TARGET ARTICLE 1

TA1 by Herbert FJ Muller: IS THE MIND REAL ? (27 June 1997)

COMMENTARIES to TA1

TA1 C1 by Paul Jones: ZERO SCIENCE VS HIERARCHICAL SCIENCE (7 July 1997)
TA1 C2 by Dimiter Chakalov: THE UNDEFINABLE MATRIX: IS THE UNIVERSAL MIND REAL ? (16 July 1997)
TA1 C3 by Gary Schouborg: CONTRAST SUBJECTIVE AND OBJECTIVE, NOT SUBJECTIVITY AND OBJECTIVITY (30 July 1997)
TA1 C4 by Mark Seelig: IS THE MIND REAL ? COMMENTS ON A PIVOTAL QUESTION (5 August 1997)
TA1 C5 by H. Mark Hubey: SCIENCE OF PHILOSOPHY (5 August 1997)
TA1 C6 by Joel E. Henkel: MULLER'S INDEFINABLE ENCOMPASSING MATRIX AS ORGANISM EXPERIENCE (12 August 1997)
TA1 C7 (to Response 3) by Christopher J Lofting: A COMMON LANGUAGE (12 Sep 97)
TA1 C8 (to Response 3) by Dimiter G Chakalov: (EXPERIENCE, UNIVERSAL MIND, AND PARTICLE PHYSICS) (16 September 1997)
TA1 C9 (to Response 5) by Christopher J Lofting: NUMBERS, BRAIN, AND SCIENCE (16 October 1997)
TA1 C10 (to Response 7) by Joel E Henkel: (ON EXTRA-CARTESIANISM IN PARTICLE PHYSICS) (25 November 1997)
TA1 C11 (to Response 8) by Christopher John Lofting: WHOLES AND THEIR ASPECTS (27 January 1998)
TA1 C12 (to Response 9) by Joel E Henkel: ISSUES RELATED TO THE EXISTENCE OF MIND-INDEPENDENT REALITY, MIR (8/10 March 1998)
TA1 C13 (to Response 11) by Chris J Lofting: (re. MIR WEIRDNESS AND ITS CORRECTION) (17/24 March 1998)
TA1 C14 (to Response 11) by Joel E Henkel: COMPLETE ELIMINATION OF MIR (24Mar98)
TA1 C15 (to Henkel's C14) by Christopher J Lofting: MIR ELIMINATION AS AN ACT OF REPRESSION (26/31 March 1998)
TA1 C16 by Henry Swift: EXISTENCE WHILE IN QUANTUM MECHANICAL POTENTIA (31 March 1998)
TA1 C17 (to Lofting's C15) by Chris Nunn: ON THE REALITY OF QM POTENTIALITY (1 April/14 May 1998)
TA1 C18 by Hugh Bone: MIND, MATTER, INFORMATION (6 / 18 May 1999)
TA1 C19 by Jan Holmgren : THERE IS A MIND-INDEPENDENT EXTERNAL WORLD (3 / 14 December 1999)
TA1 C20 by Jan Holmgren (to R 14) : STRIVING FOR CONSENSUS (31 December 1999 / 18 January 2000)
TA1 C21 by Jan Holmgren (to R15) : MIND-INDEPENDENT REALITY IS A RATIONAL BELIEF (9 / 22 Febr 2000)
TA1 C22 by Lothane and Holmgren : (ON FREUD, LINNAEUS, WHITEHEAD, DILTHEY) (25 Feb / 14 Mar 2000)
TA1 C23 by Holmgren : WORKING IDEAS OF THE UNIVERSE (2 / 14 March 2000)
TA1 C24 by Holmgren : TO BE, AND TO NOT-BE (18 / 30 May 2000)
TA1 C25 by Mutnick (to Holmgren) : WHITEHEAD'S METAPHYSICAL VIEW OF TIME AND SPACE (2 July / 1 August 2000)
TA1 C26 Adler : IS INTELLECT IMMATERIAL ? (1990 / 23 April 2002)
TA1 C27 van der Meijden : ON ADLER (24 / 30 April 2002)
TA1 C28 Wood on Adler's C26 : ( IS INTELLECT IMMATERIAL ?) (28 April / 7 May 2002)
TA1 C29 Gardner : IT'S OFFICIAL : ADLER FINALLY CONVERTS (2000 / 21 May 2002)
TA1 C30 Wood on Gardner (C29) : RIBBING AND TONGUE IN CHEEK (22 May / 25 June 2002)
TA1 C31 vdMeijden : REVIVALS, REBIRTHS, AND RENAISSANCES (25 March / 2 April 2005)
TA1 C32 vdMeijden : ( MORE TOHU WA BOHU ) (1 / 9 April 2005)
TA1 C33 vdMeijden : TOHU WA BOHU (15 / 23 April 2005)
TA1 C34 vdMeijden : EXPERIENCE IN ART (22 April / 7 May 2005)
TA1 C35 vdMeijden : EXPERIENCE IN ART (18 / 28 May 2005)

RESPONSES by Herbert FJ Muller

TA1 R1 to several commentaries: TERMINOLOGY AND THE CARTESIAN ERROR (12Aug97)
TA1 R2 to Paul Jones (C1): DIALECTICAL MATERIALISM AND THE MIND-REALITY QUESTION (22 August 1997)
TA1 R3 to Dimiter Chakalov (C2): EXPERIENCE, UNIVERSAL MIND, AND PARTICLE PHYSICS (9 September 1997)
TA1 R4 to Gary Schouborg (C3) (contained in C2 to TA2)
TA1 R5 to Mark Seelig (C4): MIND AND SCIENCE (14 October 1997)
TA1 R6 to Mark Hubey (C5): DEFINITIONS, MIND, NUMBERS, AND SCIENCE (28 October 1997)
TA1 R7 to Joel Henkel (C6): THE MIND-BRAIN PROBLEM IS THE RELATION OF EXPERIENCE TO KNOWLEDGE (18 November 1997)
TA1 R8 to Chris Lofting (C7): THE SUBJECT IN PRAGMATISM (9 December 1997)
TA1 R9 to Joel Henkel (C10): ONE-WAY FROM EXPERIENCE TO SCIENCE (10 Febr 1998)
TA1 R10 to Chris J Lofting: STRUCTURES ARE INSIDE-AND-OUTSIDE (10 Mar 98)
TA1 R11 to Joel E Henkel (C12): MIR WEIRDNESS AND ITS CORRECTION (17 March 98)
TA1 R12 to Joel E Henkel's C14: THINKING REQUIRES WORKING METAPHYSICS (14April 1998)
TA1 R13 to Hugh Bone's C18 : WHAT IS INFORMATION ? (5 / 14 December 1999)
TA1 R14 to Holmgren's C19 : PLATONIC METAPHYSICS AS A SPECIAL CASE OF WORKING METAPHYSICS (4 / 21 December 1999)
TA1 R15 to Holgren's C20 : WHITEHEAD, SOLIPSISM, AND MIND-INDEPENDENT REALITY. (10 / 25 Jan 2000)
TA1 R16 to Holmgren's C21 : DIFFICULTIES WITH WORKING METAPHYSICS (18 / 29 February 2000)
TA1 R17 to Holmgren's C23 : STRUCTURING, INVCENTING, AND HAMLET (6 / 14 March 2000)
TA1 R18 to Holmgren's C24 : REALITY-DETECTION VERSUS REALITY BUILDING (12 / 20 June 2000)

*****************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 2

TA2 by Gary Schouborg A METHODOLOGY FOR THE SCIENCE OF CONSCIOUSNESS (17 July 1997)

COMMENTARIES to TA2

TA2 C1 by Paul Jones: THE SCIENCE OF CONSCIOUSNESS AND THE CONSCIOUSNESS OF SCIENCE (12 August 1997)
TA2 C2 by Herbert FJ Muller (also response to C3 of TA1): TO ON OR NOT TO ON (23 September 1997)
TA2 C3 by Christopher J Lofting (also response to C2 above): ON METHODS (30 Sep 97)


************************************************************************************************
**************

TARGET ARTICLE 3

TA3 by Christopher John Lofting: A HEURISTIC DERIVATION OF NEO-CORTICAL FUNCTION (26 August 1997)

COMMENTARY TO TA3

TA3 C1 by V.V. Raman: BRAIN MODES, ILLUSIONS, PERCEPTION (4 Sept 1997)

RESPONSES by Christopher J Lofting

TA3 R1 to V.V. Raman (C1): LOGIC, REDUCTION, ILLUSION, HEMISPHERIC DOMINANCE (4 September 1997)
TA3 R2 to Shlien and Morgan (N 7): (no title) (18 September 1997)

***********************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 4

TA4 by Mark Seelig: TRANSPERSONAL PSYCHOLOGY (4 November 1997)


COMMENTARIES TO TA 4

TA4 C1 by Jonathan Reams: SELF AND IDENTITY: PARADOX OR TRANSCENDENCE ? (27 January 1998)
TA4 C2 by VV Raman: Response to C1 above (3 February 1998)

*************************************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 5

TA5 by Varadaraja V Raman: FROM SIMPLICITY TO HYPERCOMPLEXITY (16 December 1997)

COMMENTARIES TO TA 5

TA5 C1 by J E Henkel: ON CARTESIAN FORMALISM (18 December 1997)
TA5 C2 by P Jones: HIERARCHICAL REALITY AND CONSCIOUSNESS (18 Dec 97)
TA5 C3 by F Abraham: REALITY AS A NON-LOGOCENTRIC, INTERACTIVE, DYNAMICAL PROCESS (6 January 1998)
TA5 C4 by M Hubey: CHAOS AND COMPUTERS (6 January 1998)
TA5 C5 by Christopher John Lofting: FROM 'IN HERE' TO 'OUT THERE' AND BACK (29 Dec 97/13 Jan 98)
TA5 C6 By Christopher John Lofting: (ILLUSION vs OUT THERE) (3 February 1998)

RESPONSES BY VV RAMAN

TA5 R1 to F Abraham: (ON PREDICTABILITY, D BOHM, MULTIPLICITY, AND CHAOS) (6 Jan 1998)
TA5 R2 to CJ Lofting: THE WORLD AS AN ILLUSION (21 January 1998)

************************************************************************************************
***********

TARGET ARTICLE 6

TA6 by Chris Nunn: ARE QUANTUM THEORIES OF CONSCIOUSNESS WORTH BOTHERING ABOUT ? (24 February 1998)

COMMENTARIES TO TA 6

TA6 C1 by CJ Lofting: ARE THE *STRUCTURES* OF QUANTUM THEORIES WORTH BOTHERING ABOUT ? (25 Febr/3 March 1998)
TA6 C2 by VV Raman: TRANSRATIONAL DIMENSIONS OF BRAIN ACTIVITY (25Feb/3March 1998)
TA6 C3 by G Schouborg: INQUIRY INTO CONSCIOUSNESS: SCIENTIFIC OR MINDFUL ? (28 Febr/3March 1998)
TA6 C4 by P Jones: MULTIFORM CONSCIOUSNESS BEYOND THE BRAIN (27Febr/3March98)
TA6 C5 by CJ Lofting (to C4 by Jones): (ON SOCIAL CONSCIOUSNESS) (17Mar98)
TA6 C6 by H Swift: QUANTUM MECHANICS AND CONSCIOUSNESS (17Mar98)

RESPONSE BY C NUNN

TA6 R1 to several commentaries: ON QUANTUM THEORIES OF CONSCIOUSNESS (6/12 May 1998)

**********************************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 7

TA7 by Henry Swift SCIENTIFIC PARADIGM SHIFTS AND THE PRIMACY OF CONSCIOUSNESS
(31 March / 7 April 1998)

COMMENTARIES TO TA7

TA7 C1 by JE Henkel: CRITERIA FOR CHOOSING A NEW PARADIGM (11/21 April 1998)
TA7 C2 by ER Close: CONSCIOUSNESS WITHIN SCIENCE PLUS NEW MATHEMATICS EQUALS TRANSCENDENTAL PHYSICS (19/21 April 1998)
TA7 C3 by VV Raman (to C2): PARADIGM SHIFTS AND CONSCIOUSNESS PHYSICS (26/28 April 1998)
TA7 C4 by JE Henkel (to C3): THE SOCIAL DIFFUSION OF NEW SCIENTIFIC PARADIGMS (3/5 May 1998)
TA7 C5 by R Banerji: SCIENCE WITHIN CONSCIOUSNESS: POSSIBLE OBSTACLES TO A PARADIGM SHIFT (12/19 May 1998)
TA7 C6 by G Schouborg: DIFFERENT ISSUES ABOUT PARADIGMS (12/19 May 1998)
TA7 C7 by ER Close: ON SWC AND TRANSCENDENTAL PHYSICS (10/16 June 1998)
TA7 C8 by R Leonard: CLARIFICATION OF CONCEPTS AND ISSUES CONCERNING SWC PARADIGM (7 June 1998, Part 1 distributed 23 June 1998)

RESPONSE BY H SWIFT


TA7 R1 (to Close): (ON TRANSCENDENTAL PHYSICS) (13/19 May 1998)

**********************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 8

TA 8 by Chris Hooley: WHOLENESS AND THE SOLIPSYSTEM, INVERTING THE WORLD VIEW (14/28 April 1998)

COMMENTARIES TO TA 8

TA8 C1 by JP Verhey: WHEN THE CAT STOPS CHASING ITS OWN TAIL (4/5 May 1998)
TA8 C2 by G Schouborg: INVERSION AS ESCAPISM (8/19 May 1998)
TA8 C3 by H Muller: METHODOLOGICAL SOLIPSISM AND THE FUTURE OF ONTOLOGY (26 MAY 1998)

RESPONSES by Chris Hooley

TA8 R1 (to Schouborg): ON VIEW I AND VIEW II (18 May 1998)
TA8 R2 (to Muller): EXPERIENTIAL RESEARCH AND ATTRACTORS (2/9June 1998)

**********************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 9

TA9 by Joel E Henkel: HOW LIFE LEARNS: AN EPISTEMOLOGICAL BASIS FOR CONSCIOUSNESS
(26 April/12 May 1998, amended 1 June 1999)

COMMENTARIES TO TA 9

TA9 C1 by G Schouborg: EPISTEMOLOGY, ONTOLOGY, PHENOMENOLOGY, AND CONSCIOUSNESS (14/19 MAY 1998)
TA9 C2 by C Nunn: ON QUANTUM CONSCIOUSNESS (15/19 May 1998)
TA9 C3 by HF Alroe: EPISTEMOLOGY, ONTOLOGY, AND METAPHYSICS (28 May/2June 1998)

RESPONSES by JE Henkel

TA9 R1 (to Nunn): ON QUANTUM CONSCIOUSNESS (19 May 1998)

 ************************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 10

TA 10 by Henry Swift: EXPERIMENTAL VALIDATION OF SCIENCE WITHIN CONSCIOUSNESS (13/26 May 1998)

COMMENTARIES TO TA 10

TA10 C1 by C Nunn: (ON A. GOSWAMI'S THEORY) (28 May/2 June 1998)
TA10 C2 by C Nunn: (ON GOSWAMI'S THEORY) (23/30 June 1998)

RESPONSES by Henry Swift

TA 10 R1 (to Nunn): (GOSWAMI'S THEORY) (10/16 June 1998)
TA 10 R2 (to Nunn): (GOSWAMI'S THEORY) (4-7 July 1998)

************************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 11

TA 11 by Herbert FJ Muller: LIMITATIONS OF THE ONTOLOGICAL METHOD (7 July 1998)

COMMENTARIES TO TA11

TA11 C1 by VV Raman: (ON PHYSICAL THEORY) (7/28 July 1998)
TA11 C2 by C Nunn: (SYMMETRY BREAKING: IDEALISM AND MATERIALISM) (9/29 July 1998)
TA11 C3 by ER Close: WHAT IS TRANSCENDENTAL PHYSICS ? (28 July/4August 1998)
TA11 C4 by C Hooley: (MARTIN BUBER AND EXPERIENCE) (29 July/11 August 1998)
TA11 C5 by H Swift: (SCIENCE AND BELIEF) (31 July/11 August 1998)
TA11 C6 by C Lofting (to Close's C3): APPLYING OCCAM'S RAZOR (5/18 August 1998)
TA11 C7 by HF Alroe: THE VIEW FROM SOMEWHERE (9/18 August 1998)
TA11 C8 by JE Henkel: I. ACCESSIBILITY AS A LIMIT TO REALITY, II. STRUCTURED EXPERIENCE (10/25 August 1998)
TA11 C9 (to Close's C3) by C Hooley: (CALCULUS OF EXPERIENCE) (11/25 August 1998)
TA11 C10 (to Hooley's C4) by C Lofting: THE PATH OF EXPERIENCE (16 Aug./1 Sept.1998)
TA11 C11 (to R2 to C2) by C Nunn: (WHITEHEAD, STAPP, AND ONTOLOGY) (26 Aug./1 Sept. 1998)
TA11 C12 (to C3, Close and C6, Lofting) by H Swift: (THE PRIMACY OF CONSCIOUSNESS ACCORDING TO RAMESH BALKESAR) (9/15 September 1998)
TA11 C13 (to R3 and R4:) 4 short commentaries, by C Hooley, C Lofting, EM Stern, A Aguilar (22 September 1998)
TA11 C14 (to Lofting's C6) by ER Close: SHARPENING THE RAZOR. (27 Aug / 17 Sept / 23 Sept 1998)
TA11 C15 (to R3) by ER Close: EXPERIENCE AS THE CONTENT OF CONSCIOUSNESS (29 Sept.1998)
TA11 C16 (to R5 to C5) by Swift: (PHYSICS AND RELIGION) (29 Sept / 6 Oct 1998)
TA11 C17 (to R5 to C5) by Henkel: CONCEPTUAL EXPERIENCE: THE COMMON GROUND OF PHYSICS AND RELIGION (29 Sept / 13 Oct 1998)
TA11 C18 (to the discussion on Science and Religion) by Raman: (see TA 14)
TA11 C19 (to C8/C13 by Henkel/Aguilar) by Lofting: (ON ACCESSIBILITY) (13 / 20 October 1998)
TA11 C20 (to R7) by Henkel: TYPES OF ACCESSIBILITY AND THE CONTRAST BETWEEN MENTAL STRUCTURING PROCESSES: PRESENTATION VS. REPRESENTATION (19 / 27 October 1998)
TA11 C21 (to Raman's C18) by Mikes: (see TA 14)
TA11 C22 (to Raman's C18) by Elkins: (see TA 14)
TA11 C23 (to Raman's C18) by Arons: (see TA 14)
TA11 C24 (to R8) by Nunn: (STAPP AND DESCARTES) (29 October / 10 November 1998)
TA 11 C25 by Swift : ON BOOKS BY R. LEONARD, AND BY N. TRASI (2 / 14 September 1999)
TA11 C26 by Lothane and Bakker : (HERMENEUTICS, PSYCHOANALYSIS, PHENOMENOLOGY) (26 Febr / 21 March 2000)
TA11 C27 by Lothane and Muller : (DILTHEY AND I-THOU) (24 February / 28 March 2000)
TA11 C28 by van der Meijden : (THEORY MAKING VERSUS THEORY) (21 March / 4 April 2000)

RESPONSES by HFJ Muller

TA11 R1 (to Raman): ONTOLOGY IN PHYSICS IS A FACULTATIVE COMMODITY (11 August 1998)
TA11 R2 (to Nunn): ONTOLOGICAL DERAILMENT OF EMPIRICISM (25 August 1998)
TA11 R3 (to Close): THE DIFFICULTY OF MAINTAINING THE FOCUS ON EXPERIENCE (1 Sept.1998)
TA11 R4 (to Hooley's C4): MARTIN BUBER AND THE ORIGIN OF THINKING (8 September 1998)
TA11 R5 (to Swift's C5): INTER-DISCIPLINARY COMMUNICATION: PHYSICS AND RELIGION (22 Sept 1998)
TA11 R6 (to Alroe's C7): UNITY FROM WITHIN EXPERIENCE (29 September 1998)
TA11 R7 (to Henkel's C8, and Aguilar's C13) NEUTRINOS AND KANT'S UNFINISHED OPUS (13 Oct 1998)
TA11 R8 (to Nunn's C11) WHITEHEAD, STAPP, AND NUNN: UNFINISHED BUSINESS IN EMPIRICIST METAPHYSICS (27 October 1998)
TA11 R9 (to Close's C15) POTENTIALITY MEANS HINDSIGHT (AND NIETZSCHE ON MIR) (17 Nov 1998)

***********************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 12

TA 12 by Christopher John Lofting: DICHOTOMOUS ANALYSIS: PROS AND CONS (19 August/15 September 1998)

COMMENTARY to TA 12

TA12 C1 by Mark H Hubey: DICHOTOMOUS ANALYSIS (16/29 September 1998)

***********************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 13

TA13 byThomas J McFarlane: INTEGRAL SCIENCE: TOWARD AN INTEGRAL SCIENCE OF INNER AND OUTER EXPERIENCE (19 Sept / 6 Oct 1998)

COMMENTARIES TO TA13

TA13 C1 by JE Henkel: INTEGRAL CULTURE: A GENERALIZATION THAT ELIMINATES CERTAIN DIFFICULTIES (15 / 20 October 1998)
TA13 C2 by Close: TOWARD A SCIENCE BASED ON THE PRIMACY OF CONSCIOUSNESS (20 / 27 Oct. 1998)
TA13 C3 by Swift: (ON INTEGRAL SCIENCE) (21 October / 10 November 1998)
TA 13 C4 by Sundararajan: FORGET ABOUT THE INNER AND OUTER DISTINCTION, JUST WHAT IS "EXPERIENCE ?" (26 October / 10 November 1998)
TA 13 C5 by Swift (to Henkel's C1) (ON INTEGRAL SCIENCE) (21 Oct / 17 November 1998)
TA 13 C6 by Raman (to C5 to C1) (ON THE RIGHT TO BELIEVE) (17 / 24 November 1998)
TA 13 C7 by Lofting (to Sundararajan's C4) (DESCARTES AND THE DEFINITION OF SCIENCE) (15 / 24 November 1998)
TA 13 C8 by Henkel (to Swift's C5) (ON INTEGRAL SCIENCE) (20 Nov / 1 Dec 1998)
TA 13 C9 by Swift (to Raman`s C6): THE FREEDOM TO BELIEVE (13 / 15 December 1998)
TA 13 C10 by Lofting (to Swift`s C9): SEEKERS OF ILLUSION (15 / 17 December 1998)

TA 13 C11 by Close (to Swift's C9 and Lofting's C10): THE ILLUSION OF SEEKERS (4 / 12 January 1999)
TA 13 C12 by Lofting (to Close's C11): THE SEEKERS OF ILLUSION, PART II (13 / 19 January 1999)
TA 13 C13 by Muller (to McFarlane and Aguilar): CENTRALITY OF EXPERIENCE AND MIR (26 Jan 1999)
TA 13 C14 by Swift (to McFarlane and Lofting): I'LL SEE IT WHEN I BELIEVE IT (22 / 26 January 1999)
TA 13 C15 by Close (to Lofting's C12): PATTERNS OF ILLUSION (29 Jan / 2 Febr 1999)
TA 13 C16 by Raman (to Swift's C14): (PRIMACY OF CONSCIOUSNESS) (26 Jan / 2 Febr 1999)
TA 13 C17 by Lofting (to Swift's C14): THE PROBLEMS OF PRE-COGNITION ( 27 Jan / 9 Febr 1999)
TA 13 C18 by Swift (to R1): SCIENCE ALWAYS CHANGES (27 Jan / 16 Febr 1999)
TA 13 C19 by Banerji : NO POINT ARGUING ABOUT MATERIALISM AND MYSTICISM (3 / 23 Febr 1999)
TA 13 C20 by Lofting (to Close's C15): (ON PATTERNS OF ILLUSIONS) (3 / 9 Febr. 1999)
TA 13 C21 by Lofting (to Raman's C14): (PRIMACY OF CONSCIOUSNESS ?) (3 Febr / 9 March 1999)
TA 13 C22 by Swift (to R3): SCIENTIFIC REVOLUTIONS (14 / 23 March 1999)

RESPONSES by T McFarlane

TA 13 R1 (to Henkel, Close, Swift, and Sundararajan): ISSUES IN INTEGRAL SCIENCE (14 / 24 Nov 1998)
TA 13 R2 (to C5-C11) IS CONSCIOUSNESS PRIMARY ? (18 / 26 January 1999)
TA 13 R3 (to Swift's C18) : SCIENTIFIC REVOLUTIONS AND USEFUL FICTIONS (19 Febr / 2 March 1999)

**********************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 14

TA 14 by Varadaraja V Raman : DEFINITIONS FOR SCIENCE, RELIGION, AND SPIRITUAL QUEST (13 / 20 October 1998)


COMMENTARIES TO TA 14

TA 14 C1 by Mikes : (DEFINITIONS ABOUT HUMAN MENTALITY) (27 Oct / 3 Nov 1998)
TA 14 C2 by Elkins : (DEFINITIONS ON SCIENCE AND RELIGION) (3 Nov 1998)
TA 14 C3 by Arons : (DISTINCTIONS BETWEEN SCIENCE AND RELIGION) (3 Nov 1998)
TA 14 C4 by Morris : (ON RAMAN'S DEFINITIONS ON SCIENCE, RELIGION, AND SPIRITUAL QUEST) (11/17Nov 1998)

TA 14 C5 by Lofting : (Re. SCIENCE, RELIGION, AND THE SPIRITUAL QUEST) (17 Nov / 1 Dec 1998)

RESPONSE BY VV RAMAN

TA 14 R1 to Morris : ON DEFINITIONS OF SCIENCE, RELIGION, AND SPIRITUALITY

*******************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 15

TA 15 by Herbert FJ Muller: HOW DO PHYSICISTS BUILD REALITY ? (19 January 1999)

COMMENTARIES TO TA 15

TA 15 C1 by Henkel: PHYSICISTS BUILD REALITY EPISTEMOLOGICALLY (21 Jan / 2 Febr 1999)
TA 15 C2 by Agapinan: (PHYSICS AND REALITY) (22 Jan / 2 Febr 1999)
TA 15 C3 by Raman: (ON BUILDING REALITY) (23 Jan / 9Febr 1999)
TA 15 C4 by Jones: I DO EXIST. DO YOU ? (25 Jan / 9 Febr 1999)
TA 15 C5 by Nunn: CONSTRUCTION AND QUANTUM CONSCIOUSNESS (25 Jan / 16 Febr 1999)
TA15 C6 by Raman: (ON BUILDING REALITY) (25 Jan / 9 Febr 1999)
TA 15 C7 by Morgenstern: HOW DO CHILDREN BUILD REALITY ? (24 Jan / 16 Febr 1999)
TA 15 C8 by Jones: MATERIALISM AND REFLECTIVITY IN SCIENCE (1 / 9 Febr 1999)
TA 15 C9 by McFarlane: QUANTUM PHYSICS AND REALITY (31 Jan / 23 Febr 1999)
TA 15 C10 by von Glasersfeld : PIAGET'S GENETIC EPISTEMOLOGY (1 / 16 Febr 1999)
TA 15 C11 by Lofting (to Henkel's C1): PHYSICISTS AND LITERAL-MINDEDNESS (3 / 23 Febr 1999)
TA 15 C12 by Close : PHYSICS AND CONSCIOUSNESS (6 Febr / 2 March 1999)
TA 15 C13 by Swift : (HOW DO PHYSICISTS BUILD REALITY ?) (9 Febr / 2 March 1999)
TA 15 C14 by Finkelstein (to Jones' C4&8): EXISTENCE AND MATERIALISM (10 Febr / 9 March 1999)
TA 15 C15 by Henkel (to Raman's C6): EPISTEMOLOGY VS ONTOLOGY (10 Febr / 9 March 1999)
TA 15 C16 by Henkel (to R1): EPISTEMOLOGY AS PROCESS (18 Febr / 16 March 1999)
TA 15 C17 by Lofting (to McFarlane's C9) : QUANTUM PHYSICS : a methodology operating within REALITY (23 Febr / 16 March 1999)
TA 15 C18 by Henkel (to Lofting's C11): THE PHYSICS OF DOUBLE SLIT ELECTRON DIFFRACTION (24 Febr / 23 March 1999)
TA 15 C19 by Raman (to R2): QUESTIONS IN REALITY BUILDING (1 / 23 March 1999)
TA 15 C20 by Raman (to Swift's C13): (HOW DO PHYSICISTS BUILD REALITY ?) (2 March / 6 April 1999)
TA 15 C21 by Jones (to R3) : WE CANNOT ARGUE IF WE DON'T EXIST (4 / 16 March 1999)
TA 15 C22 by Szirko (to Close's C12): CHALLENGE FROM A SUCCESSFUL LOVER (5 March / 6 April 1999)
TA 15 C23 by Morgenstern (to R4): PIAGET'S EPISTEMOLOGY (13 / 30 March 1999)
TA 15 C24 by Schleifer (to R4): PIAGET AND ABSTRACTION (15 / 30 March 1999)
TA 15 C25 by Lofting (to Henkel's C18): THE METAPHYSICS OF THE DOUBLE SPLIT (24 March / 6 April 1999)
TA 15 C26 by vGlasersfeld (to Muller's R1 and Schleifer's C24): (ON PIAGET'S EPISTEMOLOGY) (6 / 13 April 1999)
TA 15 C27 by Close (to Muller's C12 and Szirko's C22) : THE PERSISTENT ILLUSION OF MIR (13 / 20 April 1999)
TA 15 C28 by Henkel (to R8) : (ON REALITY BUILDING) (22 / 27 April 1999)
TA 15 C29 by Szirko (to Close's C27) : BLIND FOR CADACUALTEZ, ANTICHRONISMS DENY THE PSYCHISM'S SEPARATION AND THEIR APTITUDE TO START NEW CAUSAL SERIES IN NATURE (25 April / 11 May 1999)
TA 15 C30 by von Glasersfeld (to R9 and R10) : (ON PIAGET'S EPISTEMOLOGY) (29 April / 11 May 1999)
TA 15 C31 by Morgenstern (to R9 and R10) : (PIAGET'S EPISTEMOLOGY) (18 April / 18 May 1999)
TA 15 C32 by Szirko (to R9) : CONSTRUCTIVISM IS NOT PANTOPOIESIS (30 April / 25 May 1999)
TA 15 C33 by Swift (to Close's C27) : CONSCIOUSNESS AND KNOWING (4 / 25 May 1999)
TA 15 C34 by Szirko (to R11): PALPATING THE HYLOZOIC HIATUS, WE KNOW THE EXTRAMENTALITIES AS THEY RESIST OUR SEMOVIENCE (18 May / 8 June 1999)
TA 15 C35 by Szirko (to Swift's C33) : BLIND FOR CADACUALTEZ, MONPSYCHISMS DENY PERSONAL SEPARATION AND FREEDOM (26 May / 22 June 1999)
TA 15 C36 by McFarlane (to Swift's C33) : FRANKLIN MERRELL-WOLFF'S PHILOSOPHY (27 May / 29 June 1999)
TA 15 C37 by Close (to Szirko's C29) : CADACUALTEZ - A SYNONYM FOR 'UNABLE TO SEE THE WOOD FOR THE TREES' (15 May / 6 July 1999)
TA 15 C38 by Szirko (to Muller's R12&13) : NEGLECT FOR CADACUALTEZ INSTALLS MATERIALISM : HERBERT, NOT MARIELA, IS MATERIALIST (16 June / 20 July 1999)
TA 15 C39 by Szirko (to R14) : (ON HYLOZOISM) and reply : PLAIN TEXT PLEASE (27 July / 24 August 1999)

 RESPONSES by Herbert FJ Muller

TA 15 R1 to Henkel and Agapinan : EXPERIENTIAL PRIORITY (16 Febr 1999)
TA 15 R2 to Raman's C3 and C6: QUESTIONS IN REALITY BUILDING (23 Febr 1999)
TA 15 R3 to Jones (C4&C8) and Nunn (C5) : MATTER AND THE ENTRANCE TO REALITY (2 March 1999)
TA 15 R4 to Morgenstern and von Glasersfeld : PIAGET AND ABSTRACTION (9 March 1999)
TA 15 R5 to McFarlane and Henkel : CONSTRUCTION AND OBJECTIVITY (23 March 1999)
TA 15 R6 to Close and Swift: START FROM INDIVIDUAL EXPERIENCE (30 March 1999)
TA 15 R7 to Raman's C19 : GAMES AND REALITY BUILDING (23 March / 13 April 1999)
TA 15 R8 to Henkel's C16 : REALITY FUNCTION AND BELIEF FUNCTION (16 March / 20 April 1999)
TA 15 R9 to C23 by Morgenstern and C24 by Schleifer : HOW CONSTRUCTIVIST IS PIAGET'S THEORY ? (30 March / 27 April 1999)
TA 15 R10 to C26 by vGlasersfeld : PIAGET'S REALITY (13 / 27 April 1999)
TA 15 R11 to C22 by Szirko : HOW DO YOU KNOW THE UNKNOWABLE ? (14 April / 4 May 1999)
TA 15 R12 to C30-32 by vGlasersfeld, Morgenstern, Szirko : ON PIAGET - and simultaneously : SECOND ANNIVERSARY REQUEST FOR OPINIONS (13 May / 8 June 1999)
TA 15 R13 toC34 by Szirko : EXPERIENCE EMERGES BEFORE MATTER (24 May / 15 June 1999)
TA 15 R14 to C38 by Szirko : NO COMPRENDO (1 / 27 July 1999)

***********************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 16

TA 16 by Paul Jones: IS THERE ANYTHING AT ALL ? (18 Jan / 16 March 1999)

COMMENTARIES TO TA 16

TA 16 C1 by VV Raman: MATERIALISM AND IDEALISM (18 / 19 / 30 March 1999)
TA 16 C2 (also response to Jones' C21 to TA15) by HFJ Muller : THE HARD PROBLEM IS THE WRONG QUESTION (16 March / 13 April 1999)
TA 16 C3 (to Muller's C2) by Lofting : THE HARD PROBLEM : AN EASY ANSWER ? (14 / 20 April 1999)
TA 16 C4 (to Lofting's C3) by Muller : MIND, BRAIN, AND DICHOTOMY (21 April / 11 May 1999)
TA 16 C5 (to Muller's C4) by Lofting: STRUCTURED EXPERIENCE, and Reply by Muller: GOEDEL AND GOD (12 May / 1 June 1999)
TA 16 C6 by von Glasersfeld : COMPREHENSION BEYOND EXPERIENCE ? (1 / 24 August 1999)

RESPONSES by Paul Jones

TA 16 R1 to Raman's C1 : CONSISTENCY AND FREEDOM (6 / 27 July 1999)

***********************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 17

TA 17 by Ernst von Glasersfeld : KNOWING WITHOUT METAPHYSICS: ASPECTS OF THE RADICAL CONSTRUCTIVIST POSITION (1991, posted 4 May 1999)

COMMENTARIES TO TA 17

TA 17 C1 by Nunn : ON CONSTRUCTIVISM (6 / 18 May 1999)
TA 17 C2 by Muller : FUNCTIONS OF METAPHYSICS (13 / 25 May 1999)
TA 17 C3 by Szirko : CONSTRUCTIVISM IS NOT PANTOPOIESIS (30 April / 25 May 1999)
TA 17 C4 by Close : CONSCIOUSNESS - IS IT ALL OR NOTHING ? (9 / 16 May / 1 June 1999)
TA 17 C5 by Morgenstern : ON CONSTRUCTIVISM (24 May / 1 June 1999)
TA 17 C6 by Hooley : ON RADICAL CONSTRUCTIVISM (24 May / 8 June 1999)
TA 17 C7 by Masoni : (TRUTH OF CONSTRUCTIVISM) (6 / 22 June 1999)
TA 17 C8 by Nunn and von Glasersfeld : (AN EXCHANGE ON CONSTRUCTIVISM) (21 June / 27 July 1999)
TA 17 C9 by Muller : ZERO-DERIVATION AND MUTUAL TRANSCENDENCE, with an excursion on the book BELIEF AND RESISTANCE by Barbara Herrnstein Smith (1 July / 3 August 1999)
TA 17 C10 by Jones : (ON CONSTRUCTIVISM) (6 July / 10 August 1999)
TA 17 C11 by Dykstra : RADICAL CONSTRUCTIVISM IN EDUCATION (2 July / 24 August 1999)
TA 17 C12 by Bone (to Jones' C10) : LANGUAGE, MIND, AND GENES (10 / 31 August 1999)
TA 17 C13 by Henkel : RADICAL CONSTRUCTIONISM FROM AN EPISTEMOLOGICAL VIEWPOINT (29 August / 5 October 1999)
TA 17 C14 by Jarvilehto : IS RADICAL CONSTRUCTIVISM RADICAL ENOUGH ? (14 / 28 September 1999)
TA 17 C15 by Yoo : RADICAL CONSTRUCTIVISM IN EDUCATION (22 Sept / 12 October 1999 )
TA 17 C16 by Dykstra : THE MEANING OF 'RADICAL' IN RADICAL CONSTRUCTIVISM (4 / 12 October 1999)
TA 17 C17 by Ingalls : COMPLEX ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS, CONSTRUCTIVIST THERAPIES, AND KENNETH GERGEN'S RELATIONAL SUBLIME (9 / 19 October 1999)
TA 17 C18 by Jarvilehto (to Dykstra's C16) : KNOWING THE WORLD WITHOUT METAPHYSICAL ASSUMPTIONS (14 / 19 October 1999)
TA 17 C19 by Lutterer : ON CONSTRUCTIVISM (15 / 26 October 1999)
TA 17 C20 by Arons and Ingalls : ON CONSTRUCTIVISM (16 / 26 October 1999)
TA 17 C21 by Caughey : HEIDEGGER -- OVERCOMING METAPHYSICS (16 November 1995 / 2 November 1999)
TA 17 C22 by O'Hara, Arons, Ingalls ON CONSTRUCTIVISM (23 Oct / 2 Nov 1999)
TA 17 C24 by Owen : (DIFFICULTIES WITH CONSTRUCTIVISM) (11 October / 9 November 1999)
TA 17 C25 by Muller (to Owen's C24): BUILDING REALITY (4 / 16 November 1999)
TA 17 C26 by Cull : THE ONTOLOGICAL CONSTRUCTION OF TWO WORLDS INTERNAL / EXTERNAL OR RELATIONAL ? (8 / 16 November 1999)
TA 17 C27 by Jarvilehto : TWO MEANINGS OF EXPERIENCE (17 / 29 February 2000)

RESPONSES by Ernst von Glasersfeld

TA 17 R1 to Nunn : CONSTRUCTIVISM DOES NOT CLAIM TO BE 'TRUE', IT MERELY WANTS TO BE USEFUL (6 / 15 June 1999)
TA 17 R2 to Muller : METAPHYSICS IS FINE, BUT I WANT IT APART FROM KNOWLEDGE (10 / 29 June 1999)
TA 17 R3 to Szirko : THE PERILS OF INTERPRETATION (14 June / 6 July 1999)
TA 17 R4 to Close : (CONSTRUCTION IN PHYSICS) : (26 June / 20 July 1999)
TA 17 R5 to Morgenstern : (CONSTRUCTION IN RELIGION AND ARTS) (26 June / 20 July 1999)
TA 17 R6 to Hooley : TWO PATHS AND A COMMON DESTINATION (24 July / 10 August 1999)
TA 17 R7 to Masoni : (DEFINITIONS OF TRUTH) (18 July / 17 August 1999)
TA 17 R8 to Muller : (EXPERIENCE AND METAPHYSICS) (21 August / 7 September 1999)
TA 17 R9 to Jones (C10), Bone (C12), Henkel (C13) : (ON CONSTRUCTIVISM) (26 / 30 November 1999)
TA 17 R10 to Jarvilehto (C14) : (CONCEIVING THE INCONCEIVABLE) (22 Dec 99 / 11 Jan 2000)
TA 17 R11 to Yoo (C15) : CONSTRUCTIVISM IN EDUCATION (24 December 1999 / 18 January 2000)
TA 17 R12 to Lutterer (C19) : ON DEMANDING TOO MUCH FROM REASON (25 Dec 1999 / 25 Jan 2000)

******************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 18

TA 18 by Varadaraja V Raman : ON SCIENTIFIC AND RELIGIOUS TRUTHS (4 May / 15 June 1999)

COMMENTARIES TO TA 18

TA 18 C1 by Muller : FUNCTIONS OF SCIENCE AND OF RELIGION (14 / 29 June 1999)
TA 18 C2 by Mikes : (ON SCIENTIFIC AND RELIGIOUS TRUTHS) (26 June / 6 July 1999)
TA 18 C3 by vGlasersfeld : (CONSTRUCTION IN RELIGION AND ART) (26 June / 20 July 1999)
TA 18 C4 by Jones : HIERARCHICAL TRUTH (26 July / 3 August 1999)
TA 18 C5 by Russell : SCIENCE, CONSCIOUSNESS (AND DARE I SAY IT ? GOD) (April / 31 August 1999)
TA 18 C6 by Mikes (to Russell's C5) : (ON CONSCIOUSNESS) (3 / 7 September 1999)

***********************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 19

TA 19 by Chris Nunn : PHYSICS FROM FISHER INFORMATION (B Roy Frieden) (8 June / 3 August 1999)

COMMENTARIES TO TA 19

TA 19 C1 by Lindley : ON REALISM (10 / 17 August 1999)
TA 19 C2 by Matthews : I IS THE LAW (30 January / 17 August 1999)
TA 19 C3 by Henkel : THE PHILOSOPHY BEHIND THE FISHER INFORMATION APPROACH (28 / 31 August 1999)
TA 19 C4 by Szirko : COMMENTS TO C2 BY MATTHEWS AND TO C3 BY HENKEL (17 / 31 August / 14 September 1999)
TA 19 C5 by Jones : INFORMATION, PHYSICS, AND ANIMAL SUBJECTIVISM (24 August / 6 / 14 September 1999)
TA 19 C6 by Muller : ON REALITY ASSIGNMENT (3 August / 20 / 21September 1999)
TA 19 C7 by Szirko : CURRENT STATE OF OUR DISCUSSIONS ON FRIEDEN'S INCONSISTENT SUBJECTIVISM AND THE REALITY OF PSYCHISM'S PLURALITY AND FINITUDE (22 Sept 1999)
TA 19 C8 by Raman : SOME BRIEF COMMENTS ON ROY FRIEDEN'S BOOK/THESIS (6 / 12 October 1999)
TA 19 C9 by van der Meijden : ON FIRST READING FRIEDEN (12 January / 1 February 2000)

RESPONSES by Nunn and Frieden

TA 19 R1 by Frieden to Henkel's C3 : (ON PHILOSOPHY OF FISHER INFORMATION) (31 August / 7 September 1999)
TA 19 R2 by Frieden to C1, C4, and C5 : WITHDRAW, and Editorial Question : OPEN FORUM ? by Muller (14 / 21 September 1999)

*******************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 20

TA 20 by Joel E Henkel : AQUINAS' TWO LEVELED EXISTENCE : APPLICATIONS TO MODERN SCIENCE (8 June / 27 August / 8 September 1999)

COMMENTARIES to TA 20

TA 20 C1 by Frieden : REMARKS ON HENKEL'S PRESENTATION 'AQUINAS' TWO LEVELED EXISTENCE ... ' (7 / 14 September 1999)
TA 20 C2 by Berezin : CONCEPTUALIZATIONS IN LOWER AND HIGHER LIFE FORMS (7 / 21 September 1999)
TA 20 C3 by Nunn : (ONTOLOGY AND EPISTEMOLOGY) (9 / 28 September 1999)
TA 20 C4 by Muller : EPISTEMOLOGY, CONSTRUCTION, AND MIND (7 / 28 September 1999)
TA 20 C5 by Lofting : DICHOTOMIES, DICHOTOMIES, THEY ALL SAY THE SAME THING (15 Sept / 5 Oct 1999)
TA 20 C6 by Close : HENKEL'S APPLICATION OF AN EPISTEMOLOGICAL APPROACH TO THE PARADOXES OF PHYSICAL SCIENCE IS A STEP IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION (21 Sept / 5 Oct 1999)
TA 20 C7 by Lothane : REMARKS ON HENKEL'S PRESENTATION (19 September / 12 October 1999)
TA 20 C8 by Lofting (to R1 to Berezin) : MEANING ALL THE WAY DOWN ? (22 Sept / 19 Oct 1999)
TA 20 C9 by Muller (to R4) : UNSTRUCTURED BACKGROUND TO REALITY BUILDING (3 / 26 Oct 1999)
TA 20 C10 by von Glasersfeld : WHAT ACCESS TO AN ONTIC WORLD ? (17 / 26 October 1999)
TA 20 C11 by Lothane : (ADLER, FREUD, ALEXANDER) (25 Oct / 9 November 1999)
TA 20 C12 by Muller : THINKING REQUIRES STRUCTURES (10 / 23 November 1999)

RESPONSES by Joel E Henkel

TA 20 R1 to Berezin's C1 : ANIMALS GESTALT RATHER THAN CONCEPTUALIZE (8 / 21 September 1999)
TA 20 R2 to Frieden : THE NATURE OF THE SYSTEM ASSOCIATED WITH INFORMATION (19 / 28 September 1999)
TA 20 R3 to Nunn : (ONTOLOGY AND EPISTEMOLOGY) (29 September / 12 October 1999)
TA 20 R4 to Muller's C4 : (EPISTEMOLOGY, CONSTRUCTION, AND MIND) (29 Sept / 19 Oct 1999)
TA 20 R5 to Lothane : (ON ADLER'S "WHAT MAN HAS MADE OF MAN") (13 Oct / 2 Nov 1999)
TA 20 R6 to Muller's C9 : MIR REQUIRES STRUCTURE (8 / 9 November 1999)
TA 20 R7 to Muller's C12 : HOW MOMENTARY EXPERIENCE IS A FORM OF THINKING (27 / 30 Nov 1999)

***********************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 21

TA 21 by Mariela Szirko : EXCERPTS FROM AVILA & CROCCO'S 'SENSING' (15 June / 4 September / posted 5 October 1999)

**********************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 22

TA22 by Timo Jarvilehto : MENTAL ACTIVITY AND CONSCIOUSNESS IN THE FRAMEWORK OF THE ORGANISM-ENVIRONMENT THEORY (30 August / 2 November 1999)

COMMENTARIES TO TA 22

TA22 C1 by Muller : THE SUBJECT IS NOT AN OBJECT (2 / 9 November 1999)
TA22 C2 by Swift : (SCIENCE WITHIN CONSCIOUSNESS) (3 / 16 November 1999)

TA22 C3 by Henkel : ISSUES ABOUT THE PHYSICAL BASIS OF THE ORGANISM-ENVIRONMENT PICTURE (8 / 16 November 1999)
TA22 C4 by Hooley : (CONSCIOUSNESS IN ORGANISM-ENVIRONMENT THEORY) (11 / 23 November 1999)
TA22 C5 by Henkel (to C1 by Muller) : (INEVITABILITY OF ONTOLOGY ?) (11 / 23 November 1999)
TA22 C6 by Mikes : MIND-BRAIN COMPLEXITY (15 / 30 November 1999)
TA22 C7 by Holmgren : SUBJECTIVIST PRINCIPLE (19 / 30 November 1999)
TA22 C8 by Pockett : (ON CONSCIOUSNESS) (18 November / 7 December 1999)
TA22 C9 by Cull : SUBJECT / OBJECT - RELATIONAL WORLD (26 November / 14 December 1999)
TA22 C10 by Mikes (to R2) : THE MIND AS EMERGENCE (20 / 21 December 1999)
TA22 C11 by Abraham : (COMMENT ON JARVILEHTO'S VIEW) (20 / 21 December 1999)
TA22 C12 by Muller (to Cull's C9) : MATURANA AND SUBJECTIVE EXPERIENCE (22 Dec 99 / 11 Jan 00)
TA22 C13 by Muller (to R1) : SUBJECT AND/OR OBJECT (5 / 18 January 2000)
TA22 C14 by Jones : BETTER LATE THAN NEVER, BETTER SOMETHING THAN NOTHING (10/18 Jan 00)
TA22 C15 by Lothane : (PRIMACY OF I-THOU) (25 January 2000)
TA22 C16 by Fisher : CONSCIOUSNESS IS AN ISLAND (18 Janury / 1 February 2000)
TA22 C17 by Lothane : BUBER, FREUD, AND I-THOU (4 / 15 February 2000)
TA22 C18 by Muller (to C17) : MONADS AND DYADS (6 / 22 February 2000)
TA22 C19 by Muller (to R3) : WHY MORE GENERAL THEORIES (9 / 29 February 2000)
TA22 C20 by Malcolm : THE ORGANISM-ENVIRONMENT AND ROBOT-ENVIRONMENT THEORIES (23 / 28 March 2000)
TA22 C21 by Jones (to Malcolm's C20) : (ORGANISM-ENVIRONMENT AND ROBOT-ENVIRONMENT THEORIES) (10 / 23 May 2000)
TA22 C22 by Jones (to Pockett's C8) (ON DEFINITION OF CONSCIOUSNESS) (10 / 30 May 2000)
TA22 C23 by Jones (to R4) (CONSCIOUSNESS AND MATERIALISM) (15 / 30 May 2000)

RESPONSES by Timo Jarvilehto

TA22 R1 to Muller (C1) : AN ATTEMPT TO TRANSCEND THE SUBJECT-OBJECT DICHOTOMY (29 Nov / 7 Dec 1999)
TA22 R2 to Mikes (C6) and Pockett (C8) : DO WE NEED THE CONCEPT OF EMERGENCE ? (13 / 21 December 1999)
TA22 R3 to Muller (C13) : KNOWING AS EXISTING (22 January / 8 February 2000)
TA22 R4 to Jones : DIALECTICAL MATERIALISM AND ORGANISM-ENVIRONMEENT THEORY (5 - 11 April 2000)
TA22 R5 to Holmgren : DETECTISM AND ORGANISM-ENVIRONMENT THEORY (30 April / 9 May 2000)
TA22 R6 to Malcolm : ROBOTS, ENVIRONMENT AND CONSCIOUSNESS (4 / 16 May 2000)

***********************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 23

TA23 by David Miller : BEING AN ABSOLUTE SKEPTIC (4 June 1999 / 25 January 2000)

COMMENTARIES to TA 23

TA23 C1 by Skoyles : (POPPER'S INSIGHT) (9 July 1999 / 1 February 2000)
TA23 C2 by Roberts : (SKEPTICISM AND RELATIVISM) (9 July 1999 / 8 February 2000)
TA23 C3 by Barnes : (SCIENCE AND PSEUDOSCIENCE) (9 July 1999 / 8 February 2000)
TA23 C4 by Lothane : (POPPER VS GRUNBAUM) (2 / 8 February 2000)
TA23 C5 by Grunbaum : (GRUNBAUM VS MILLER) (2 / 8 February 2000)
TA23 C6 by de Duve : (SCIENCE'S SELF-CORRECTION) (9 July 1999 / 15 February 2000)
TA23 C7 by Kilty : (SCIENCE AND IRRATIONALISM) (9 July 1999 / 15 February 2000)
TA23 C8 by Muller : EMPIRICISTS ARE LAPSED SKEPTICS - WORKING METAPHYSICS CAN HELP (October 1999 / 15 February 2000)
TA23 C9 by Kounaves : LEFT WITH THE TRUTH (13 August 1999 / 22 February 2000)
TA23 C10 by Owen (to C1 by Skoyles) (2 é 22 February 2000)
TA23 C11 by Maxwell : IS MILLER SKEPTICAL ENOUGH ? (4 / 22 February 2000)
TA23 C12 by Wolpert : (PHILOSOPHERS AND SCIENCE) (14 / 29 fEBRUARY 2000)
TA23 C13 by van der Meijden, to deDuve (C6) and Kounaves (C9) (16 / 23 February / 7 March 2000)
TA23 C14 by Muller (to R1) WHY ABSOLUTE TRUTH ? (26 Febr / 7 March 2000)
TA23 C15 by Lothane, van der Meijden, Wolpert : SCIENTISTS AND PHILOSOPHY (posted 14 March 2000)
TA23 C16 by Skoyles : THE RATIONALITY OF NONAUTHORITARIAN GOAL AUTHORITY (12 / 14 March 2000)
TA23 C17 by van der Meijden : (SCIENCE AS A MONOLOGUE BETWEEN REALITY AND THE OBSERVER) (15 / 21 March 2000)
TA23 C18 by van der Meijden (to C16 by Skoyles) : (AUTHORITY, MONEY, AND TARSKI) (16 / 28 MARCH 2000)
TA23 C19 by Lothane (to C15 by van der Meijden) (MAVERICKS AND MUSIC) (March / 4 April 2000)
TA23 C20 by Muller (to R3) TRUTH AND NATURE (19 / 28 March 2000)
TA23 C21 by van der Meijden (to Miller's R3 and Lothane's C19) (22 March / 11 April 2000)
TA23 C22 by van der Meijden : (TRUTH, ABSOLUTE, NOT ETERNAL, NOT CERTAIN) (19 April / 2 May 2000)
TA23 C24 by Mayo : IS THE SKEPTICAL RATIONALIST THE RIGHT MAN FOR THE JOB ? (19 / 25 April 2000)
TA23 C25 by Raman : ( TO BE RATIONAL, IRRATIONAL, ABSOLUTIST, RELATIVIST ) (8 / 22 aUGUST 2000)

RESPONSES by David Miller

TA23 R0 : SKEPTICISM IS NOT RELATIVISM : Response to Skoyles, Roberts, Barnes, deDuve, Kilty (9 July 1999 (Science), posted (with minor changes) 29 February 2000
TA23 R1 to Muller (C8) : ABSOLUTE TRUTH (27 February / 7 March 2000)
TA23 R2 to Grunbaum, Kounaves, Maxwell, Wolpert : POPPER'S PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE (2 / 7 March 2000)
TA23 R3 to Muller, Lothane, van der Meiden, Wolpert, Skoyles : SCIENCE NEEDS GOOD PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE (17 / 21 March 2000)
TA23 R4 to van der Meijden and Muller : THUTH : ABSOLUTE, NOT ETERNAL, NOT CERTAIN (17 / 18 April 2000)
TA23 R5 to Mayo : ANYTHING YOU CAN DO, I CAN DO BETTER (25 July / 8 August 2000)

***********************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 24

TA 24 by Herbert FJ Muller : CONCEPT-DYNAMICS AND THE HISTORY OF REALITY, SUBJECT, AND THE ENCOMPASSING (1 / 24 February 2000 / 7 March 2000) / Quotations and comments / References

COMMENTARIES to TA 24

TA24 C1 by Bausch : (MIND, REALITY, AND SELF-ORGANIZATION (8 / 21 March 2000)
TA24 C2 by van der Meijden (OBJECTION TO MIR) (March 2000 / 11 April 2000)
TA24 C3 by Jarvilehto : ROOTS OF MODERN PSYCHOLOGY (24 March / 4 April 2000)
TA24 C4 by von Glasersfeld : ON SEPARATING KNOWING FROM BEING (22 March / 4 April 2000)
TA24 C5 by Mikes : A VIEW FROM THE MIR (7 / 11 April 2000)
TA24 C6 and C10 by Bone : SELF-ORGANIZATION AND SUBJECTIVITY (9 / 16 / 18 April 2000)
TA24 C7 by Stapp : QUANTUM ONTOLOGY AND MIND-MATTER SYNTHESIS (21 July 1998 / 25 April 2000)
NOTE :
the best version for printing is the Acrobat Format
TA24 C8 by Glanville : (TAKE CONSTRUCTIVISM FARTHER) (16 / 25 April 2000)
TA24 C9 by Mosca : MYTH OF AN INDEPENDENT REALITY (15 April / 2 May 2000)
TA24 C10 by Bone (see C6)
TA24 C11 by Walther : (BEGRIFFS-DYNAMIK UND GESCHICHTLICHE AUFFASSUNGEN VON REALITAET, SUBJEKT, UND DEM UMGREIFENDEN) (30 March-16 April / 2May 2000)
TA24 C12 by Simanonok : ENDOGENOUS LIGHT (20 April / 9 May 2000)
TA24 C13 by von Glasersfeld : KNOWING WHAT WAS SAID MAY NOT BE KNOWING WHAT WAS MEANT (23 March / 9May 2000)
TA24 C14 by Krippner : (CONCEPTS AND EXPERIENCE) (25 April / 23 May 2000)
TA24 C15 by Riegler : MOVING ON WITH CONSTRUCTIVISM (16 / 30 May 2000)
TA24 C16 by Bone to R5 and to Stapp's article (C7) (16 May / 6 June 2000)
TA24 C17 by Bone : SELF AND BRAIN (6 / 20 June 2000)
TA24 C18 by von Glasersfeld (to Muller, Holmgren, Riegler, Walther) : THE CONCEPT OF BEING FROM A ZERO-DERIVATION PERSPECTIVE (14 / 27 June 2000)
TA24 C19 by Sarfatti (to R9) : (POST-QUANTUM PHYSICS) (5 / 27 June 2000)
TA24 C20 by van der Meijden : (THE UNSTRUCTURED GROUND OF EXISTENCE COMES AT BIRTH) (10 May / 4 July 2000)
TA24 C21 by Walther (to Muller (R8) and vGlasersfeld (C18)) : 0-D, METAPHYSICS AND MYSTICISM (to R8), RECOGNITION MATRIX AND VIABILITY, UNDERSTANDING AND REASON (to C18) (22 June / 11 July 2000) and Illustration
TA24 C22 by von Glasersfeld to Walther (C21) : (RECOGNITION MATRICES) (2 / 18 July 2000)
TA24 C23 by Sarfatti : MORE ON QM AND THE SUBJECT (4 July / 1 August 2000)
TA24 C24 by vdMeijden : ( WE DO NOT INVENT EXPERIENCE ) (12 July / 8 August 2000)
TA24 C25 by van der Meiden : ( A NEVER-ENDING JOB ) (15 July / 8 August 2000)
TA24 C26 by Walther : METAPHYSIK GEGEN DENK-UNABHAENGIGE WIRKLICHKEIT (20 July / 8 August 2000)
TA24 C27 by Adams : GETTING SOMETHING OUT OF NOTHING (31 July / 15 August 2000)
TA24 C28 by von Glasersfeld (to Walther's C26) : ( CONSTRUCTION, REALITY, AND ETHICS ) (11 Aug / 5 Sept 00)
TA24 C29 by van der Meijden : (to C27 by Adams) MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING (17 / 29 August 2000)
TA24 C30 by van der Meijden (to R18 to Adams) : (MENTAL STRUCTURE IN THE UNSTRUCTURED) (23 / 29 August 2000)
TA24 C31 by Adams : EXPLANATION AND DIALOG (26 August / 5 September 2000)
TA24 C32 by vdMeijden : ( START FROM ZERO ) (6 / 19 September 2000)
TA24 C33 by Adams to vdMeiden : ON THE INAPPROPRIATENESS OF IRRATIONALITY (4 / 12 December 2000)
TA24 C34 by vdMeijden to Adams : NAMINGS AND KNOWINGS (14 Dec 2000 / 9 Jan 2001)
TA24 C35 by Rifat to vdMeijden (C34) : NOT JUST NAMINGS BUT KNOWINGS ARE NEEDED TOO (10 / 16 January 2001)
TA24 C36 by vdMeijden and Kolos to Rifat (C35) : ( MORE ON AKHENATION ) (17 / 30 January 2001)
TA24 C37 by Kolos : BLAMING MONOTHEISM FOR PSYCHOPATHOLOGY (1 / 20 February 2001)
TA24 C38 by Rifat : BRAIN AS AN INTERFACE "BETWEEN" MATTER AND THE VACUUM (2 / 27 Feb 2001)
TA24 C40 by Rifat (to Kolos) : MONOTHEISM AND MODERN PROBLEMS (1 / 13 March 2001)
TA24 C41 by Archambeault to Rifat and van der Meijden : FROM AKHENATON TO MODERN PSYCHIC DISSOCIATION (8 / 18 September 2001)
TA24 C42 vdMeijden to Archambeault : LANGUAGE DISTORTS (19 / 25 September 2001)
TA24 C43 Rifat to Archambeault : ( DREAM ) (28 Sept / 2 October 20)
TA24 C44 vdMeijden to Archambeault : ( FROM AKHENATON TO MODERN PSYCHIC DISSOCIATION ) (26 Sept / 9 October 2001)
TA24 C45 Rifat to van der Meijden : ( AKHENATON AND DISSOCIATION ) (10 / 23 October 2001)
TA24 C46 van der Meijden to Rifat : ( AKHENATON AND DISSOCIATION ) (24 Oct / 13 Nov 2001)

RESPONSES by Muller

TA24 R1 to Bausch (C1) : SELF-ORGANIZATION AND SUBJECTIVITY (16 / 28 March 2000)
TA24 R2 to Jarvilehto (C3) : CONCEPT-DYNAMICS AND HISTORY (27 March / 11 April 2000)\
TA24 R3 to von Glasersfeld (C4) : THE AMBIGUITY OF METAPHYSICS (3 / 18 April 2000)
TA24 R4 to Stapp (C7) : EXPERIENCE BEFORE QM (17 April / 9 May 2000)
TA24 R5 to Mikes (C5) and Bone (C6 & C10) : TO MIR OR NOT TO MIR (22 April / 16 May 2000)
TA24 R6 to von Glasersfeld (C13) : WHY DO WE INVEST STRUCTURES WITH TRUTH- AND REALITY-BELIEF (24 April / 16 May 2000)
TA24 R7 to Glanville (C8) and Mosca (C9) : HOW TO GET FROM MIR TO 0-D ? (30 April / 23 May 2000)
TA24 R8 to Walther (C11) : THE ENCOMPASSING IS SOURCE, NOT LIMIT (17 May / 6 June 2000)
TA24 R9 to Riegler (C15)_: REALITY, TRUTH, AND LOGIC (5 / 13 June 2000)
TA24 R10 to Simanonok : EXPERIENCE, OBJECTIVITY, AND ENDOGENOUS LIGHT (19 June / 4 July 2000)
TA24 R11 to Sarfatti and Stapp : QM AND THE SUBJECT (26 June / 4 July 2000)
TA24 R12 to Krippner (C14) : CONCEPT-DYNAMICS AND ONTOLOGY (21 June / 11 July 2000)
TA24 R13 to von Glasersfeld : WE DO NOT INVENT EXPERIENCE, BUT WE DO ALL THE STRUCTURING, AND BELIEF DETERMINES CERTAINTY (24 June / 11 July 2000)
TA24 R14 to van der Meijden (C20) : A NEVER-ENDING JOB (29 June / 18 July 2000)
TA24 R15 to Walther (C21) : FORMING CLAY, NOT FISHING IN A POND (6 / 18 July 2000)
TA24 R16 to Sarfatti (C23) : STILL MORE ON QM AND THE SUBJECT (16 July / 8 August 2000)
TA24 R17 to Walther (C26) : BEGRIFFS-DYNAMIK UND DIE DENK-GEHIRN FRAGE (July / 15 August 2000 )
TA24 R18 to Adams (C27) : BUILDING MENTAL STRUCTURES IN THE UNSTRUCTURED (12 / 22 Aug 2000)
TA24 R19 to vdMeijden (C29,30) : START FROM ZERO : (17 August / 5 September 2000 )
TA24 R20 to Adams (C31) : NO NEED FOR MIR IN SCIENCE (28 August / 12 September 2000)

***********************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 25

TA 25 by Jane Cull : IN SEARCH OF THE MIND (1996 / 9 Nov / 7 Dec 1999)

COMMENTARIES to TA 25

TA 25 C1 by Krippendorff : (IN SEARCH OF MIND) (9 / 14 December 1999)
TA 25 C2 by Jones : (REMARK ON TA25 AND C25-C1) (21 December 1999)
TA 25 C3 by Earls : MATURANA AND MCCULLOCH (22 December 1999 / 11 January 2000)
TA 25 C4 by Jones : BETTER LATE THAN NEVER, BETTER SOMETHING THAN NOTHING (10/18 Jan 00)
TA25 C5 by Jarvilehto : MIND, LANGUAGE, AND THINKING (27 March / 4 April 2000)
TA25 C6 by Jarvilehto : IS THE BOUNDARY BETWEEN ORGANISM AND ENVIRONMENT A USEFUL DISTINCTION ? (24 April / 16 May 2000)

RESPONSES by Jane Cull

TA25 R1 to Jarvilehto (C5) : THE MIND AND BEHAVIOR - THE MYTHS AND CONTRADICTIONS (13 / 18 April 2000)
TA25 R2 to Earls (C3) : THE MIND AND STRUCTURAL DETERMINISM (17 / 25 April 2000)
TA25 R3 to Krippendorff (C1) : CIRCULARITY, THE MIND/BRAIN AND BEHAVIOR (17 / 25 April 2000)
TA25 R4 to Jones (ART, SCIENCE, AND METAPHORS) (17 April / 2 May 2000)
TA25 R5 to Muller (re C12 to TA22) : MATURANA AND MULLER (18 April / 30 May 2000)

***********************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 26

TA26 by Amit Goswami : THE HARD QUESTIONS : VIEW FROM A SCIENCE WITHIN CONSCIOUSNESS (1999, posted 18 April 2000)

COMMENTARIES TO TA 26

TA26 C1 by Sarfatti : (TWO MEANINGS OF CONSCIOUSNESS) (19-21 April / 2 May 2000)
TA26 C2 by van der Meijden : (THE HARD QUESTIONS : VIEW FROM A SCIENCE WITHIN CONSCIOUSNESS) and :
TA26 C3 by van der Meijden to Sarfatti's C1 (20 April / 9 May 2000)
TA26 C4 by McFarlane : THE HARD PROBLEM OF SCIENCE WITHIN CONSCIOUSNESS (23 April / 16 May 2000)
TA26 C5 by Banerji : (QUANTUM MENTALITY) (5 / 23 May 2000)
TA26 C6 by Sarfatti (to TA26, also to C2 and 3 by vdMeijden) (9 / 30 May 2000)
TA26 C7 by Sarfatti (to C4 by McFarlane) : (THE HARD PROBLEM OF SCIENCE WITHIN CONSCIOUSNESS) (15 / 30 May 2000)
TA26 C8 by van der Meijden (to McFarlane's C4) : (THE HARD PROBLEM OF SCIENCE WITHIN CONSCIOUSNESS) (18 May / 6 June 2000)
TA26 C9 by Sarfatti and Bekkum (to R1 by Goswami and Cummings) : (CONSCIOUSNESS AND QUANTUM MEASUREMENT) (24 / 30 May 2000)
TA26 C10 by Close : ADVAITA AND MARXIST MATERIALISM AS COMPLEMENTARY VIEWS OF REALITY (25 May / 6 June 2000)
TA26 C11 by McFarlane (to Sarfatti and Bekkum) : NON-DUALITY AND SCIENCE WITHIN CONSCIOUSNESS (30 May / 13 June 2000)
TA26 C12 by van der Meijden : (NONE OF OF CAN GO "OUT THERE") (31 May / 20 June 2000)
TA26 C13 by Sarfatti (to McFarlane's C11) (MONISM AND DUALISM) (13 / 27 June 2000)
TA26 C14 by McFarlane (to R2) : PARADOXES IN GOSWAMI'S MEASUREMENT THEORY (14 / 27 June 2000)
TA26 C15 by Sarfatti to van der Meijden : ( PHYSICS VERSUS METAPHYSICS ) (20 June / 4 July 2000)
TA26 C16 by Rose to Sarfatti, McFarlane, Bekkum (C6,7,9,11,13) : MONISM AND DUALISM (28 June / 11 July 2000)
TA26 C17 by Mutnick (to Goswami, Swift (R2), McFarlane (C4)) : TOWARD A REAL THEORY, ALONG THE PATH OF AMIT GOSWAMI (2 / 18 July 2000)
TA26 C18 by vd Meijden to Sarfatti : MECHANICS OR ZEN ? (8 July / 1 August 2000)
TA26 C19 by Mutnick : CRITIQUE OF HENRY STAPP'S "A QUANTUM THEORY OF MIND" (1/15/22 Aug 2000)
TA26 C20 by Sarfatti : RABBI SARFATTI COMES DOWN FROM DA MAGICK MOUNTAIN (10/18 Aug 2000)
TA26 C21 by Muller (to Mutnick, Stapp, Sarfatti) : CAN YOU WORK WITHOUT STATIC ONTOLOGY ? (21 / 29 August 2000)
TA26 C22 by Sarfatti (to C21 by Muller) ( ANHOLONOMIC FIELD THEORY ) (29 August / 12 September 2000)
TA26 C23 by Jones (to Goswami and Sarfatti) : SCIENCE WITHOUT CONSCIOUSNESS : COLLAPSE OF REASON (1 / 12 September 2000) - Part 1 and Part 2
TA26 C24 by van der Meijden (to Jones' C23) : NO "MUSINGS" THIS ROUND (4 / 19 September 2000)
TA26 C25 by Mutnick (to Muller's C21) : ONTOLOGY SHOULD BE STATIC AND DYNAMIC / EXPERIENCE SHOULD BE ECSTATIC (at some of the time) (2 / 19 Septemner 2000)
TA26 C26 by Muller to C25 by Mutnick : QUANTUM THEORY AND THE MIND (6 / 26 September 2000)
TA26 C27 by Sarfatti to Jones' C23 : ( SCIENCE WITHOUT CONSCIOUSNESS : COLLAPSE OF REASON ) : (13 / 26 September 2000)
TA26 C28 by vdMeijden to Mutnick (C25) : ABOUT MIR (21 September / 3 October 2000)
TA26 C29 by Mutnick : SUMMARY OF MY CREATIVE UNDERSTANDING OF STAPP'S CONJECTURES (23 September / 3 October 2000)
TA26 C30 by Mutnick to Muller : QUANTUM THEORY AND THE MIND (29 September / 10 October 2000)
TA26 C31 by Mutnick to vdMeijden : ABOUT MIR (3 / 10 October 2000)
TA26 C32 by vdMeijden to Mutnick (C31) : ABOUT MIR (4 / 17 October 2000)
TA26 C33 by Muller to Mutnick (C30) : OPERATIONAL METAPHYSICS NEEDED (7 / 17 October 2000)
TA26 C34 by Mutnick to Muller (C33) : ( OPERATIONAL METAPHYSICS NEEDED ) (17 / 24 October 2000)
TA26 C35 by vdMeiden to Muller : ( OPERATIONAL METAPHYSICS ) (19 / 24 October 2000)
TA26 C36 by Muller to Mutnick : MIR SIDE EFFECTS (19 / 31 October 2000)
TA26 C37 by Muller to vdMeijden : OPERATIONAL METAPHYSICS (19 Oct / 7 Nov 2000)
TA26 C38 by vdMeijden to Mutnick : (OPERATIONAL METAPHYSICS) : (25 Oct / 7 Nov 2000)
TA26 C39 by Mutnick to Muller : INQUIRY INTO FOUNDATIONS (2 / 14 November 2000)
TA26 C40 by Muller yo Mutnick : ON MIR-STRUCTURES AND AN ERRONEOUS QUESTION (8 / 21 November 2000)
TA26 C41 by vdMeijden to Muller : ( OPERATIONAL METAPHYSICS ) (8 / 14 November 2000)
TA26 C42 by Muller to van der Meijden : EXPERIENCE AND STRUCTURE (9 / 21 November 2000)
TA26 C43 by Mutnick and Muller : TRANSCENDENCE AND MIR (21 / 28 nOVEMBER 2000)
TA26 C44 by vd Meijden : ( EXPERIENCE, STRUCTURE, AND TIBET ) (22 / 28 November 2000)
TA26 C45 by Muller to vdMeijden : CREATIVITY AND MYSTICISM (22 Nov / 5 Dec 2000)
TA26 C46 by vdMeijden to Muller : ( ON ALTERATIONS AND ECCENTRICITY ) :(19 Dec 2000)


RESPONSES by Goswami and Swift

TA26 R1 to Sarfatti : CONSCIOUSNESS AND QUANTUM MEASUREMENT by Goswami and Comings ( 12 / 23 May 2000)
TA26 R2 to McFarlane (C4) by Swift : (ON SCIENCE WITHIN CONSCIOUSNESS) (22 May / 13 June 2000)

***********************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 27

TA27 by Adrian van der Meijden : METAPHYSICAL MUSINGS (19 April / 6 June 2000)

COMMENTARIES TO TA27

TA27 C1 by Lothane : METAPHYSICAL MUSINGS (20 Febr / 13 June 2000)
TA27 C2 by Hooley : (METAPHYSICAL MUSINGS) (14 / 20 June 2000)
TA27 C3 by Mikes : (LANGUAGE AND CULTURE) (12 / 27 June 2000)
TA27 C4 by Jones : PRACTICAL CONSIDERATIONS (2 / 18 July 2000)

RESPONSES by Adrian van der Meijden

TA27 R1 to Lothane : ( ROADMAPS ) (14 / 21 June 2000)
TA27 R2 to Hooley : ( MUSING ABOUT THE MUSES) (15 June / 4 July 2000)
TA27 R3 to Mikes : MORE TOWARDS HOLISM THAN "SCIENCE" (30 June / 11 July 2000)
TA27 R4 to Jones : (NOTHING EXISTS BY ITSELF) (14 July / 1 August 2000)

***********************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 28

TA 28 by Nicholas Maxwell : CAN HUMANITY LEARN TO BECOME CIVILIZED ? THE CRISIS OF SCIENCE WITHOUT CIVILIZATION (J Applied Philosophy 2000 / posted 1 August 2000) - Part 1 - Part 2 - Part 3


COMMENTARIES to TA 28

TA28 C1 by Wolpert ( CRISIS OF SCIENCE ) 3 / 15 August 2000
TA28 C2 by vdMeijden : ( SCIENCE WITHOUT CIVILIZATION ) : 3 / 15 August 2000
TA28 C3 by Muller : RATIONALITY IS DISCONTINUOUS (26 / 29 August 2000)
TA28 C4 by Swift : WORLD CRISIS AND SCIENCE (27 August / 5 September 2000)
TA28 C5 by Muller, to R2 : RATIONALITY AND MIND-INDEPENDENT REALITY (7 / 26 September 2000)
TA28 C6 by vdMeijden to R2 : THE HARD PROBLEM SOFTENS (19 / 26 September 2000)
TA28 C7 by McHenry : MAXWELL'S PHILOSOPHY OF WISDOM (22 / 26 September 2000)
TA28 C8 vdMeijden to Maxwell : ( SCIENCE WITHOUT CIVILIZATION ) (15 / 24 oCTOBER 2000)
TA28 C9 by Muller : THE PREDICAMENT OF EMPIRICISM : WE DO NOT KNOW NATURE (19 / 30 Oct 2000)
TA28 C10 by Miller : FALSIFICATIONISM IS NOT A VERSION OF STNDARD EMPIRICISM (28/31 Oct 2000)
TA28 C11 by Bone : ( PURSUIT OF WISDOM ) (10 / 23 January 2001)
TA28 C12 by vd Meijden to Maxwell's R6 : THOUGHT RATHER THAN METHOD, PERHAPS ? (11 / 30 Jan 2001)
TA28 C13 by Muller to Maxwell : ONTOLOGY'S DILEMMA (Jan-April 2001 / 24 April 2001)
TA28 C14 by vdMeijden to Maxwell : ( NATURE AND CIVILIZATION ) (17 Jan / 6 Febr 2001)
TA28 C15 by Adams : IN DEFENSE OF SOCIALIZATION (2 / 13 February 2001)
TA28 C16 by vdMeijden to Adams : IN DEFENSE OF SOCIALIZATION (14 Febr / 13 March 2001)

RESPONSES by Maxwell

TA28 R1 to Wolpert : (ON RIVAL THEORIES) (23 / 29 August 2000)
TA28 R2 to Muller (C3) : RATIONALITY IS UNVERSAL (4 / 12 September 2000)
TA28 R3 to vdMeijden : SCIENCE WITHOUT CIVILIZATION (13 / 17 October 2000)
TA28 R4 to Swift : WORLD CRISIS AND THE PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE (10 / 17 October 2000)
TA28 R5 to Muller : RATIONALITY AND MIND-INDEPENDENT REALITY : RESPONSE (15 / 24 October 2000)
TA28 R6 to McHenry (C7) : COMMENTS ON THE PHILOSOPHY OF WISDOM (2 / 9 January 2001)
TA28 R7 to vdMeijden (C8) : CIVILIZATION AND FREEDOM (2 / 16 Janury 2001)
TA28 R8 to Muller (C9) : PURPOSE, RATIONALITY, AND CONJECTURAL KNOWLEDGE OF REALITY (2 / 23 January 2001)
TA28 R9 to Miller (C10) : AIM-ORIENTED EMPIRICISM VERSUS FALSIFICATIONISM (4 / 21 January 2001)

***********************************************************************************************

TARGET ARTICLE 29

TA29 By Ken Bausch : A SELF-REFERENTIAL EPISTEMOLOGY : BEYOND CIRCULARITY TO RIGOR (14 February 2000 / 5 September 2000)

Table of contents of Bausch's book "The Emerging Consensus in Social Systems Theory"

COMMENTARIES to TA 29:

TA29 C1 by Adams : BREAKING THE CIRCLE OF REIFICATION (12 / 19 September 2000)
TA29 C2 by Muller : SOME EXPLORATORY QUESTIONS (August / 19 September 2000)\
TA29 C3 by Muller (to R3) : BOOTSTRAPS AND CIRCLES (1 / 17 October 2000)
TA29 C4 by Adams (to R1 and R2) : SOME ERRORS OF FUNCTIONALISM (23 / 31 October 2000)
TA29 C5 Muller to Bausch (R4) : CHAOS AND THE ENCOMPASSING : (1 / 14 November 2000)
TA29 C6 Muller to Bausch (R6) : WHO ORGANIZES CHAOS ? (29 Nov / 12 Dec 2000)

RESPONSES by Kenneth Bausch

TA29 R1 to Adams (C1) : (THE CIRCLE OF REIFICATION) (26 September / 3 October 2000)
TA29 R2 to Adams (C1) : THE EVOLUTION OF EMBODIED INFORMATION (27 September / 3 October 2000)
TA29 R3 to Muller (C2) : SELF-REFERENTIAL EPISTEMOLOGY (28 September / 10 October 2000)
TA29 R4 to Muller (C3) : CLARIFICATIONS (27 October / 7 November 2000)
TA29 R5 to Adams (C4) : ( ON FUNCTIONALISM, VITALISM, REDUCTIONISM ) (2 / 14 November 2000)
TA29 R6 to Muller (C5) : THE ENCOMPASSING AND RELATED IDEAS (27 Nov / 5 Dec 2000)