (C3) : (THANKS)
(2 July / 8 August 2009)
*******************************************************************************************