TA65 by Edgar Paternina : FISICA, EDGAR MORIN Y EL PENSAMIENTO COMPLEJO. INTRODUCCION : EL PENSAMIENTO COMPLEJO Y LA CRISIS DE LA FISICA (16 September / 30 November 2003) English Translation.doc of TA 65 or as Acrobat file

COMMENTARIES on TA65 :

TA65 C1 Muller : PATERNINA AND MORIN : 0-D FALLBACK OF COMPLEXITY (November 2003 / 14 December 2003)
TA65 C2 Archambeault (to C1) : (PATERNINA, MORIN, AND 0-D) (15 / 21 December 2003)
TA65 C3 Wood (to C1, Muller) : EVOLUTION AND REVELATION ( 1 / 18 January 2004 )

RESPONSES by Edgar Paternina

TA65 R1 to C1 (Muller) : ( PHYSICS AND COMPLEX THINKING ) (Dec 03 / 11 Jan 2004)

*******************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 66

TA66 by Germano D'Abramo : A THOUGHT EXPERIMENT ON CONSCIOUSNESS (6 / 15 / 21 December 2003)

COMMENTARIES on TA66 :

TA66 C1 Adams : CAN SCIENTIFIC THINKING CHARACTERIZE CONSCIOUSNESS ? (24 Dec / 11 January 2004)
TA66 C2 Wood : ( SELF, MIND, BRAIN ) ( 28 Dec 2003 / 18 Jan 2004 )
TA66 C3 Fisher : SCIENTIFIC THINKING AND CONSCIOUSNESS (11 / 18 January 2004)
TA66 C4 Adams (to R1, and to C3 by Fisher) : (SCIENCE, MATERIALISM, AND SUBJECTIVITY) (17 / 31 January 2004)
TA66 C5 van der Meijden : SCIENCE AND CONSCIOUSNESS (17 / 31 January 2004)

RESPONSES by Germano d'Abramo

TA66 R1 to Adams (C1) : SCIENTIFIC THINKING AND CONSCIOUSNESS (13 / 18 January 2003)
TA66 R2 to Adams (C4) : SCIENCE, MATERIALISM, AND SUBJECTIVITY (17 / 2W1 February 2004)

*******************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 67

TA67 by Thomas Metzinger : PHENOMENAL TRANSPARENCY AND COGNITIVE SELF-REFERENCE (Fall 2003 / 31 January 2004)

COMMENTARIES on TA67 :

TA67 C1 by Muller : WE STRUCTURE SELVES AND OTHER ENTITIES (6 / 14 February 2004)
TA67 C2 van der Meijden : REAL AND FICTION (21 / 28 February 2004)
TA67 C3 van der Meijden : WHO DESIGNED THE CHESSBOARD ? (13 Febr / 6 March 2004)
TA67 C4 Archambeault : SCIENCE AND REALITY (19 March / 4 April 2004)
TA67 C5 Muller : STRUCTURING REALITY : SCIENCE AND RELIGION ( 21 March / 17 April 2004 )
TA67 C6 Johnson : NATURALISM ? (23 March / 10 April 2004)
TA67 C7 Bone : PHILOSOPHY OF REALITY (28 March / 10 April 2004)
TA67 C9 Sebastian to Archambeault (C4) : SCIENCE AND REALITY (3 / 24 April 2004)
TA67 C10 Wood to Archambeault (C4) : ( SCIENCE AND REALITY ) (5 / 24 April 2004)
TA67 C11 vdMeijden to Muller : REALITY IN SCIENCE AND RELGION (16 April / 1 May 2004)
TA67 C12 Archambeault to Wood (C10) : SCIENCE AND REALITY (27 April ? 22 May 2004)
TA67 C13 McCarthy : COLOURS OF NATURALISM (May 2004 / 24 May 2004)
TA67 C14 Muller : OPERATIONAL DEFINITION OF METAPHYSICS (16 / 29 May 2004)
YA67 C15 vdMeijden to McCarthy : QUESTION (22 May / 5 June 2004)
TA67 C16 Leifer to Archambeault (C12) : ( SCIENCE AND REALITY ) (21 / 29 May 2004)
TA67 C17 Benjamin to Muller (C14) : OPERATIONAL DEFINITION OF METAPHYSICS (28 May / 5 June 2004)
TA67 C18 Archambeault to Leifer (C16) : THIS IS THEIR PROPOSAL (28 May / 5 June 2004)
TA67 C19 vdMeijden to Muller (C14) : OPERATIONAL DEFINITION OF METAPHYSICS (28 May / 5 June 2004)
TA67 C20 Muller to vdMeijden (C19) : LANGUAGE, EXISTENCE, AND NAGEL (28 May / 12 June 2004)
TA67 C21 Johnson to Muller (C14) : METAPHYSICS IN CONTEXT (3 / 12 June 2004)
TA67 C22 Leifer to Archambeault (C18) : ( ELIMINATING THE FIRST CAUSE ) (4 / 19 June 2004)
TA67 C23 vdMeijden to Archambeault (C18) : THE UNIVERSE IN METABOLISM (4 / 19 June 2004)
TA67 C24 Muller to Johnson (C21) : PROCESS PHYSICS WITH PEOPLE (6 / 19 June 2004)
TA67 C25 vdMeijden to Muller (C20) : COME INTO THE PARLOUR ..... (11 / 26 June 2004)
TA67 C26 Archambeault to vdMeijden (C23) : THE UNIVERSE IN METABOLISM (18 / 26 June 2004)
TA67 C27 Johnson to Muller : PEOPLE : CREATIVE COSMIC AGENCY (20 June / 3 July 2004)
TA67 C28 Lothane to Muller (C14) : ( OPERATIONAL DEFINIUTION OF METAPHYSICS ) (21 June / 3 July 2004)
TA67 C29 vdMeijden to Archambeault (C26) : QUIDDITAS ? (24 June / 24 July 2004)
TA67 C30 McCarthy to vdMeijden (C15) : QUESTIONING ? (27 June / 24 July 2004)
TA67 C31 Muller to Lothane : ( OPERATIONAL DEFINITION OF METAPHYSICS ) (22 July / 7 August 2004)
TA67 C32 vdMeijden to McCarthy : ( QUESTIONING ? ) (23 July / 7 August 2004)
TA67 C33 Lothane to Muller : ( OPERATIONAL DEFINITION OF METAPHYSICS ) (14 / 28 August 2004)
TA67 C34 Patlavskiy to Metzinger : LIVING CORPSES AND THE THEORY OF MENTAL RREPRESENTATIONS (4 / 9 Oct 2004)

*******************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 68

TA68 by Peter Beamish : THE DUALITY OF "TIME" (30 November 2003 / 21 February 2004)

COMMENTARIES on TA68 :

TA68 C1 by vd Meijden : THE DUALITY OF WHAT ? (21 Febr / 6 March 2004)
TA68 C2 by Muller : TIME STRUCTURING IN COMPLETE EXPERIENCE (29 Febr / 6 March 2004)
TA68 C3 vdMeijden : ( SCIENCE REALITY : TIME STRUCTURING ) (5 / 20 March 2004)
TA68 C4 Archambeault : TIME AND CONSCIOUSNESS (13 / 27 March 2004)
TA68 C5 Muller (to R2,R3,R4) : TIME CONCEPTS IN YOUR MIND (14 / 27 March 2004)
TA68 C6 Roll : ( ANIMAL CONTACT ) (14 March / 3 April 2004)
TA68 C7 Wood : ( THE DUALITY OF "TIME" ) (16 March / 3 April 2004)
TA68 C8 Raman : VARIETY OF REALITIES (19 / 27 March 2004)
TA68 C9 Pivnicki : MICHELANGELO : ETERNITY, TIME, AND SPACE (21 March / 3 April 2004)
TA68 C10 Bone to Raman : ( VARIETY OF REALITIES ) (28 March / 17 April 2004)
TA68 C11 vdMeijden to Wood : ( DUALITY OF TIME ) (2 / 17 April 2004)
TA68 C12 Muller (to R5) : (TIME CONCEPTS IN YOUR MIND) (10 April / 1 May 2004)
TA68 C13 Wood to Pivnicki : ( MICHELANGELO : ETERNITY, TIME, AND SPACE ) (2 / 17 April 2004)
TA68 C14 vdMeijden to Bone and Raman (C10) : VARIETY OF REALITIES (16 April / 8 May 2004)
TA68 C15 Wood to vdMeijden : DUALITY OF TIME (16 April / 8 May 2004)
TA68 C16 vdMeijden to Wood (C15) : USING A MACHETE ! (7 / 22 May 2004)
TA68 C17 McCarthy : COLOURS OF NATURALISM (May 2004 / 24 May 2004)

RESPONSES by Peter Beamish :

TA68 R1 Beamish : ( ANIMAL CONTACT ) (23 / 28 February 2004)
TA68 R2 to Muller (C2) : ( TIME STRUCTURING IN COMPLETE EXPERIENCE ) (6/13 March 2004)
TA68 R3 to C2 : ( TIME STRUCTURING IN COMPLETE EXPERIENCE ) (8 / 13 March 2004)
TA68 R4 to C2 : ( SCIENCE REALITY ; TIME STRUCTURING, PART 3 ) (11 / 20 March 2004)
TA68 R5 to C5 ( TIME IN MIND ) (29 March / 17 April 2004)
TA68 R6 to C7, Wood : THE DUALITY OF "TIME" (5/24 April 2004)
TA 68 R7 Beamish : ( TIME DOES NOT FLOW ) (16 April / 1 May 2004)
TA68 R8 Beamish : ON "TIME" AND "DURATION", "READINGS" AND "MEASUREMENTS" (12/19 June 2004)
TA68 R9-11 Beamish : ( ON TIME ) (posted 24 July 2004)
TA68 R12 Beamish : EUREKA ! A NEW DEFINITION OF "RHYTHM BASED TIME, RBT" (6 / 11 Septemnber 2004)
TA68 R13 Beamish : SPACE VERSUS "TIME" (19 / 27 November 2004)
TA68 R14 Beamish : "TIME's" DUALITIES (3 / 18 December 2004)

*******************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 69

TA69 by Gonzalo Munevar : EVOLUTIONARY RELATIVISM (30 January / 6 March 2004)

COMMENTARIES on TA69 :

YA69 C1 van der Meijden : ( SCIENTIFIC REALITY : ) HISTORICAL REALISM (5 / 27 March 2004)
TA69 C2 Bone : CHALLENGE ON SCIENTIFIC REALITY (5/13 March 2003)
TA69 C3 Bone : ( SCIENCE REALITY : EVOLUTIONARY RELATIVISM ) (9 / 20 March 2004)
TA69 C4 Muller : SCIENCE REALITY : THE FIRST-PERSON IN THE WORLD OF SCIENCE (8 / 20 March 2004)
TA69 C5 v d Meijden to Bone, C2 : WATCHERS ON THE QUAI (12 March / 3 April 2004)
TA69 C6 Beamish : REALITY : "SUBJECTIVE VS. OBJECTIVE" (13 March / 3 April 2004)
TA69 C7 Wood : ( SCIENCE REALITY : YES BUT NO EVOLUTION PLEASE ) (13 / 20 March 2004)
TA69 C8 McCormick : ( CHALLENGE ON SCIENTIFIC REALITY ) (12 / 20 March 2004)
TA69 C9 McCarthy : ON SCIENTIFIC REALITY (15 / 20 March 2004)
TA69 C10 vGlasersfeld to McCarthy (C9) : KNOWLEDGE WITHOUT KNOWER ? (19 / 27 March 2004)
TA69 C11 McCarthy to Wood (C7) : OBJECTIVE REALITY (20 / 27 March 2004)
TA69 C12 Bone to Muller, C4 : ( SCIENCE REALITY ) (21 March / 10 April)
TA69 C13 Boyd to vGlasersfeld (C10) and McCarthy (C9) : KNOWLEDGE WITHOUT KNOWER ? (26 March / 3 April 2004)
TA69 C14 Barnett to vGlasersfeld : KNOWLEDGE WITHOUT KNOWER ? (28 March / 10 April 2004)
TA69 C15 Bone to vdMeijden (C1) : HISTORICAL REALISM (28 March / 24 April 2004)
TA69 C16 McCarthy to vGlasersfeld (C10) : YES, INDEED, KNOWLEDGE WITHOUT A KNOWER ! (27 March / 10 April 2004)
TA69 C17 Muller to McCarthy (C9 and C16) : REALITY AND REFERENTS (31 March / 24 April 2004)
TA69 C18 Morozzo to McCarthy (C9) : ( ON SCIENTIFIC REALITY ) (2 / 10 April 2004)
TA69 C19 vdMeijden to Beamish (C6) : REALITY SUBJECTIVE VS OBJECTIVE (2 / 17 April 2004)
TA69 C20 Wood to Pivnicki (C9) ( MICHELANGELO : ETERNITY, TIME, AND SPACE ) (2 / 17 April 2004)
TA69 C21 vdMeijden to Boyd (13) : KNOWLEDGE WITHOUT KNOWER ?
TA69 C22 vGlasersfeld to Barnett (C14) : MY "SUBJECT" (9 / 24 April 2004)
TA69 C23 Wood to vGlasersfeld (C10) and McCarthy (C9) : KNOWLEDGE WITHOUT KNOWER ? (3 / 17 April 2004)
TA69 C24 vdMeijden to Bone (C12) : THAT WORD REALITY (9 April / 1 May 2004)
TA69 C25 vGlasersfeld to McCarthy (C16) : WHAT "EXISTS" ? (9 April / 1 May 2004)
TA69 C26 vdMeijden to Bone (C15) : HISTORICAL REALISM (23 April / 8 May 2004)
TA69 C27 vdMeijden to Muller (C17) : WEIRD AND TRUE ? (23 April / 8 May 2004)
TA69 C28 Archambeault to Bone (C15) : HISTORICAL REALISM (26 April / 15 May 2004)
TA69 C29 Barnett to vGlasersfeld (C22) : ( MY SUBJECT ) (13/15 May 2004 )
TA69 C30 McCarthy : COLOURS OF NATURALISM (May 2004 / 24 May 2004)
TA69 C31 McCarthy to Morozzo, Muller, vGlasersfeld : VARIOUS REPLIES (16 / 29 May 2004)
TA69 C32 Andemicael : EVOLUTION (4 / 18 January 2005)
TA69 C33 vdMeijden to Munevar : EVOLUTION (21 January / 26 February 2005)
TA69 C34 Andemicael (to R1) : IS THE WORLD THREE-DIMENSIONAL OR FOUR-DIMENSIONAL (24/29 Jan 2005)
TA69 C35 vdMeijden : MORE WEIRD ? (25 Febr / 26 March 2005)
TA69 C36 vdMeijden : NOTES AND QUERIES (25 March / 2 April 2005)

RESPONSES by Gonzalo Munevar :

TA69 R1 to Andemicael (C32) : EVOLUTION (14 / 22 January 2005)
TA69 R2 to Andemicael (C34) : ( IS THE WORLD THREE-DIMENSIONAL OR FOUR-DIMENSIONAL ? ) (31 Jan / 5 Febr 2005)

*******************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 70

TA70 by Glenn C Wood : THE LIMITS OF HISTORICAL DETERMINATENESS APPLIED TO EVOLUTIONISM (19 April / 1 May 2004)

COMMENTARIES on TA70 :

TA70 C1 Adams (to be posted later)

TA70 C2 & C3 Johnson : ( EVOLUTION, JASPERS, AND EINSTEIN ) (21 April / 15 May 2004)
TA70 C4 Muller : EVOLVING QUESTIONS (1 / 15 May 2004)
TA70 C5 Benjamin : ( EVOLUTION ) (16 / 22 May 2004)
TA79 C6 Johnson and X : EVOLUTION; CONTENT AND PROCESS PERSPECTIVES (17 / 29 May 2004)
TA70 C7 vdMeijden to R2 : ( CONCISENESS ) (30 Sept / 16 October 2004)
TA70 C8 Muller to R3 : REVELATIONS AND COUNTERREVELATIONS (14 / 16 October 2004)
TA70 C9 vdMeijden to Muller and Wood (C8, R3) ( ON CONCISENESS, MENHIRS, AND THE FREEDOM OF ASSOCIATIONS ) (15/23 Oct 2004)
TA70 C10 vdMeijden to Wood : ( CLAIM ) (10 Dec 2004 / 15 Jan 2005)
TA70 C11 J Johnson to R5 : TWO BOXES (1 / 12 February 2005)
TA70 C12 J S Johnson to R5 : MYTH AND SURVIVAL (14 / 26 February 2005)

RESPONSES by Glenn C Wood :

TA70 R1 to Muller (C4) : ( EVOLVING QUESTIONS ) (19 / 25 September 2004)
TA70 R2 to Muller (R1) : ( TO BE CONCISE OR NOT TO BE CONCISE ) (25 September / 2 October 2004)
TA70 R3 further to R2 : ( THE RULES ) (16 October 2004)
TA70 R4 to vdMeijden, C9 : ( RESPONSE ) (2 / 11 December 2004)
TA79 R5 to J Johnson : ( EVOLUTION, JASPERS, AND EINSTEIN ) (22 January 2005)

*******************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 71

TA71 by Zvi Lothane : FREUD'S 1895 PROJECT : FROM MIND TO BRAIN AND BACK AGAIN (1998 / 29 May 2004)

COMMENTARIES on TA71 :

TA71 C1 by vdMeijden : CRACKING THE COSMIC EGG ? (29 May / 12 June 2004)
TA72 C2 by Muller : FREUD'S OBJECTS ABD REALITY (20 / 26 June 2004)

RESPONSES by Zvi Lothane :

TA72 R1 to vdMeijden : ( CRACKING THE COSMIC EGG ? ) (19 / 26 June 2004)
TA72 R2 to Muller (C2) : FREUD'S OBJECTS AND REALITY

*******************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 72

TA72 by Jerome Blackman : THE RELATION BETWEEN MATHEMATICS AND PHYSICS (Spring 2004 / 19 June 2004)

COMMENTARIES on TA72 :

TA72 C1 Bindeman : ON THE RELATION OF MATH AND PHYSICS (Spring 2004 / 26 June 2003)
TA72 C2 Bindeman : ( REALITY AND MEANING ) (Spring 2004, posted 3 July 2004)
TA72 C3 vdMeijden : ( THE RELATIONSHIP BERTWEEN MATHEMATICS AND SCIENCE ) (18 June / 3 July 2004)
TA72 C4 vdMeijden : ( MATHEMATICS AND PHYSICS ) (19 June / 31 July 2004)
TA72 C5 Muller : PROCEDURES AND STRUCTURES FOR OBJECTS AND FOR COUNTING (18 / 31 July 2004)
TA72 C6 Patlavskiy to vdMeijden : ( MORE QUESTIONS ) (14 August 2004)
TA72 C7 & C9 vdMeijden to Patlavskiy and Blackman : A PROPOPSAL and RELEVANCY !! (13 August / 11 September 2004)
TA72 C8 Muller (to R3 by Blackman) : REALITY WITH AND WITHOUT SUBJECTS (11 September 2004)
TA72 C10 Patlavskiy to vdMeijden (C7) : ( MORE QUESTIONS ) (Sept 2004 / 2 October 2004)
TA72 C11 Muller (to R4) : ON THE FUNCTION OF MODELS (18/30 October 2004)
TA72 C12 vdMeijden to Patlavskiy : ( MORE QUESTIONS ) (30 Sept / 30 Oct 2004)
TA72 C13 Muller to R5 : MATH AND METAPHYSICS (26 / 30 October 2004)
TA72 C14 Patlavskiy to vdMeijden (C12) : QUESTIONS (1 / November 2004)
TA72 C15 vdMeijden to Patlavskiy : QUESTIONS (5 / 20 Nove3mber 2004)

RESPONSES by Jerome Blackman :

TA72 R1 to Bindeman (C1) : ( REALITY AND MIND ) (Spring 2004, posted 3 July 2004)
TA72 R2 to Bindeman : ( DOES REALITY EXIST ? ) (Spring 2004 / 24 July 2004)
TA72 R3 Blackman to vdMeijden and Muller : ( MATHEMATICS AND PHYSICS ) (30 August / 4 Sept 2004)
TA72 R4 Blackman to Muller (C8) : ( REALITY WITH AND WITHOUT SUBJECTS ) (17 / 23 October 2004)
TA72 R5 to Muller (C11) : ( MATH, PHYSICS, AND METAPHYSICS ) (25 / 30 October 2004)

*******************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 73

TA73 by Ernst von Glasersfeld : THE CONSTRUCTIVIST APPROACH : TOWARD A THEORY OF REPRESENTATIONS (21 November 1985 / 31 July 2004)

COMMENTARIES on TA73 :

RESPONSES by Ernst von Glasersfeld :

TA73 R1 to vdMeijden (C1) : ( MIND REVISITED ) (22 / 28 August 2004)
TA73 R2 to Cull (C2) : ( THEORY OF REPRESENTATIONS ) (22 / 28 August 2004)
TA73 R3 to Adams (C3) : REPRESENTATIOIN AND MEMORY (21 August / 4 Sept 2004)
TA73 R4 to Patlavskiy (C4) : THE CONSTRUCTIVIST APPROACH (22 Auguat / 4 Sept 2004)
TA73 R5 to Lothane (C5) : THEORY OF REPRESENTATIONS (27 August / 4 Sept 2004)
TA73 R6 to Muller (C6) : PARMENIDES' TRAP (4 / 11 September 2004)
TA73 R7 to Blackman (Sundararajan and Stern) : ( ON BERKELEY ) (4 / 11 September 2004)
TA73 R8 to Geelan (C11) : LEARNING, CYBERNETICS, HOLOGRAMS (8 / 18 September 2004)
TA73 R9 to DK Johnson (C16) : "FALLIBILISTIC" CRITICISM ? (13 / 25 September 2004)
TA73 R10 to McCarthy, C19 : REPRESENTATION AND COMMUNICATION (30 Sept / 2 October 2004)
TA73 R11 to Kozloff, C15 : OLD CERTAINLY, BUT NOT QUITE DEAD YET (9 October 2004)
TA73 R12 to DK Johnson (C34) ( THEORY OF REPRESENTATIONS ) (15 / 23 October 2004)
TA73 R13 to Lothane (C47) : (REPRESENTATIONS) (17 / 22 September 2007)

*******************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 74

TA74 by Serge Patlavskiy : ARE THE SKEPTICS' AIMS SCIENTIFICALLY CORRECT ? (25 August / 18 September 2004)

COMMENTARIES on TA74 :

TA74 C1 vdMeijden : QUO VADIS ? (17 September / 2 October 2004)
TA74 C2 Draganescu : ARE THE SKEPTICS' AIMS SCIENTIFICALLY CORRECT ? (14/20 November 2004)
TA74 C3 Gopych : DOES PRINCIPALLY ANOTHER SYSTEM OF PROOFS IS ACTUALLY REQUIRED IN THE FIELD OF CONSCIOUSNESS STURDIES ? (17/20 November 2004)

*******************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 75

TA75 by David Kenneth Johnson : THE VIEW FROM SOMEWHERE : A PHILOSOPHICAL CRITIQUE OF RADICAL CONSTRUCTIVISM (1996 / 9 Oct 2004)

COMMENTARIES on TA75 :

TA75 C1 vdMeijden : WORLD MODELS (8 / 23 October 2004)
TA75 C2 Adams : A PARTIAL DEFENSE OF RADICAL CONSTRUCTIVISM (8 / 23 October 2004)
TA75 C3 Muller : SUBJECT-OBJECT APORIA AND REALIST MAGIC (20 September / 23 October 2004)
TA75 C4 vdMeijden (to C3, Muller) : TO BE OR NOT TO BE (22 / 3) Oct 2004)
TA75 C5 vdMeijden (to C2, Adams) : ANTICATEGORIA, OR AI AND CONSCIOUSNESS. An interdisciplinary Comment. (24 October / 6 November 2004)
TA75 C6 vGlasersfeld : THE VIEW FROM HERE (september 1996 / 6 November 2004)
TA75 C7 Muller : ONTOLOGICAL TRAP (30 November / 18 December 2004)
TA75 C8 Chumakin to Johnson, TA75 and vGlasersfeld, C6 : MODEL CONFUSION (29 Nov / 11 December 2004)
TA75 C9 Silliman : ("THE VIEW FROM SOMEWHERE") (6 / 11 December 2004)
TA75 C10 vdMeijden (to C9, Silliman) : ( VIEW FROM SOMEWHERE ) (10 Dec 2004 / 29 Jan 2005)
TA75 C11 Silliman : ( MODEL CONFUSION ) (13 / 18 December 2004)
TA75 C12 M Freeman : ( CONSTRUCTIVISM ) (14 / 18 December 2004)
TA75 C13 Chumakin to Silliman (C11) : (MODEL CONFUSION) (17 Dec 04 / 8 Jan 2005)
TA75 C14 vdMeijden vdMeijden : WORDS, WORDS, WORDS (10 December 2004 / 29 January 2005)
TA75 C15 Barnett to Silliman : ("THE VIEW FROM SOMEWHERE") (20 Dec 2004 / 15 January 2005)
TA75 C16 McCarthy to Freeman (C12) THE TOUCHSTONE (31 Dec 2004 / 22 January 2005)
TA75 C17 Muller to DK Johnson : STRUCTURING AND TRUSTING REALITY (Jan / 15 Jan 2005)
TA75 C18 Silliman to Chumakin : ( MODEL CONFUSION ) (10 / 22 January 2005)
TA75 C19 vdMeijden : ( TRUSTING REALITY ) (14 / 29 January 2005)
TA75 C20 vdMeijden : UNDER standing (16 / 29 January 2005)
TA75 C21 Wood : THE IMMERSION OF THE MULLER/ vGLASERSFELD EPISTEMOLOGY IN THE HISTORIC PREEXISTING RIVER OF LIFE (21 January / 5 February 2005)
TA75 C22 Muller to R5 : EVOLUTION OF METAPHYSICS (30 Jan / 12 February 2005)
TA75 C23 Chumakin to Silliman : ( MODEL CONFUSION ) (24 / 29 January 2005)
TA75 C24 Freeman to Chumakin : ( MODEL CONFUSION ) (28 Jan / 5 February 2005)
TA75 C25 vdMeijden to C22, Muller : ( EVOLUTION OF METAPHYSICS ) (11 Febr / 12 March 2005)
TA75 C26 Muller to R6 : HOW TO KNOW THINGS-IN-THEMSELVES (17 Febr / 5 March 2005)
TA75 C27 Wood to C22 : METAPHYSICAL MINDFULNESS VS. THE DYNAMICS OF THE SUBJECT-OBJECT POLARITY (19/26 Feb 05)
TA75 C28 Muller to R7 : 0-D ENCOMPASSES REALISM (28 March / 9 Apr4il 2005)
TA75 C29 vdMeijden to Muller, C28 : ( 0-D ENCOMPASSES REALISM ) (8 / 16 April 2005)
TA75 C30 Silliman to Muller, C28 : ( RHETORIC AND TERMINOLOGY ) (13 / 16 April 2005)
TA75 C31 Muller to Silliman (C30) : RECONCILIATION OR JUMP TO CONCLUSIONS ? (21 / 23 April 2005)
TA75 C32 Hontela (on Hauser et al, C22) ( EVOLUTION OF LANGUAGE ) (March 2005 / 23 April 2005)
TA75 C33 Hontela (to Muller, C22) : ( EVOLUTION OF METAPHYSICS ) (March 2005 / 30 April 2005)
TA75 C34 Muller (to R8) : TO LEAP, OR NOT TO LEAP (26 April / 21 May 2005)
TA75 C35 Nixon (to Hontela C32) : [CULTURAL] EVOLUTION OF LANGUAGE (27 / 30 April 2005)
TA75 C36 Nixon (to R9) : ( ? ZERO-DERIVATION DE-ZEROED ? ) (30 April / 7 May 2005)
TA75 C37 Weedon : BEDROCK (6 / 14 May 2005)
TA75 C38 Silliman : RECONCILIATION (10 / 21 May 2005)
TA75 C39 vGlasersfeld : TACTICS REVEALED (30 April / 21 May 2005)
TA75 C40 Muller to Silliman (C38) : RECONCILIATION (16 / 28 May 2005)
TA75 C41 Suydam : THE ILLUSION OF SELF (18 / 21 May 2005)
TA75 C42 vdMeijden : ( RECONCILIATION ) (28 May / 25 June 2005)
TA75 C43 Bone to R9 : ON KNOWING (17 / 25 March 2006)

RESPONSES by DK Johnson :

TA75 R1 to Muller, C3 : SUBJECT-OBJECT FUSION AND IDEALIST METAPHYSICS (28 Nov / 11 December 2004)
TA75 R2 to vGlasersfeld, C6 : "'USELESS' DEFENSES AND PARTIAL REPLIES" (28 November / 11 December 2004)
TA75 R3 to Adams, C2: "REALIST INFIGHTING" (29 November / 11 December 2004)
TA75 R4 to Muller, C7 : BETWEEN MIR, HIR, AND SIR: CONSTRUCTIVISM'S PRONOUN PROBLEM (Dec 04 / 8 Jan 2005)
TA75 R5 to Muller C17 : ANTI-SIR ? NO SIR ! (18 / 22 January 2005)
TA75 R6 to Muller (C22) and vGlasersfeld : MAKE-BELIEVE METAPHYSICS (15 / 19 February 2005)
TA75 R7 to Muller (C22 and C26) : THE METAPHYSICS OF EXPERIENCE (24 March / 2 April 2005)
TA75 R8 to Muller (C28 and C31) : ZERO-DERIVATION DE-ZEROED (25 / 30 April 2005)
TA75 R9 to KJF : ON KNOWING (14 / 18 March 2006)

*******************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 76

TA76 by Raf Vanderstraeten and Gert Biesta : CONSTRUCTIVISM, EDUCATIONAL RESEARCH, AND JOHN DEWEY (8 Sept / 6 November 2004)

COMMENTARIES on TA76 :

TA76 C1 Muller : DEWEY'S LIMITED PRAGMATISM. (October / 13 November 2004)
TA76 C2 vdMeijden : EX CATHEDRA (5 / 13 November 2004)
TA76 C3 vdMeijden to Muller, C1 : 0-D, ETC., & UNSTRUCTURED EXPERIENCE (17 Nov / 11 December 2004)
TA76 C4 vdMeijden to R1 : MORE MUSINGS (26 Nov 2004 / 5 February 2005)
TA76 C5 vGlasersfeld : CYBERNETICS AND CONSTRUCTIVISM (1 / 4 December 2004)

RESPONSES by Raf Vanderstraeten :

R1 to C1, Muller : ( CONSTRUCTIVISM ) (23 / 27 November 2004)
R2 to vGlasersfeld, C5 : ( CYBERNETICS AND CONSTRUCTIVISM ) (9 / 11 December 2004)

*******************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 77

TA77 by Timo Jarvilehto : IS THERE AN ULTIMATE ESSENCE OF MATTER ? (20 November 2004)

COMMENTARIES on TA77 :

RESPONSES by Jarvilehto :

TA77 R1 to Maataanen, C6 : EMBODIED MIND WITH NO INTERACTION (6 / 11 December 2004)
TA77 R2 to Chumakin, C4 : SOME CLARIFICATIONS (6 / 11 December 2004)

*******************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 78

TA78 by Herbert FJ Muller : PEOPLE, TOOLS, AND AGENCY : WHO IS THE KYBERNETES ? (Nov / 18 December 2004)
Also included are discussions about the enlarged version (78CF) of this paper (same title) in "Constructivist Foundations", 1.1, 1 Nov 2005.
http://www.univie.ac.at/constructivism/journal/articles/1.1.muller.pdf

COMMENTARIES on TA78 :

RESPONSES by Herbert FJ Muller :

TA78 R1 to McCarthy (C2 & C5) : ONTOLOGY (22 Dec 2004 / 22 January 2005)
TA78 R2 to Chumakin : REALITY AND GHOSTS (29 Dec 2004 / 29 January 2005)
TA78 R3 to vGlasersfeld (C8) : THE SUBJECT-OBJECT SPLIT TOOL (16 / 22 January 2005)
TA78 R4 to McCarthy (C17) : TRUST VERSUS KNOWLEDGE (26 February 2005)
TA78 R5 to Adams (C15) : OBJECTIVE EXPLANATIONS ARE INSIDE 0-D (12 Febr / 5 March 2005)
TA78 R6 to Pivnicki (C24) : REINER ON ARISTOTLE'S METAPHYSICS (1 / 12 March 2005)
TA78 R7 to vdMeijden (C27) : FOR 0-D METHOD (ON FEYERABEND) (14 / 26 March 2005)
TA78 R8 to Wood : 0-D FOR EVOLUTION AND RELIGION (THE VATICAN AND JASPERS) (23 March / 2April 2005)
TA78 R9 (to an article by Portela) : THE 0-D UMBRELLA IN EDUCATION (ABSOLUTES IF NECESSARY BUT NOT NECESSARILY ABSOLUTES) (7 / 30 April 2005)
TA78 R10 : 0-D IN PSYCHIATRIC THEORY ( ON KENDLER'S PHILOSOPHICAL STRUCTURE ) (15 / 23 April 2005)
TA78 R11 : DAWKINS AND MCGRATH : THE LEAP TO CERTAINTY IN SCIENCE AND RELIGION ()April 2005 / 7 May 2005)
TA78 R12 to Dykstra (C32) : EDUCATION : CONSTRUCTION BY INDIVIDUALS VERSUS STRUCTURE-TEACHING (30 April / 14 May 2005)
TA78 R13 to Nixon (c33) : EPISTEMOLOGICAL ASYMMETRY (1 / 14 May 2005)
TA78 R14 : MID-COURSE CORRECTION (ON DIETTRICH'S EPISTEMOLOGY) (12 / 28 May 2005)
TA78 R15 to Wood : JASPERS ON EVOLUTION (12 May / 2 July 2005)
TA78 R16 : ON THE ANTI-CONSTRUCTIVIST VIEW OF ROBERT NOLA (22 / 28 May 2005)
TA78 R17 to Wood (C10) : ROADMAP TO AGREEMENT ? (16 July / 13 August 2005)
TA78 R18 to J Johnson (C53) : REAL GREEN LIGHT (31 Oct / 12 Nov 2005)
TA78 R19 to J Johnson (C54) : WHY CAN BE A METAPHYSICAL QUESTION (7 / 19 November 2005)
TA78 R20 to Patlavskiy (C55) : RORTY AND THE SENSITIVE PEAR-TREE (16 / 26 November 2005)
TA78 R21 to J Johnson (C56 & 57) THE SUBJECT NEEDS TO BE SPECIFIED (22 Nov / 3 Dec 2005)
TA78 R22 to DK Johnson and M Silliman (C37 to TA 81-82) (26 Nov / 10 Dec 2005)
TA78 R23 to Bone : BOOTSTRAP AND FEEDBACK (10 / 17 December 2005)
TA78 R24 to Patlavskiy (C62) : THE QUESTION OF OBJECTIVITY (6 / 10 December 2005)
TA78 R25 to Nixon (C61) : WHITEHEAD AND THE SUBJECT (15 / 24 December 2005)
TA78 R26 to Silliman : TRANSCENDENCE (ON EMERGENCE OF MIND IN CRITICAL REALISM) (23 / 31 December 2005)
TA78 R27 to McCarthy (C65) : ON SELLARS AND SPACE IN MIND (28 Dec 2005 / 7 Jan 2006)
TA78 R28 to Modell (C72) : HOLISTIC SCIENCE (GENETICS, ETHICS, AND UNITY OF PROCESS) (31 Dec 2005 / 14 Jan 2006)
TA78 R29 to Nixon (C73) : TO QUOTE OR NOT TO QUOTE, AND MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING (6 / 21 January 2006)
TA78 R30 to Weedon (C78) : ROSES, ELEPHANTS, AND MONKS ( RELIABILITY AND MEANING ) (25 Jan / 11 Febr 2006)
TA78 R31 to Moeller (C83) : WORKING-STRUCTURES (6 / 8 July 2006)

*******************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 79

TA79 by Joseph S Johnson : NEW PROCESS THEORY AND CONSEQUENCES (28 January / 5 February 2005)

COMMENTARIES on TA79 :

TA79 C1 vdMeijden (in 3 parts) (ON STAPP AND OTHERS) (29 Jan / 19 Febr 2005)
TA79 C2 Weedon : ( CONFUCIANISM ) (4 / 19 February 2005)
TA79 C3 Muller : WHERE IS THE PROCESS ? (19 February 2005)
TA79 C4 Beamish : EINSTEIN'S POTENTIAL ERROR (1905), THE "A-O" METAPHOR, SPECIAL RELATIVITY (100 YEARS LATER), EXPLAINED DUFFERENTLY (9 / 19 February 2005)
TA79 C5 Wood : THE SCIENTIFIC ATTITUDE VS THE FALLACIES OF EVOLUTIONISM (Febr / 5 March 2005)
TA79 C6 Patlavskiy : THERE ARE MORE PHILOSOPHICAL ERRORS (14 / 19 February 2005)
TA79 C7 Weedon : WHERE IS THE PROCESS ? (18/26 February 2005)
TA79 C8 Muller (to R1) : QM AND LEGGETT (24 Febr / 19 March 2005)
TA79 C9 Beamish : SUBJECTIVITY UNLOCKED (24 Febr / 5 March 2005)
TA79 C10 Weedon : DOWN AND DIRTY (26 February 2005)
TA78 C11 (to C3) : NOTE ON PROCESS, I'M NOT SO SURE ABOUT THE PHYSICS (27 Feb ? 26 March 2005)
TA79 C12 vdMeijden to R2 : PROCESS THEORY (4 / 19 March 2005)
TA79 C13 vdMeijden to Beamish (C9) : SUBJECTIVITY (4 / 19 March 2005)
TA79 C14 vdMeijden to Wood (C5) : ( EVOLUTIONISM ) (4 / 19 March 2005)
TA79 C15 Weedon : SCIENCE SANS CONSCIENCE ... (4 / 12 March 2005)
TA79 C17 Patlavskiy to R3 : ( INCONSISTENCY ) (10 / 19 March 2005)
TA79 C18 vdMeijden to Roberts (C16) : ( EVOLUTIONISM ) (11 / 19 March 2005)
TA79 C20 Wood to Roberts (C16) : QUESTION TO ROBERTS (14 / 19 March 2005)
TA79 C21 vdMeijden : (QM AND LEGGETT) (18 March / 2 April 2005)
TA79 C22 Beamish (to R5) : "GEOMETRIC TIME" IS NOT REAL "TIME" (21 / 26 March 2005)
TA79 C23 Muller to R7 : COSMOS AND CONCEPTOLOGY (2/16 April 2005)
TA79 C24 Weedon : A BRIDGE TOO FAR (1 / 9 April 2005)
TA79 C25 Beamish : "PROPER TIME" DEFINED ! & "RELATIVE TIME" AS POSSIBLY EINSTEIN'S GREATEST INSIGHT (OF ~ 100 YEARS AGO) (6 / 9 April 2005)
TA79 C26 vdMeijden to Beamish (C25) (PROPER TIME) (8 / 16 April 2005)
TA79 C27 vdMeijden to Weedon : A BRIDGE TOO FAR (8 / 16 April 2005)
TA79 C28 Muller (to R9) : REDUNDANT ASSUMPTIONS (28 April / 21 May 2005)
TA79 C29 Wood : AVOIDING MISCHIEVOUS WORDS OF DISTINCTION (7 / 14 May 2005)
TA79 C30 Beamish : ( RELATIVITY AND QM ) (13 / 21 May 2005)
TA79 C31 vdMeijden to R10&11 : ( EVOLUTION AND CREATION ) (28 May / 2 July 2005)
TA79 C32 Wood to Johnson : JASPERS MAN (2 June / 2 July 2005)
TA79 C33 vdMeijden : UNMUDDLING THE MYSTERY (4 / 9 July 2005)
TA79 C34 Andemicael : QUESTION REGARDING EXISTENCE (12 / 23 July 2005)
TA79 C35 Muller to Andemicael : QUESTION OF EXISTENCE (16 July / 6 August 2005)
TA79 C36 Wood (to R12) : BEYOND UNITY OF EXPERIENCE AND THOUGHT (30 July 2005)
TA79 C37 vdMeijden to Andemicael : EXISTENCE (July / 27 August 2005)
TA79 C39 Wood to R15 : PSYCHE - RESPONSIBILITY VS. PETTIFOGGING (11 / 27 August 2005)
TA79 C40 vdMeijden to Roberts : EVOLUTION. ON OBSERVER BIAS (12 Aug / 3 Sept 2005)
TA79 C41 Wood to Roberts : LAMARCK / DARWIN GRADATION QUEST (25 Aug / 10 Sept 2005)

DISCUSSION OF TIME :

TA79 C42 Andemicael : THE RATE OF FLOW OF SUBJECTIVE TIME (12 / 16 September 2006)
TA79 C43 Beamish to Andemicael : THE NON "FLOW OF TIME" (15 / 23 September 2006)
79 C44 vGlasersfeld to Beamish (C43) : QUESTION ABOUT 'FLOW' AND 'CONSTANCY' (23 Sept / 7 Oct 2006)
79 C45 Andemicael : PERCEPTION OF MOTION (2 / 7 October 2006)
79 C46 Beamish to vGlasersfeld : FLOW AND CONSTANCY (6 / 14 October 2006)
79 C47 Beamish to Andemicael : PERCEPTION OF MOTION (6 / 14 October 2006)
79 C48 Muller to Andemicael : FLOW OF EXPERIENCE WITH STATIC ENTITIES (10 / 21 October 2006)
79 C49 Conn Henry to Beamish : PERCEPTION OF MOTION (13 / 21 October 2006)
79 C50 vGlasersfeld to Beamish : AGAIN : FLOW AND CONSTANCY ? (13 / 21 October 2006)
79 C51 Beamish to vGlasersfeld : FLOW AND CONSTANCY (20 / 28 October 2006)
79 C52 Beamish to Conn Henry : PERCEPTION OF MOTION (20 / 28 October 2006)
79 C53 McCarthy to Beamish and vGlasersfeld : A DEFINITION OF TIME (28 October / 4 November 2006)
79 C54 Beamish to vGlasersfeld : A DEFINITION OF TIME (4 / 11 November 2006)
79 C55 McCarthy toBeamish and Muller : COMMENTS ON FLOW (16 / 18 Nov 2006)
79 C56 vGlasersfeld to McCarthy : MY WAY OF GETTING OUT OF FLOW (18 / 25 November 2006)
79 C57 Muller to McCarthy : FLOW, COUNTING, AND QUANTIFICATION (20 / 25 Nov 2006)
79 C58 Beamish to McCarthy : ON FLOW (22 / 25 Nov 2006)
79 C59 McCarthy to vGlasersfeld, Muller, and Beamish : MIND WITHOUT A SUBJECT (26 November / 2 December 2006)
79 C60 McCarthy to vGlasersfeld and Muller : DISCONTINUITY OF TIME ) (2 / 9 December 2006)
79 C61 Beamish to McCarthy : MIND WITHOUT A SUBJECT (4 / 9 December 2006)
79 C62 McCarthy to Beamish : THE DIRECTIONALITY OF TIME (7 / 9 December 2006)
79 C63 McCarthy to Beamish : TIME AS THE INNER WORLD (9 / 19 December 2006)
79 C64 Beamish to McCarthy : KNOWLEDGE AND "TIME'S" DICHOTOMY (20 / 23 December 2006)

RESPONSES by Joseph S Johnson :

TA79 R1 to C3, Muller : PROCESS : QUANTUM VS. COSMIC (23 / 26 February 2005)
TA79 R2 to vdMeijden, C1 : PROCESS THEORY; FOCUS AN ISSUE (26 Febr / 5 March 2005)
TA79 R3 to Patlavskiy : A FAILED PARADIGM AND ITS PERSISTENT ERRORS (27 Febr / 12 March 2005)
TA79 R4 to Beamish : PROCESS THEORY; SIMPLICTY AND SURVIVAL (5 / 12 March 2005)
TA79 R5 to Beamish : (PROCESS THEORY; SIMPLICITY AND SURVIVAL) (14 / 19 March 2005)
TA79 R6 to Wood, C5 : OF SCIENCE, FALLACIES, AND ATTITUDE (16 / 26 March 2005)
TA79 R7 to Muller (C8) : A COMMON CONCEPTUAL BASIS FOR THINKING (22 / 26 March 2005)
TA79 R8 to Beamish : ABSTRACTION THEORY OF NATURAL ORDER (31 March / 2 April 2005)
TA79 R9 to Muller : ZERO-D, AND RHETORIC (20 / 23 April 2005)
TA79 R10 to Wood : EVOLUTION AND CREATION (20 / 28 May 2005)
TA79 R11 to Muller : REDUNDANT ASSUMPTION (21 / 28 May 2005)
TA79 R12 to Wood : JASPERS MAN ? (3 / 9 July 2005)
TA79 R13 to vdMeijden : EVOLUTION AND CREATION (3 / 9 July 2005)
TA79 R14 (to Andemicael, C34) : CLARIFYING PRESUPPOSITIONS (23 / 30 July 2005)
TA79 R15 to Wood : DRAWING THE PICTURE (3 / 6 August 2005)

*******************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 80

TA80 by Michael Chumakin : THEORY OF MIND WITHIN AN ACTIVITY APPROACH (24 / 30 April 2005)

COMMENTARIES on TA80 :

TA80 C1 vdMeijden : ( THEORY OF MIND ) (30 April / 14 May 2005)
TA80 C2 Muller : COLLECTIVE THINKING (3 / 14 May 2005)
TA80 C3 McCarthy : SOCIAL THINKING ( 17 / 21 May 2005 )
TA80 C4 Patlavskiy : THE APPROACH CORRESPONDS WITH THE AIM (16 / 21 May 2005)
TA80 C5 vdMeijden : ( CAN OF WORMS ) (28 May / 25 June 2005)

RESPONSES by Michael Chumakin

TA80 R1 to vdMeijden and Muller : COLLECTIVE THINKING ? (19 / 28 May 2005)
TA80 R2 to McCarthy : WHY METODOLOGIA ? (24 / 28 May 2005)
TA80 R3 to various commentaries : CLARIFICATION ABOUT GRAPHICAL ILLUSTRATIONS AND PROPOSITION ABOOUT RESEARCH GROUP (4 / 16 July 2005) diagram 1(Jane Cull) diagram 2(Timo Jarvilehto) diagram3(metodologia) diagram 4(Wittgenstein)

*******************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 81

TA81 by A.U. De and Dhananjay Pal : PHYSICS OF CONSCIOUSNESS AND ITS MODEL MAY PROVIDE GUIDELINES TO SOLVE MANY SCIENTIFIC PROBLEMS. (2004 / 9 July 2005)

See .pdf version for the full text

TARGET ARTICLE 82

TA82 by A.U. De and Dhananjay Pal : CONSCIOUSNESS MODEL. SIGNIFICANCE OF THOUGHT-CARRYING PARTICLES AND THOUGHT-RETAINING PARTICLES IN QUANTUM MEASUREMENT AS WELL AS COGNITIVE PROBLEM. (2005 / 9 July 2005)

See .pdf version for the full text

COMMENTARIES on TA81 AND TA82 :

TA81-82 C1 vdMeijden : QUO VADIS ? (8 / 16 July 2005)
TA81-82 C2 Reams : ON TA81 (10 / 16 July 2005)
TA81-82 C3 Reams : ON TA82 (10 / 16 July 2005)
TA81-82 C4 J Johnson : SIMPLY STATED (14 / 23 July 2005)
TA81-82 C5 Patlavskyi : CONSCIOUSNESS REQUIRES ITS OWN APPROPRIATE SCIENTIFIC DISCIPLINE (14 / 23 July 2005)
TA81-82 C6 Muller : QUANTA, MINDS, AND PEOPLE (20 / 30 July 2005)
TA81-82 C7 Wood to Patlavskyi : AN OVATION TO CONSCIENTIOUS CRITIQUING (26 July / 6 August 2005)
TA81-82 C8 Chumakin : COMMENTARY NEUROQUANTOLOGY (26 / 30 July 2005)
TA81-82 C9 Weedon (to Muller, C6) : THANKS FOR THE MEMORY (29 July / 6 August 2005)
TA81-82 C10 vdMeijden : OVERBOARD (29 July / 13 August 2005)
TA81-82 C11 Wood (to C6, Muller) : HALFMAST MASTHEAD ? (July / 13 August 2005)
TA81-82 C12 Muller to Wood, C11 : RELIGION WITH SCIENCE (30 Aug / 17 Sept 2005)
TA81-82 C13 Patlavskiy : COMPARING EASTERN AND WESTERN WAYS OF THINKING (11 / 13 August 2005)
TA81-82 C14 Wood to Patlavskiy : JASPERS ON CONSCIOUSNESS AND SCIENCE (1 / 17 September 2005)
TA81-82 C15 Benjamin to Muller, C12 : EVOLUTION : SCIENCE OR PSEUDO-SCIENCE (16 / 24 September 2005)
TA81-82 C16 McCarthy to Muller, C12 : ON RELIGION WITH SCIENCE (18 / 24 Sewptember 2005)
TA81-82 C17 Benjamin to Wood, C14 : CONSCIOUSNESS AND SCIENCE (17 / 24 September 2005)
TA81-82 C18 vdMeijden to Benjamin C15 : OOPS (23 Sept / 15 Oct 2005)
TA81-82 C19 Roberts to Benjamin C15 : ON EVOLUTION (23 Sept / 15 Oct 2005)
TA81-82 C20 Benjamin to Roberts C19 : EVOLUTION (14/22 October 2005)
TA81-82 C21 vdMeijden to Roberts C19 : EVOLUTION (14/22 October 2005)
TA81-82 C22 vdMeijden to Benjamin C17 : EVOLUTION (15/22 October 2005)
TA81-82 C23 vdMeijden to Benjamin : FOOTNOTE (15/22 October 2005)
TA81-82 C24 Patlavskiy (to C14 Wood) : ( GOVERNING PRINCIPLES AND SCIENTIFIC METHOD ) (23/29 October 2005)
TA81-82 C25 Patlavskiy to Roberts and Benjamin EVOLUTIONISM VS. CREATIONISM : BOTH ARE WRONG (28 Oct / 5 Nov 2005)
TA81-82 C26 Boyd to Patlavskiy : SCIENTIFIC METHOD (31 October / 5 November 2005)
TA81-82 C27 Muller to Benjamin : EVOLUTION (2 / 5 November 2005)
TA81-62 C28 Roberts to Patlavskiy, C25 : EVOLUTION (4 / 12 November 2005)
TA81-82 C29 vdMeijden to Boyd C26 : SCIENTIFIC METHOD (CREATIONISM) (4 / 12 Nov 2005)
TA81-82 C30 Muller to Boyd C26 : CRITICAL REALISM (4 / 12 Nov 2005)
TA81-82 C31 Benjamin to Muller, C27 : EVOLUTION (GENOME SIMILARITIES) (8 / 12 November 2005)
TA81-82 C32 Muller to Benjamin (C31) : EVOLUTION WITH INTELLIGENCE (10 / 19 Nov 2005)
TA81-82 C33 Nixon to Benjamin (C31) : (EVOLUTION (GENOME SIMILARITIES))
TA81-82 C34 Weedon to Benjamin (C31) : EVOLUTION (11 / 19 Nov 2005)
TA81-82 C35 J Johnson to Benjamin (C31) : NATEC ? (14 / 19 November 2005)
TA81-82 C36 Benjamin (toC32-5) EVOLUTION (21 / 26 November 2005)
TA81-82 C37 DK Johnson and M Silliman (to C30, Muller) (22 / 26 November 2005)
TA81-82 C38 Hontela to Benjamin (C31) : PROBLEM OF RELIGION, FAITH (29 Dec 2005 / 14 Jan 2006)
TA81-82 C39 Muller to R2 : MICRO-MATERIALISM (15 / 24 June 2006)
TA81-82 C40 Patlavskiy : CRITICAL REMARKS ARE TOTALLY IGNORED (27 June / 1 July 2006)
TA81-82 C41 Andemicael : EINSTEIN'S RELATIVITY AND THE BRAIN (14 / 18 Nov 2006)
TA81-62 C42 Patlasvskiy to Andemicael : A QUESTION (19 / 25 November 2006)
TA81-82 C43 Andemicael to Patlavskiy : RESPONSE TO PATLAVSKIY (3 / 9 December 2006)
TA81-82 C44 Patlavskiy tgo Andemicael : WHAT DOES SPECIAL RELATIVITY HAVE TO DO WITH CONSCIOUSNESS ? (12 - 16 December 2006)
TA81-82 C45 Andemicael : AUDITORY INFORMATION PROCESSING (26 / 28 April 2007)

RESPONSES by De and Pal

TA81-82 R1 : CONCEPT OF MIND AND CONSCIOUSNESS< ON CONSCIOUSNESS MODEL. ANSWERS TO FAQ (FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS) (19/23 July 2005) Diagram to R1
TA81-82 R2 Pal&De : CONSCIOUSNESS MODEL AND ITS VERSATILE PLAUSIBLE APPLICATIONS (11 / 17 June 2006)

*******************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 83

TA83 by Stan Franklin : EVOLUTIONARY PRESSURES AND A STABLE WORLD FOR ANIMALS AND ROBOTS : A COMMENTARY ON MERKER (March 2005, posted 6 August 2005)

COMMENTARIES on TA83 :

A83 C1 vdMeijden : THE RIDDLE OF LIFE ? (5 / 20 August 2005)
TA83 C2 Muller : EXPERIENCE BY SUBJECTS (7 / 20 August 2005)
TA83 C3 Susan Schneider : TAKING MACHINE CONSCIOUSNESS SERIOUSLY (10 / 13 August 2005)
TA83 C4 Patlavskiy : SEVERAL QUESTIONS CONCERNING STAN FRANKLIN'S COMMENTARY (15 / 20 August 2005)
TA83 C5 Patlavskiy to Schneider, C3 : DISCUSSION WITH SUSAN SCHNEIDER (18 / 20 August 2005)
TA83 C6 Bone : ( EXPERIENCE BY SUBJECTS ) (2 / 10 September 2005)
TA83 C7 Muller (to R3) : EXPERIENCE BY SUBJECTS (29 August / 10 September 2005)
TA83 C8 Wood : UNEASY DISEASE QUESTIONS (3 / 17 September 2005)
TA83 C9 Weedon : EXPERIENCE BY SUBJECTS (9 / 17 September 2005)
TA83 C19 Bone (to R5) : EXPERIENCE BY SUBJECTS (15 / 24 September 2005)
TA83 C11 Weedon : A THIMBLEFUL OF PROUST (16 / 24 September 2005)
TA83 C12 McCarthy : ROBOTS NO, SOFTWARE AGENTS MAYBE (17 / 24 September 2005)
TA83 C13 vdMeijden to McCarthy : POIHAPS (23 Sept / 15 Oct 2005)

RESPONSES by Franklin :

TA83 R1 to Schneider : (MACHINE CONSCIOUSNESS) (22 / 27 August 2005)
TA83 R2 to vdMeijden : ( THE RIDDLE OF LIFE ? ) (22 / 27 August 2005)
TA83 R3 to Muller : (EXPERIENCE BY SUBJECTS) (22 Aug / 3 Sept 2005)
TA83 R4 to Patlavskiy : ( QUESTIONS ) (22 Aug / 3 Sept 2005)
TA83 R5 to Bone : ( EXPERIENCE BY SUBJECTS ) (2 / 10 September 2005)
TA83 R6 to Muller, C7 : EXPERIENCE BY SUBJECTS (19 / 24 September 2005)

*******************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 84

TA84 by Richard Conn Henry : THE MENTAL UNIVERSE (7 July 2005 / posted 7 January 2006)
(earlier extended version : A CLEARER LIGHT by RC Henry)
[.pdf versions of both papers are available at the end of TA84]

COMMENTARIES on TA84 :

TA84 C1 Nixon : ( THE MENTAL UNIVERSE ) (6 / 21 January 2006)
TA84 C2 Bussey : BETWEEN MATERIALISM AND IDEALISM (11 / 21 January 2006)
TA84 C3 Patlavskiy : ARE WE REALLY FACING AN EPISTEMOLOGOICAL CRISIS ? (14 / 21 January 2006)
TA84 C4 Baggott : I THINK, THEREFORE … ? (15 / 28 January 2006)
TA84 C5 Muller : MIND-INCLUSIVE RREALITY (10 / 28 January 2006)
TA84 C6 Bone to Henry and Baggott : ( I THINK, THEREFORE … ? ) (28 Jan / 4 Febr 2006)
TA84 C7 Patlavskiy to Baggott : (I THINK, THEREFORE … ?) (30 Jan / 4 Febr 2006)
TA84 C8 Patlavskiy to Muller : MIND-INCLUSIVE REALITY (2 / 4 Febr 2006)
TA84 C9 Bone to Baggott and Patlavskiy : ( I THINK, THEREFORE … ? ) (6 / 11 Febr 2006)
TA84 C10 Bussey to Bone : A FEW COMMENTS ON BONE'S RESERVATIONS ABOUT KANT'S NOOUMENA (10 / 18 Febr 2006)
TA84 C11 Muller to Baggott : SUBJECT-INCLUSIVE PHYSICS ? WE THINK, CREATING TENTATIVE STRUCTURES (14 / 18 Febr 2006)
TA84 C12 Foellmi : ( A CLEARER LIGHT ) (16 / 18 Febr 2006)
TA84 C13 Bone to Bussey (C10) : METAPHYSICS IS BEYOND PHYSICS (18 / 25 Febr 2006)
TA84 C14 Beamish to Bone : NOUMENA (24 Febr / 4 March 2006)
TA84 C15 Muller : CHECK YOUR REALITY (28 Febr / 4 March 2006)
TA84 C16 : REALITY REFERENDUM RESULTS (March / 1 April 2006)
…..TA84 C16a : EXTENDED VERSION OF RESULTS (April 2006)
TA84 C17 Patlavskiy : CHECK YOUR REALITY (29 March / 8 April 2006)
TA84 C18 Mutelesi : COMMENT ON SURVEY QUESTIONNAIRE (29 March / 8 April 2006)
TA84 C19 Lindblom : JASPERS QUESTIONNAIRE (7 March / 8 April 2006)
TA84 C20 Bussey : ( REALITY SURVEY ) (7 / 8 April 2006)
TA84 C21 Muller : HOW TO INTERPRET THE RESULTS ? (16 / 22 April 2006)
TA84 C22 Arons : HOW TO INTERPRET THE RESULTS ? (21 / 29 April 2006)
TA84 C23 Nixon : HOW TO INTERPRET THE RESULTS ? (21 / 29 April 2006)
TA84 C24 Bone : HOW TO INTERPRET THE RESULTS ? (23 / 29 April 2006)
TA84 C25 Muller to Arons (C22) : HOW TO INTERPRET THE RESULTS ? (30 April / 20 May 2006)
TA84 C26 Arons to Muller : (RESULTS) (25 May / 3 June 2006)
TA84 C27 Muller to Arons : REALITY (31 May / 10 June 2006)
TA84 C28 Bone : ( CONSTRUCTIVIST PHNENOMENOLOGY ) and Sarfatti (books) (9 / 17 June 2006)
TA84 C29 Hontela : POSSIBILITIES FOR REALITY (27 May / 17 June 2006)
TA84 C30 Prevost : REALITY SURVEY (27 April / 17 June 2005)
TA84 C31 Andemicael : SPACE, TIME, MATTER AND MIND (12 / 14 April 2007)
TA84 C32 Andemicael : THE NATURE OF REALITY (19 / 21 April 2007)
TA84 C33 Beamish : ( TIME ) (14 / 23 August 2008)
TA84 C34 Muller : METAPHYSICS VERSUS OPERATIONS (15 / 23 August 2008)

RESPONSES by R C Henry :

TA84 R1 to Commentaries 1 to 9 (11 / 18 Febr 2006)
TA84 R2 (addition) MINKOWSKI TRUMPS EINSTEIN (June / 16 Aug 2008)

*******************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 85

TA85 by Ramona Fotiade : LIFE AFTER DECONSTRUCTION (REVIEW OF : APPRENDRE A VIVRE ENFIN, Jacques Derrida) (2 Dec 2005 / 11 Febr 2006)
Acrobat version (.pdf) of TA85

COMMENTARIES on TA85 :

TA85 C1 Barros : ( DERRIDA'S TESTAMENT ) (17 / 25 Febr 2006)
TA85 C2 Abraham : DERRIDA'S TESTAMENT (17 / 25 Febr 2006)
TA85 C3 Muller : DERRIDA WITH WORKING-ONTOLOGY (AND KIERKEGAARD'S 'OR') (23 Jan / 25 Febr 2006)
TA85 C4 Barros to Muller (C3) : (DERRIDA AND KIERKEGAARD ) (2 / 4 March 2006)
TA85 C5 Muller to Barros (C4) : MIR AND WORKING-MIR (5 / 11 March 2006)
TA85 C6 Beamish to Muller (C5) : SCIENCE AND SPIRITUALITY (12 / 18 March 2006)
TA85 C7 Barros to Muller (C5) : WORKING-MIR (15 / 18 March 2006)
TA85 C8 Nixon to Beamish (C6) : CARETAKER GOD (17 / 25 March 2006)
TA85 C9 Muller (to R1) : ONTOLOGY-WITHDRAWAL (STRUCTURES AND REASON) (22 March / 8 April 2006)
TA85 C10 Patlavskiy : ( DECONSTRUCTION AND PHENOMENOLOGY ) (24 March / 1 April 2006)
TA85 C11 Muller to Barros (C5) : WORKING-MIR (26 March / 1 April 2006)

RESPONSES by Ramona Fotiade :

TA85 R1 to comments 1 to 5 : ( DECONSTRUCTION AND PHENOMENOLOGY ) (14 / 18 March 2006)

*******************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLES 86 and 87

TA86 by Stuart A. Umpleby : THE DESIGN OF INTELLECTUAL MOVEMENTS (2002 / 11 March 2006)

German translation of TA86

TA87 by Stuart A. Umpleby : STRATEGIES FOR WINNING ACCEPTANCE OF SECOND ORDER CYBERNETICS (1991 / 11 March 2006)

COMMENTARIES on TA86 and 87 :

*******************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 88

TA88 by Alexander Riegler : THE CONSTRUCTIVIST CHALLENGE (1 November 2005 / 3 June 2006)
Acrobat version (.pdf) of TA88

COMMENTARIES on TA88 : TA88 C1 Patlavskiy : CAN CONSTRUCTIVISM PROVIDE SUFFICIENT PLASTICITY TO SCIENCE ? (9 / 17 June 2006)

TA88 C2 Muller : SOME CONSTRUCTIVIST QUESTIONS (5 / 17 June 2006)
TA88 C3 Patlavskiy to Muller (C2) : DISCUSSING THE PRINCIPLES OF CONSTRUCTIVISM (27 June / 1 July 2006)
TA88 C4 Muller to Patlavskiy (C3) : OPERATIONS BY SUBJECTS (29 June / 8 July 2006)
TA88 C5 Patlavskiy to Muller (C4) : COMPARING THE APPROACHES (11 / 29 July 2006)
TA88 C6 Muller to Patlavskiy : COMPARING THE APPROACHES (20 July / 5 August 2006)
TA88 C7 Barros Gewehr : COMPARING THE APPROACHES (4 / 12 August 2006)
TA88 C8 Patlavskiy : CLARIFYING THE APPROACH (4 / 12 August 2006)

*******************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 89

TA89 by Eugene Webb : EROS AND THE PSYCHOLOGY OF WORLD VIEWS (June 2006 / 24 June 2006)

COMMENTARIES on TA89 :

TA89 C1 Nixon : ( PSYCHOLOGY OF WORLD VIEWS ) (23 June / 1 July 2006)
TA89 C2 Muller : OPERATIONAL BASES OF THEORIES AND WORLD-VIEWS (30 June / 8 July 2006)
TA89 C3 Lothane : ( EROS AND PSYCHOLOGY OF WORLD-VIEWS (4 / 8 July 2006)

*******************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 90

TA90 by Rodrigo Barros Gewehr : REALITY AND ITS DISCONTENTS (18 June / 29 July 2006)

COMMENTARIES on TA90 :

RESPONSES by Rodrigo Barros Gewehr :

TA90 R1 to Patlavskiy (C3) ( REALITY ) (25 Aug / 2 Sept 2006)
TA90 R2 to Muller (C1) ( REALITY ) (26 Aug / 2 Sept 2006)
TA90 R3 to LYON (C7) and Muller (C8) : ( REALITY ) (26 Aug / 2 Sept 2006)

*******************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 91

TA91 by Herbert FJ Muller : TIME AND REALITY (in Micheal Lockwood's materialism; and some 0-D counterproposals)

COMMENTARIES on TA91 :

TA91 C1 Adams : CONSTRUCTING NOWHERE (7 / 16 December 2006)
TA91 C2 Beamish : TIME AND REALITY (11 / 16 December 2006)
TA91 C3 Patlavskiy : ON THE ROLE OF THE SUBJECT IN DEFINING TIME (12 / 16 December 2006)
TA91 C4 Beamish : "RELATIVISTIC PARADOX" SEEMINGLY SOLVED ! (22 / 30 December 2006)
TA91 C5 Benjamin : COMPLETE EXPERIENCE (23 / 30 December 2006)
TA91 C6 Patlavskiy : ALTERNATIVE TO SUBJECTIVE EXPERIENCE VS COMPLETE EXPERIENCE (26 / 30 December 2006)
TA91 C7 Beamish : WE DO NOT MOVE THROUGH TIME - TIME MOVES THROUGH US (28 / 30 December 2006)
TA91 C8 Beamish : SPECIAL RELATIVITY - REINTERPRETATION (4 / 6 January 2007)
TA91 C9 Patlavskiy : CAN CONSCIOUSNESS BE ENFRAMED AS AN OBJECT OF STUDY ? (17 / 20 Jan 2007)
TA91 C10 vGlasersfeld to Patlavskiy : INVESTIGATING REALITY ? (I9 / 27 January 2007)
TA91 C11 Patlavskiy to vGlasersfeld : INVESTIGATING REALITY IN TWO MODES (4 / 10 February 2007)
TA91 C12 Andemicael : CONSIDERING ALTERNATIVES TO THE SPACETIME MODEL OF REALITY (21 / 24 March 2004)
TA91 C13 Andemicael : THE NATURE OF SPACETIME (24 / 26 May 2007)
TA91 C14 Beamish to Andemicael (C13) : THE NATURE OF SPACE AND TIME (24 May / 2 June 2007)
TA91 C15 Andemicael : INTERSUBJECTIVE EVENTS (9 / 11 August 2007)
TA91 C16 Andemicael : TIME AND DESIGN (26 / 29 September 2007)
TA91 C17 Patlavskiy to Andemicael : A THIRD POSSIBILITY (30 Sept / 6 Oct 2007)
TA91 C18 Roberts to Patlavskiy and Andemicael : ( TIME AND DESIGN ) (8 / 20 October 2007)
TA91 C19 McCard : ( UNREALITY OF TIME ) (20 / 27 October 2007)
TA91 C20 Benjamin : BLOCK-UNIVERSE ? (25 Oct / 3 Nov 2007)
TA91 C21 Hontela to Andemicael, Patlavskiy, Roberts : ( TIME AND DESIGN ) (1 / 10 November 2007)
TA91 C22 Andemicael : PARALLEL UNIVERSES AND THE MIND (8 / 15 December 2007)
TA91 C23 Petkov : TIME IS ONLY AN ILLUSION (26 / 29 December 2007)
TA91 C24 Andemicael : SPACES WITH MORE THAN THREE DIMENSIONS (25 / 29 March 2008)

RESPONSES by Herbert FJ Muller :

TA91 R1 to Adams : DISCUSSING WORKING-CONCEPTS (16 / 23 December 2006)
TA91 R2 to Beamish and Patlavskiy : COMPLETE EXPERIENCE (16 / 23 December 2006)
TA91 R3 to Benjamin : ON RELATIVITY, WORKING-ABSOLUTES, AND FREE WILL (26 Dec 2006 / 6 Jan 2007)
TA91 R4 to Patlavskiy : MIND ENCOMPASSES THEORY (31 December 2006, posted 13 January 2007)
TA91 R5 to Patlavskiy : CONSTRUCTED REALITY (22 / 24 Febr 2007)
TA91 R6 to Andemicael (C16) : BLOCK-UNIVERSE ? (3 / 27 October 2007)
TA91 R7 to McCard (C19) : ( UNREALITY OF TIME ) (25 Oct / 3 Nov 2007)
TA91 R8 to Benjamin (C20) : BLOCK UNIVERSE ? (3 / 10 Nov 2007)

*******************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 92

TA92 by Beamish : 2 "TEMPORAL TYPES" (I & II), & 2 "TEMPORAL TAGS" (A&B) (16 / 20 / 27 January / 3 February 2007)

COMMENTARIES on TA92 :

TA92 C1 Muller : QUESTIONS ABOUT SUBJECT-INCLUSIVE TIME (29 Jan / 3 Febr 2007)
TA92 C2 Muller to R1 : MIND-INCLUSIVE ABSOLUTES ? (12 / 17 February 2007)
TA92 C3 Muller to R2 : WHERE IS MVP ? (20 Febr / 3 March 2007)
TA92 C4 Muller to R4 : WHAT IS REALITY ? (10 / 17 March 2007)
TA92 C5 McCarthy to Beamish and Muller : ATTEMPTED CLARIFICATIONS (11 / 17 March 2007)
TA92 C6 Bone : STATEMENT ABOUT "TIME" (15 / 24 March 2007)
TA92 C7 Patlavskiy : THERE PERFECTLY IS MIR (16 / 24 March 2007)
TA92 C8 Weedon : CONSTRUCTIVISM AS METAPHOR (20 / 24 March 2007)
TA92 C9 McCarthy : KNOWLEDGE AND REALITY (25 / 31 March 2007)
TA92 C10 Muller to Patlavskiy : PERFECTLY IN YOUR MIND (28 / 31 March 2007)
TA92 C11 Patlavskiy to Muller : PREVENTING INCORRECTNESSES IN CONCLUSIONS (30 March / 7 April 2007)
TA92 C12 Muller to Patlavskiy : IN THE MIND (31 March / 14 April 2007)
TA92 C13 Benjamin to Muller : (IN YOUR MIND) (30 March / 7 April 2007)
TA92 C14 McCarthy to Beamish, R8 : KNOWLEDGE AND REALITY 2 (9 / 14 April 2007)
TA92 C15 Patlavskiy to Muller : RATIONAL CONTRA-ARGUMENTS ARE WELCOMED (13 / 17 April 2007)
TA92 C16 Benjamin : QUANTUM MECHANICS CONVERGING WITH CLASSICAl PHYSICS (20 / 28 April 2007)
TA92 C17 DK Johnson : ON THE REALITY OF CANADA : DISTINGUISHING SIR, HIR, AND MIR (24 / 28 April 2007)
TA92 C18 Patlavskiy to Johnson : CONSTRUCTIVE APPROACH TO CONSTRUCTIVISM (30 April / 5 May 2007)
TA92 C19 McCarthy to Beamish and Muller : ATTEMPTED CLARIFICATIONS (11 / 18 August 2007)
TA92 C20 Bone : ( TIME ) (4 / 20 October 2007)
TA92 C21 Bone : ( TIME ) (23 / 27 October 2007)
TA92 C22 Bone : ( TIME ) (25 Oct / 3 Nov 2007)
TA92 C23 Muller (to R18) : STRUCTURES ARE TEMPORARY - EINSTEIN THE ONTOLOGIST (23 Jan / 2 Feb 2008)
TA92 C24 Andemicael : CONSIDERING ALTERNATIVES TO THE SPACTIME MODEL OF REALITY (6 / 9 Febr 2008)
TA92 C25 Kooijman (to C23, Muller) : ( ON ONTA ) (7 / 16 Febr 2008)
TA92 C26 Muller (to Kooijman, C25, also to Beamish, R23[4]) (7 / 16 Febr 2008)
TA92 C27 Raman and Rosen : HOMOGENEITY AND CONTINUITY OF TIME (Capek) (17 / 23 February 2008)
TA92 C28 Kooijman : ( POPPER, KUHN, GÖDEL ) (20 /23 February 2008)
TA92 C29 (to R26) Muller : DEFINITION OF TIME (23 Febr / 1 March 2008)
TA92 C30 Muller (to R27) : FLOW AND NOW (28 Febr / 8 March 2008)
TA92 C31 Pande and Beamish : EXTERNAL WORLD (1 / 8 March 2008)

DISCUSSION OF THE ZER0-DERIVATION VIEW (0-D) :

TA92 C32 Muller to DK Johnson (C17) : SHOULD WE LEAP TO REALISM ? (29 June / 5 July 2008)
TA92 C33 Barnett to DK Johnson and Muller : OBJECTIONS WITHOUT RESPONSES (7 July / 2 August 2008)
TA92 C34 Muller to Barnett (C33) : REPLY (25 July / 2 August 2008)
TA92 C35 Adams to Muller, C34 : ( ORIGIN OF SUBJECT AND SUBJECT ) (30 July / 9 August 2008)
TA92 C36 Muller to Adams and Barnett : ORIGIN OF SUBJECT AND NON-SUBJECT (31 July / 9 August 2008)
TA92 C37 Barnett to Muller, C34 : ( THE SUBJECT’S ROLE ) (5 / 9 Aug 2008)
TA92 C38 Adams to Muller, C36 : DEFINING ORIGINS (8 / 16 August 2008)
TA92 C39 Muller to Adams, C38 : DEFINING ORIGINS (10 / 16 August 2008)
TA92 C40 Muller to Barnett and Adams : ORIGIN OF ‘FORMS’ (SPENCER BROWN) (14 / 20 September 2008)
TA92 C41 McCarthy to Barnett and Adams : INTUITIVE CATEGORIZATION (7 / 18 October 2008)
TA92 C42 Adams to McCarthy : INTUITION AND CREATIVITY (10 / 25 October 2008)
TA92 C43 McCarthy to Adams : CREATIVE INTUITION (1 / 8 November 2008)
TA92 C44 Adams to McCarthy : SELF-JUSTIFIED INTUITION (13 / 22 November 2008)
TA92 C45 DK Johnson to Barnett : “LOOKS AS IF REALISM IS TRUE AND CONSTRUCTIVISM FALSE” (20 / 29 November 2008)
TA92 C46 Adams to DK Johnson, C45 : REALISM-SOLIPSISM : FALSE DICHOTOMY ? (5 / 13 Dec 2008)
TA92 C47 McCarthy to Adams, C46 : INTUITION (8 / 13 December 2008)
TA92 C48 Barnett to DK Johnson : ( REALISM VERSUS CONSTRUCTIVISM ) (9 / 13 December 2008)
TA92 C49 Silliman and Adams : ( REALISM - CONSTRUCTIVISM ) (10 / 20 December 2008)
TA92 C50 McCarthy : CERTAINTY, ERROR, AND DOUBT (21 / 27 December 2008)
TA92 C51 Silliman to Adams, C49 : ( REALISM - CONSTRUCTIVISM ) (21 / 27 December 2008)
TA92 C52 Adams to Silliman, C51 : REALISM - CONSTRUCTIVISM (26 Dec 2008 / 3 Jan 2009)
TA92 C53 Barnett to Silliman : SILLIMAN OVERSTATES JOHNSON AND VONGLASERSFELD : BEWARE HIDDEN PRESUMPTIONS (29 Dec 2008 / 3 Jan 2009)

RESPONSES AND ADDITIONS by Peter Beamish :

TA92 R1 to Muller, C1 : NINE "QUESTIONS ABOUT SUBJECT-INCLUSIVE TIME" (3 / 10 February 2007)
TA92 R2 to Muller, C2 : "TEMPORAL TYPES" (16 / 24 Febr 2007)
TA92 R3 to Muller, C3 : TWO TEMPORAL TYPES (20 Febr / 3 March 2007)
TA92 R4 to Muller, C4 : 2 "TEMPORAL TYPES" (2 / 10 March 2007)
TA92 R5 to Muller, C4 : (REALITY) (16 / 24 March 2007)
TA92 R6 to McCarthy : CLARIFICATIONS (17 24 March 2007)
TA92 R7 to Bone : STATEMENT ABOUT "TIME" (24 / 31 March 2007)
TA92 R8 to McCarthy : (REALITY) (30 March / 7 April 2007)
TA92 R9 to McCarthy : KNOWLEDGE AND REALITY (13 / 21 April 2007)
TA92 R10 : QUANTUM MECHANICS CONVERGING WITH CLASSICAL PHYSICS (18 / 21 April 2007)
TA92 R11 : DEVELOPING TIME TAGS (23 / 29 September 2007)
TA92 R12 : ( TIME ) (27 Sept / 6 Oct 2007)
TA92 R13 to Bone (C20) : TIME (20 / 27 October 2007)
TA92 R14 to Bone (C22) : ( TIME ) (2 / 10 November 2007)
TA92 R15 : “TIME’S” DUALITIES (14 / 17 Nov 2007)
TA92 R16 : “TIME DILATION” EXPLAINED USING “MVP THEORY” (16 / 24 November 2007)
TA92 R17 to Sewell and Mohrhoff : ( ENTROPY ) (30 Nov / 15 Dec 2007)
TA92 R18 : RELATIVISTIC “LENGTH CONTRACTION” IS “SUBJECTIVE NOT OBJECTIVE REALITY” (22 / 26 January 2008)
TA92 R19 (re R18) : ( LENGTH CONTRACTION ) (25 Jan / 2 Feb 2008)
TA92 R20 (re R19) : SPECIAL RELATIVITY AND “MENTAL VECTOR PROCESSES” (31 Jan / 9 Febr 2008)
TA92 R21 (to Andemicael, C24) : (QUANTUM OBSERVATION) (4 / 9 Febr 2008)
TA92 R22 : 21^ST CENTURY SEMANTICS OF THE BIOSCIENCES OF ‘TIME’ (6 / 9 Febr 2008)
TA92 R23 to C23, Muller : ( A VOTE FOR MIR ) (10 / 16 Febr 2008)
TA92 R24 (addition to R23) : ( MORE ON MIR ) (12 / 16 Febr 2008)
TA92 R25 (further addition) ASSUMPTIONS ABOUT TIME (14 / 23 February 2008)
TA92 R26 (further addition) “REAL TIME” DEFINED, VERSUS “CONVENTIONAL TIME” & “RHYTHMIC TIME” (22 Febr / 1 March 2008)
TA92 R27 (to C29, Muller) : DEFINITION OF TIME (28 Febr / 8 March 2008)
TA92 R28 to Pande : ( LOCALITY ) (11 / 15 March 2008)
TA92 R29 (addition) : SPECIAL RELATIVITY & “DURATION DILATATION” (24 / 29 March 2008)
TA92 R30 (addition) : REGARDING “THE ‘REALNESS’ OF LENGTH CONTRACTION” OF SPECIAL RELATIVITY (26 / 29 March 2008)
TA92 R31 (addition) : A NEW GLOSSARY FOR "RBC/MVP THEORY" (AND MORE**) (31 March / 5 April 2008)
TA92 R32 (addition) : TEMPORAL PHENOMENA (8 / 12 April 2008)
TA92 R33 (addition) : SUPERLUMINAL “RHTHM BASED COMMUNICATION” (2 / 6 Sept 2008)

*******************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 93

TA93 by Muller : EPISTEMOLOGY RETURNS TO ITS ROOTS (15 / 24 March 2007)
Also published in Constructivist Foundations; see http://www.univie.ac.at/constructivism/journal/articles/2.2.14.muller.pdf

COMMENTARIES on TA93 :

TA93 C1 McCarthy : MATHEMATICAL CERTAINTY (27 / 31 March 2007)
TA93 C2 Beamish : FROM "SUBJECTIVE ACTIVITY" TO "SUBJECTIVE REALITY" (11 / 14 April 2007)
TA93 C3 McCarthy to R1 : MATHEMATICAL CERTAINTY 2 (19 / 14 April 2007)
TA93 C4 Greindl and Krieg : IS RADICAL CONSTRUCTIVISM ANTI-SCIENTIFIC ? (13 / 21 April 2007)
TA93 C5 McCarthy to Beamish : THE PRESENT STATE OF SCIENCE IS MERELY WORLD OPINION (14 / 21 April 2007)
TA93 C6 Beamish : REALITY STRUCTURING (20 / 28 April 2007)
TA93 C7 McCarthy to Greindl and Krieg : NO, RADICAL CONSTRUCTIVISM IS NOT ANTI-SCIENTIFIC (24 / 28 April 2007)
TA93 C8 Patlavskiy : CONCERNING SUBJECT-INCLUSIVENESS AND TOE (2 / 5 May 2007)
TA93 C9 Beamish : THE STRUCTURE OF “OBJECTIVE REALITY” (5 / 12 May 2007)
TA93 C10 Patlavskiy to R5 : PRACTICAL APPLICABILITY OF THE MIR DISCUSSION (10 / 19 May 2007)
TA93 C11 McCarthy to R6 : MOURN THE ROSE. IT’S EMPTY NAME ALONE REMAINS. DOES ‘EMPTY NAME’ MEAN ‘DEAD SPECIES’ ? WHEREOF THIS EMPTINESS ? (14 / 19 May 2007)
TA93 C12 Lothane to Patlavskiy (C10) : MIRs AND MIRAGES (19 / 26 May 2007)
TA93 C13 Lothane to McCarthy : SCIENCE AS WORLD OPINION (19 / 26 May 2007)
TA93 C14 Beamish to R8 : “EXPERIENCE” MUST INVOLVE ‘MENTAL VECTORS’ (25 May / 2 June 2007)
TA93 C15 Patlavskiy to Lothane and Muller : MIR AND STRANGE LOOPS (26 May / 2 June 2007)
TA93 C16 McCarthy to Lothane : SCIENCE AS WORLD OPINION (31 May / 2 June 2007)
TA93 C17 Andemicael : MATHEMATICAL LAWS AND REALITY (31 May / 2 June 2007)
TA93 C18 Adami Book Review D Hofstadter : I AM A STRANGE LOOP (25 May / ( June 2007)
TA93 C19 McCarthy (to R10) : ELEMENTARY, DR. MULLER (13 / 16 June 2007)
TA93 C20 Barnett to McCarthy (C19) : ( ELEMENTS ) (16 / 23 June 2007)
TA93 C21 Beamish (to R11) : (ASTONISHING HYPOTHESIS) (19 / 23 June 2007)
TA93 C22 McCarthy (further to R10) : THE RIBBON (20 / 23 June 2007)
TA93 C23 Rhodes : ( BOTTOM LAYER ) (22 / 30 June 2007)
TA93 C24 Roberts : ( BOTTOM LAYER ) (22 / 30 June 2007)
TA93 C25 McCarthy to Barnett (C20) THE SUBJECT, ELEMENTARY AND OTHERWISE (26 / 30 June 2007)
TA93 C26 Beamish to R14 : MIND DEBATE (7 July / 4 August 2007)
TA93 C27 Beamish to R14 : MIND DEBATE, PART II (16 July / 4 August 2007)
TA93 C28 Beamish to R16 : (ON SCIENCE) (11 / 18 August 2007)
TA93 C29 Patlavskiy to R16 : THE NOUMENA CANNOT BE KNOWN BY DEFINITION (11 / 18 August 2007)
TA93 C30 Beamish to R16 : JASPERS ON MIND, REALITY, AND COMMUNICATION (14 / 18 August 2007)
TA93 C31 Beamish to R16 : ( COMMUNICATION ) (18 / 25 August 2007)
TA93 C32 Beamish WHY CETA-RESEARCH (Science) ESPOUSES THE METAPHYSICS OF TIME CONFERENCE (Bergamo, Italy) (24 Aug / 1 Sept 2007)

RESPONSES AND ADDITIONS by Muller :

TA93 R1 to McCarthy, C1 : YOU ARE IN IT (31 March / 7 April 2007)
TA93 R2 (to discussion in RC list) : LUHMANN, JASPERS, AND THE DISAPPEARING SUBJECT (31 March / 7 April 2007)
TA93 R3 to Beamish : REALITY STRUCTURING (12 / 21 April 2007)
TA93 R4 to Greindl and Krieg : IS SCIENCE INADEQUATELY STRUCTURED ? AND IS THE WORLD FANTASY ? (22 / 28 April 2007)
TA93 R5 to Beamish, Patlavskiy, Johnson : WHO STRUCTURES REALITY ? (28 April / 5May 2007)
TA93 R6 to McCarthy (C3) BOTTOM-UP RELIABILITY AND TOP-DOWN CERTAINTY (30 April / 12 May 2007)
TA93 R7 to Patlavskiy (C8) SYSTEMS AND EVRYTHING (3 / 19 May 2007)
TA93 R8 to Beamish (C9) : PRIMACY OF MIND   AND HOFSTADTER’S EMERGING STRANGE LOOPS (12 / 26 May 2007)
TA93 R9 to Patlavskiy (C10) and Lothane (C12) : METAPHYSICS SHOULD BECOME OPERATIONAL (15 May / 2 June 2007)
TA93 R10 to McCarthy (C11) : OBJECTIVITY TOOL (24 May / 9 June 2007)
TA93 R11 to Beamish (C14) : EXPERIENCE ENCOMPASSES ALL STRUCTURES INCLUDING VECTORS      AND     THE SUBJECT DISAPPEARS IN EXCLUSIVELY-OBJECTIVE SCIENCE (31 May / 16 June 2007)
TA93 R12 to Andemicael (C17 ) : BOTTOM LAYER ? (14 / 23 June 2007)
TA93 R13 to McCarthy (C19) and Barnett (C20) : NO MIR, SIR (19 / 30 June 2007)
TA93 R14 to Beamish (C21) and Roberts (C24) ; NEURAL CORRELATES OF CONSCIOUSNESS, HOMUNCULI, AND TRANSCENDENCE (20 June / 7 July 2007)
TA93 R15 to McCarthy (C22) : STRUCTURES ARE OUR DOING; NOTHING STRANGE ABOUT THAT (25 June / 7 July 2007)
TA93 R16 to Beamish, Patlavskiy, and others : JASPERS ON MIND, REALITY, AND COMMUNICATION; AND 0-D AS EPISTEMOLOGY-ROOTING TOOL (20 July / 11 August 2007)
TA93 R17 to Beamish, C31 : PRE-VERBAL COMMUNICATION (25 August / 1 Sept 2007)
TA93 R18 : CHARLES M TAYLOR ON EPISTEMOLOGY (1 / 15 Dec 2007)
TA93 R19 : EPISTEMOLOGY AND INDIVIDUATION - GABRIEL JOSIPOVICI ON MODERNISM (27 Dec 2007 / 12 Jan 2008)   Josipovici paper
TA93 R20 : CONSTRUCTIVIST VERSUS ANALYTICAL EPISTEMOLOGY (P.F. STRAWSON) (17 / 26 January 2008)
TA93 R21 : ANTI-METAPHYSICS - WITHOUT STRUCTURING - IN TIBET (17 / 26 April 2008)
TA93 R22 (Addition) : COMMUNICATING MINDS : SHARING EXPERIENCE (5 / 10 May 2008)
TA93 R23 (Addition to R21) : Smart on NAGARJUNA, and Muller on THE ‘LAW’ OF METAPHYSICS BY DEFAULT (MIR-RELAPSE) (1967; 7 / 17 May 2008)
TA93 R24 (Addition; Kelly on Smith : HUSSERL) : PROGREES-REPORT : DIALOGUE DES MI-SOURDS ? (12 / 17 May 2008)
TA93 R25 (Addition) Holmgren / Siderits : ON BUDDHIST EPISTEMOLOGY (29 June / 5 July 2008)

*******************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 94

TA94 by Serge Patlavskiy : WHO DOES SETH SPEAK THROUGH / (24 / 30 June 2007)
use the .pdf version of this paper for the full text

COMMENTARIES on TA94 :

TA94 C1 from Wikipedia on JANE ROBERTS AND SETH (July 2007)
TA94 C2 McCarthy : ON TRANCE MEDIUMSHIP (21 / 25 August 2007)
TA94 C3 Hari : IS CONSCIOUSNESS SAME AS INFORMATION ? (13 / 15 September 2007)
TA94 C4 McCard : ( SETH AND JANE ) (26 Oct / 3 Nov 2007)

RESPONSES by Patlavskiy

TA94 R1 to McCarthy : ( ON SETH ) (25 Aug / 1 Sept 2007)
TA94 R2 to Hari : TWO CONCEPTS OF INFORMATION (17 / 22 September 2007)
TA94 R3 to McCard : WHOSE THOUGHTS WE EXPRESS ? (1 / 10 November 2007)

*******************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 95

TA95 by Gregory Nixon : THE CONTINUUM OF EXPERIENCE : NON-CONSCIOUS EXPERIENCE (1 / 7 July 2007)
Corrected Version TA95A TA95A in .pdf format

COMMENTARIES on TA95 :

TA95 C1 Christian deQuincey : THE CONTINUUM OF EXPERIENCE : NON-CONSCIOUS EXPERIENCE (3 July / 4 August 2007)
TA95 C2 Joseph S Johnson : ROLE OF CONSCIOUSNESS IN COSMIC PROCESS (23 July / 4 August 2007)
TA95 C3 William A Adams : BINARY CONSCIOUSNESS (27 July / 4 August 2007)
TA95 C4 Serge Patlavskiy : THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN CONSCIOUS AND NON-CONSCIOUS EXPERIENCE (29 July / 4 August 2007)
TA95 C5 Leslie Dewart : THE CONTINUUM FROM REALITY TO UNREALITY (7 / 11 August 2007)
TA95 C6 Philip Benjamin : A CRITIQUE ON GREGG NIXON’S CONTINUUM OF EXPERIENCE NON-CONSCIOUS EXPERIENCE ? (10 / 18 August 2007)
TA95 C7 William A Adams : CONSCIOUSNESS AND EXPERIENCE (10 / 18 August 2007)
TA95 C8 Maurice McCarthy : SOME SIGNIFICANCES OF UNCONSCIOUS EXPERIENCE (12 / 18 August 2007)
TA95 C9 Timo Jarvilehto : CONSCIOUSNESS AS A STREAM OF SHARED AND CATEGORIZED RESULTS OF EXPERIENCE (14 / 18 August 2007)
TA95 C10 Alfredo Pereira Jr : THE DIFFERENCE OF UNCONSCIOUS AND CONSCIOUS EXPERIENCE : A PHYSICALIST PERSPECTIVE (16 / 25 August 2007)
TA95 C11 Benny Shanon : CONSCIOUSNESS, EXPERIENCE AND MODES OF KNOWING. A DISCUSSION OF THE TARGET ARTICLE BY GRAG NIXON (22 / 25 August 2007)
TA95 C12 Serge Patlavskiy : THE VALUE OF TAUTOLOGICAL DEFINITIONS (24 Aug / 1 Sept 2007)
TA95 C13 Alfredo Pereira Jr : THE TRUE VALUE OF DEFINITIONS (30 Aug / 8 Sept 2007)
TA95 C14 Serge Patlavskiy (to R3) : ON THE IDEAS “MENTIONED IN PASSING ” (20 / 27 October 2007)
TA95 C15 Bill Adams to R5 (Dewart) : A SIMPLE TERMINOLOGICAL MATTER ? (13 / 22 Dec 2007)

RESPONSES by Nixon :

TA95 R1 to Adams (C3) : ( BINARY CONSCIOUSNESS ) ( 6 / 11 August 2007 )
TA95 R2 to deQuincey (C1) : ( CONTINUUM OF EXPERIENCE ) (12 / 20 October 2007)
TA95 R3 to Patlavskiy and Johnson : RESPONSE (12 / 20 October 2007)
TA95 R4 to Benjamin (C6) (27 Oct / 3 Nov 2007)
TA95 R5 to Dewart (C5) : ( THE CONTINUUM FROM REALITY TO UNREALITY ) (9 / 15 December 2007)
TA95 R6 to Adams (C15) : ( TERMINOLOGICAL MATTER ? ) (21 / 29 December 2007)

*******************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 96 :

TA96 by Lauri Jarvilehto : CATS, DUCKS, AND RABBITS : SUPERPOSITION AND THE OBJECT OF PERCEPTION (15 July / 11 August 2007)

COMMENTARIES on TA96 :

TA96 C1 Ernst von Glasersfeld : A WELCOME CLARIFICATION (15 / 25 August 2007)
TA96 C2 Sami Pihlstrom : ON CATS, DUCK AND RABBITS : SUPERPOSITION AND THE OBJECT OF PERCEPTION BY LAURI JARVILEHTO (20 / 25 August 2007)
TA96 C3 Herbert FJ Muller : 0-D ROOTING OF IMAGES AND SUPERPOSITIONS [ FAMILIARITY, GESTALT, OBJECTS, STATISTICS ] (15 / 25 August 2007)
TA96 C4 Serge Patlavskiy : CAN THE NOUMENON ‘DICTATE’ THE WAY OF ITS CONCEPTUALIZATION ? (23 Aug / 1 Sept 2007)
TA96 C5 Pentti Maattanen : On CATS DUCKS AND RABBITS : SUPERPOSITION AND THE OBJECT OF PERCEPTION by Lauri Jarvilehto (26 Aug / 1 Sepr 2007)
TA96 C6 (to R3) Serge Patlavskiy : WE CANNOT STATE THAT NOUMENAL REALITY IS PRE-STRUCTURED (17 / 22 September 2007)

RESPONSES by L Jarvilehto :

TA96 R1 to vonGlasersfeld, Pihlstrom, Muller : IS THE LIGHT ON IN THE FRIDGE ? OBJECT-IN-CONTEXT AND THE STRUCTURE OF THE WORLD (12 / 15 September 2007) pdf version of this paper
TA96 R2 to Maattanen : ANSWERS (12 / 15 September 2007)
TA96 R3 to Patlavskiy : THE NOUMENON DICTATES THE SCOPE OF ITS POSSIBLE CONCEPTUALISATIONS (12 / 15 September 2007)

*******************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 97 :

TA97 by David Hodgson : WHY I (STILL) BELIEVE IN FREE WILL AND RESPONSIBILITY (posted 1 Sept 2007)

COMMENTARIES on TA97 :

TA97 C1 Serge Patlavskiy : THE ARGUMENTS AGAINST FREE WILL SHOULD NOT BE TREATED SERIOUSLY (3 / 8 Sept 2007)
TA97 C2 Ulrich Mohrhoff : ( FREE WILL ) (4 / 8 Sept 2007)
TA97 C3 Herbert FJ Muller : FREE WILL, UNDER-DETERMINATION OF THINKING, AND PARTICLES (12 / 15 September 2007)
TA97 C4 Sid Barnett : I BELIEVE IN GERSHWIN (10 / 15 September 2007)
TA97 C5 Serge Patlavskiy : ON FREE WILL (30 Sept / 6 Oct 2007)
TA97 C6 Ulrich Mohrhoff : ( FREE WILL ) (13 / 20 October 2007)

RESPONSES by David Hodgson :

TA97 R1 to Serge Patlavskiy : ( FREE WILL ) (21 / 29 September 2007)
TA97 R2 to Ulrich Mohrhoff : ( FREE WILL ) (21 / 29 September 2007)
TA97 R3 to Sid Barnett : ( FREE WILL ) (21 / 29 September 2007)
TA97 R4 to Herbert Muller : ( FREE WILL ) (21 / 29 September 2007)

*******************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 98 :

TA98 by William Byers : GREAT IDEAS (IN MATHEMATICS) (June / 22 September 2007)

COMMENTARIES on TA98 :

TA98 C1 Michael Schleifer : GENERAL COMMENTS (21 / 29 September 2007)
TA98 C2 Joseph McCard : OFFICIAL AND UNOFFICIAL NUMBERS (30 Sept / 6 Oct 2007)
TA98 C3 Herbert FJ Muller : MATHEMATICS, ONTOLOGY, RELIABILITY (30 Sept / 6 Oct 2007)
TA98 C4 Joseph McCard : LOGIC SUPERVENIENT ON CONSCIOUSNESS / SORITES (17 / 20 October 2007)
TA98 C5 Joseph McCard : ( SORITES PARADOX ) (19 / 27 October 2007)
TA98 C6 Ernst vonGlasersfeld : WHAT MATHEMATICS CAN DO ( 2 / 10 November 2007)
TA98 C7 Serge Patlavskiy : IS MATHEMATICS ABLE TO COUNT THE WHOLES ? (4 / 10 November 2007)
TA98 C8 Muller to McCard (C5) : NO HEAPNESS IN ITSELF (21 Nov / 1 Dec 2007)
TA98 C9 McCard to Muller (C8) : ( SORITES ) (29 Nov / 15 Dec 2007)
TA98 C10 Joseph S Johnson : NATURAL ORDER AND THE EVOLUTION OF CREATIVE IODEAS (2 / 12 April 2008)

RESPONSES by William Byers :

TA98 R1 to Michael Schleifer : ( ABSOLUTES ) (4 / 20 October 2007)
TA98 R2 to Joseph McCard : ( OFFICIAL AND UNOFFICIAL NUMBERS ) (20 October 2007)
TA98 R3 to Herbert Muller : ( MIND AND MATHEMATICS ) (31 Oct / 3 Nov 2007)
TA98 R4 to Ernst von Glasersfeld : ( OBSERVER AND OBSERVED ) (12 / 17 Nov 2007)

*******************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 99 :

TA99 by William Byers : THE TRUTH OF MATHEMATICS (June / 17 November 2007)

COMMENTARIES on TA99 :

TA99 C1 Herbert FJ Muller : ON THEORIES OF MATHEMATICS (17 / 24 November 2007)
TA99 C2 Herbert FJ Muller : GORDON PASK ON CONCEPTS, MIND, AND FORMALISM (5 / 26 January 2008)

*******************************************************************************************